Leftward displacement of the spine?
Hello Dr.
Ding: I would like to ask about my father.
Four years ago, he underwent surgery to correct a leftward displacement of his spine, during which two metal screws were inserted.
Since the surgery, he has experienced persistent pain.
During follow-up visits, the doctors assured us that everything was fine.
Recently, we changed hospitals for a check-up and discovered that one of the screws was improperly placed and the other was misaligned.
Initially, the doctor did not admit to this, but later acknowledged it and said he would take responsibility.
However, my father is hesitant to let him perform any further treatment.
Can we apply for compensation, or should we return to him for treatment?
Li Xiansheng, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/11/18
Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery
Your question may not be something we can address here.
We recommend having a thorough discussion with your original physician to better understand the issue.
If you wish to seek advice from another doctor, it is advisable to gather all relevant information beforehand to facilitate the best possible assessment.
Reply Date: 2010/11/18
More Info
I'm sorry to hear about your father's situation. It sounds incredibly challenging and distressing for both him and your family. When it comes to seeking compensation for surgical errors, particularly in spinal surgery, there are several important factors to consider.
First and foremost, it's essential to establish whether there was indeed a deviation from the standard of care during your father's surgery. In medical malpractice cases, the burden of proof typically lies with the patient (or their family). This means you would need to demonstrate that the surgeon's actions fell below the accepted medical standards and that this directly resulted in harm to your father.
In your father's case, the fact that a screw was improperly placed and that this was later acknowledged by the surgeon could potentially support a claim of negligence. However, the specifics of the case matter greatly. You would need to gather all relevant medical records, including the surgical notes, imaging studies, and any follow-up assessments that document the ongoing pain and issues your father has experienced since the surgery.
Consulting with a medical malpractice attorney who specializes in surgical errors is a crucial next step. They can help you understand the legal framework in your state, evaluate the strength of your case, and guide you through the process of filing a claim if you choose to pursue that route. They can also assist in determining whether a settlement might be a more appropriate course of action, especially if the surgeon has already admitted to the error.
Regarding whether your father should return to the same surgeon for further treatment, this is a personal decision that depends on several factors, including your father's comfort level and trust in the surgeon. If he feels uneasy about the surgeon's ability to correct the issue, seeking a second opinion from another qualified spinal surgeon might be wise. This could provide insight into the best course of action for addressing the complications arising from the initial surgery.
In the meantime, it's important for your father to manage his pain and any other symptoms he may be experiencing. This could involve physical therapy, pain management strategies, or other non-invasive treatments that can help improve his quality of life while you navigate the legal and medical aspects of his care.
Ultimately, the decision to pursue compensation or to seek further treatment from the same surgeon should be made carefully, considering both the potential for recovery and the emotional toll that the situation has taken on your family. Open communication with healthcare providers and legal counsel will be key in making informed decisions moving forward.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Lumbar Disc Rupture and Its Impact on Disability Claims
Hello, doctor. I have a question. I underwent surgery for a herniated disc at the lumbar levels L3, L4, and L5 due to a car accident (it has been a year and a half since the surgery, and I am still in rehabilitation). Currently, I have complete numbness and weakness in my left le...
Dr. Lai Zhaokang reply Neurosurgery
Hello: 1. After your injury and surgery, your recovery has not been ideal. This may be due to the severity of the injury prior to surgery. If you wish to reassess whether there is room for adjustment in your treatment, you can obtain copies of your medical records and MRI/X-ray i...[Read More] Understanding Lumbar Disc Rupture and Its Impact on Disability Claims
Understanding Spondylolisthesis: Surgical Options and Recovery Insights
Hello, doctor. My older brother has experienced a spinal slip due to a work injury and often feels pain in his lower back, thighs, and the soles of his feet. He went to the hospital for X-rays and MRI examinations, and the doctor mentioned that surgery is an option for treatment....
Dr. Qiu Yushu reply Neurosurgery
Hello: If an MRI examination shows nerve compression, surgical treatment is the best approach. Generally, health insurance covers this, but some specialized equipment may require out-of-pocket expenses. Neurosurgeon Dr. Yu-Shu Chiu.[Read More] Understanding Spondylolisthesis: Surgical Options and Recovery Insights
Desperate for Medical Help: A Journey Through Orthopedic Challenges
Hello, I was involved in a car accident last year that resulted in a dislocated left clavicle joint and a displacement of the cervical muscles. I also have difficulties with bowel movements, and my left hand cannot move as freely as my right hand. The tension in my neck pulls o...
Dr. Chen Xingyuan reply Orthopedics
Dear Reader, Even after undergoing surgical treatment for an injury, it is inevitable to experience some sequelae. Most of these can be tolerated or improved with the use of medications or rehabilitation therapy. However, it is crucial for you to understand your condition, use c...[Read More] Desperate for Medical Help: A Journey Through Orthopedic Challenges
Understanding Back Injuries: Key Insights on Treatment and Recovery
Hello Dr. Chen, Recently, I was involved in a car accident and the other party is accusing me of negligent injury. They presented a medical certificate stating that due to external force, they suffered a lumbar contusion that requires surgical treatment, and they are demanding ...
Dr. Chen Xingyuan reply Orthopedics
Dear Netizen: Based on what you described, it does seem a bit unreasonable that the other party sustained injuries severe enough to require surgery! However, a lumbar contusion is only a preliminary diagnosis. If surgical treatment is necessary, there must be a more specific diag...[Read More] Understanding Back Injuries: Key Insights on Treatment and Recovery
Related FAQ
(Neurosurgery)
Car Accident(Neurosurgery)
Lumbar Spine(Neurosurgery)
Back(Neurosurgery)
Post-Discectomy(Neurosurgery)
Coccyx(Neurosurgery)
Herniated Disc(Neurosurgery)
Head(Neurosurgery)
Head Injury(Surgery)
Neck(Neurosurgery)