Evaluating the Benefits and Risks of Synthetic Bone Graft in Ankle Surgery

Bone graft substitute is used for the ankle joint?

Hello Dr.
Lee, thank you for taking the time to answer my questions.
Recently, I underwent internal fixation and joint reduction surgery for an ankle fracture.
Before the surgery, the attending physician recommended the injection of bone graft material to enhance healing.
In an effort to accelerate bone recovery, I agreed to self-pay for the bone graft.
However, in the past few days, whether searching online or looking at some questions from other patients on the forum, I have not found any cases of bone graft material being used for the ankle.
Does the use of bone graft material really have special benefits, or could it potentially have negative effects? Thank you.

CY, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/09/27

Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics

Hello, in response to your question, I believe your attending physician has suggested the injection of absorbable liquid artificial bone.
This is a very convenient bone substitute for bone defects, much easier and safer than autologous bone grafting or allograft bone transplantation.
The only drawback is that it must be paid out-of-pocket (as it is not covered by health insurance).
If you are interested in finding more information online, you can search for keywords like "injectable artificial bone" or "MIGⅢ" to obtain relevant information.
Additionally, you have the right to be informed about your condition, and you can request your attending physician to provide the brand name or product name of the injectable material, or ask the supplier for further information.
Finally, I wish you a speedy recovery.
Dr.
Li Wen-Lin, Orthopedics, Keelung Hospital.

Reply Date: 2010/09/27

More Info

The use of synthetic bone grafts, such as bone cement or bone putty, in ankle surgery has become increasingly common, particularly in cases involving fractures that require internal fixation and stabilization. The primary goal of using synthetic bone grafts is to enhance the healing process and improve the integration of the bone with the surrounding tissues. However, like any medical intervention, there are both benefits and risks associated with their use.

Benefits of Synthetic Bone Graft
1. Enhanced Healing: Synthetic bone grafts can provide a scaffold for new bone growth, which can facilitate the healing process. They can help bridge gaps in bone and provide structural support, which is particularly beneficial in cases of complex fractures or when there is significant bone loss.

2. Reduced Surgical Time: The use of synthetic grafts can sometimes reduce the time required for surgery, as they may eliminate the need for harvesting autologous bone (bone taken from another site in the patient’s body). This can lead to a quicker recovery and less postoperative pain.

3. Lower Risk of Infection: Since synthetic grafts do not require a second surgical site for harvesting, there is a reduced risk of infection associated with the donor site. This is particularly important in patients who may have compromised immune systems or other risk factors for infection.

4. Consistency and Predictability: Synthetic grafts are manufactured under controlled conditions, which means they can provide consistent results in terms of quality and performance. This predictability can be advantageous in surgical planning.

Risks of Synthetic Bone Graft
1. Biocompatibility Issues: While many synthetic grafts are designed to be biocompatible, there is still a risk of adverse reactions. Some patients may experience inflammation or an immune response to the materials used in the graft.

2. Inadequate Integration: There is a possibility that the synthetic graft may not integrate well with the surrounding bone. This can lead to complications such as non-union (failure of the bone to heal properly) or malunion (healing in an incorrect position), which may necessitate further surgical intervention.

3. Mechanical Failure: Synthetic grafts may not possess the same mechanical properties as natural bone, which can lead to issues under stress. In weight-bearing areas like the ankle, this could result in graft failure or fracture.

4. Long-term Effects: The long-term effects of synthetic grafts are still being studied. Some materials may degrade over time, potentially leading to complications or the need for revision surgery.

Conclusion
In summary, the use of synthetic bone grafts in ankle surgery can offer significant benefits, particularly in terms of enhancing healing and reducing surgical complications. However, it is essential to weigh these benefits against the potential risks. The decision to use synthetic bone grafts should be made collaboratively between the patient and the surgeon, taking into account the specific circumstances of the injury, the patient's overall health, and the surgeon's experience with these materials.

If you have concerns about the use of synthetic bone grafts in your specific case, it would be advisable to discuss these with your orthopedic surgeon. They can provide you with tailored information based on your medical history and the specifics of your ankle injury. Additionally, seeking a second opinion from another orthopedic specialist may also help clarify the best course of action for your recovery.

Similar Q&A

Ankle Fusion vs. Artificial Joint: Which Surgery is Right for You?

Hello Dr. Wang! I have rheumatoid arthritis, and the cartilage in my ankle is severely worn down, leading to deformity and osteoporosis. I have undergone PRP treatment once without any effect. I have a few questions: 1. Should I consider ankle arthroplasty or fusion surgery? Wh...

Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello, with a fusion of the ankle joint, the range of motion is 0, which will definitely affect gait. A prosthetic ankle joint offers a better range of motion; however, if osteoporosis is severe, there is indeed a higher risk of dislocation. Additionally, patients with rheumatic ...

Understanding Tibial Nonunion: The Role of Fibula Grafting Surgery

Hello Dr. You, I was in a car accident on November 26, 2019, which resulted in an open and comminuted fracture of my right tibia. On December 2, 2019, Dr. A performed an intramedullary nailing surgery. To this day, the fracture site has not healed. I have consulted with two other...

Dr. You Dianqi reply Orthopedics
Hello: Online Q&A is not face-to-face medical care, and it can easily lead to misunderstandings; the following is for reference only. The larger the bone defect, the more difficult the healing process, which may require more complex surgeries, such as vascularized fibula graf...

Reinjury After Ankle Ligament Surgery: Autograft vs. Synthetic Options

First question: Three and a half months ago, I underwent surgery for a torn ankle ligament. A few days ago, I fell again while playing in Kenting, and the same ligament has torn again. If I need to have it re-sutured, should I choose autograft or synthetic ligament material? Se...

Dr. Chen Bochen reply Orthopedics
1. Both options are equally good; however, autologous ligament has a longer recovery period but is more durable. It depends on the surgical habits of the physician performing the procedure. 2. A revision surgery is more likely to have sequelae and requires a longer rehabilitation...

Understanding Ankle Adhesions and Lateral Collateral Ligament Reconstruction

Dear Dr. Shi, Two years ago, I was involved in a car accident abroad that injured my left lower limb. Following surgery, I developed an infection, which led to a flap and skin grafting from 10 centimeters above the ankle joint to the knee joint on the inner side of my calf. My t...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Ankle joint adhesions can be diagnosed through arthroscopic examination, which can also be used to perform adhesiolysis. However, since your joint issue has been longstanding, the effectiveness of the procedure is uncertain, but it may be worth trying. After Achilles tendon recon...