Deep vein thrombosis (DVT)
Recently, my father's left calf has been experiencing mild swelling and pain.
The diagnosis from the venography indicated deep vein thrombosis (DVT).
The doctor has recommended that he take warfarin for six months.
Since my father's pain is not severe and we are concerned about the difficulty in managing the dosage of anticoagulants, we would like to know if it is possible to take nattokinase as a substitute for anticoagulants and then regularly return to the hospital for follow-up examinations.
Thank you!
Qingyuan, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2010/12/01
Dr. Ding Zhizhong reply Cardiology
The recovery from deep vein thrombosis (DVT) is closely related to the initial treatment during the acute phase.
If follow-up examinations still show signs of thrombosis (ultrasound is sufficient and relatively easy to perform), long-term treatment is necessary.
Warfarin is an anticoagulant medication, and for patients with thrombosis, only a low dose is required, unless the patient is pregnant, in which case the risk is not high (of course, regular blood tests are necessary).
It is still recommended to continue taking it.
The effect of natto kinase seems to promote thrombolysis (its actual effect needs further investigation), but it is not included in standard treatment protocols (clinical evidence is insufficient).
Therefore, I cannot comment on it.
It may be better to consult a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner for a more comprehensive answer.
Apologies!
Reply Date: 2010/12/01
More Info
When it comes to treating deep vein thrombosis (DVT), the standard approach typically involves anticoagulant medications, with warfarin being one of the most commonly prescribed. Your father's situation, where he has been diagnosed with DVT and prescribed warfarin for six months, is a common clinical scenario. The concern about the management of anticoagulation therapy, especially regarding dosage and potential side effects, is valid and should be addressed with caution.
Nattokinase, an enzyme derived from fermented soybeans (natto), has been studied for its potential fibrinolytic properties, meaning it may help dissolve blood clots. However, it is essential to note that while some studies suggest that nattokinase may have a mild anticoagulant effect, it is not recognized as a substitute for conventional anticoagulants like warfarin. The clinical evidence supporting the use of nattokinase in treating DVT is insufficient, and it has not been approved by regulatory bodies such as the FDA for this purpose.
Warfarin works by inhibiting vitamin K-dependent clotting factors, which are crucial for the blood coagulation process. It requires careful monitoring through regular blood tests (INR tests) to ensure that the blood's clotting ability remains within a therapeutic range. This is vital because both under-treatment and over-treatment can lead to serious complications, including recurrent thrombosis or bleeding events.
If your father is experiencing mild pain and swelling, it is crucial to communicate this with his healthcare provider rather than attempting to self-manage his condition with nattokinase or any other supplement. The healthcare provider can assess whether the current warfarin dosage is appropriate or if adjustments are needed based on his symptoms and INR levels.
Moreover, switching to nattokinase without medical supervision could pose risks. The interaction between nattokinase and warfarin is not well-studied, and combining these could potentially lead to unpredictable effects on blood coagulation. Additionally, the underlying cause of the DVT should be evaluated, and if there are any risk factors present (such as immobility, recent surgery, or genetic predispositions), these should be addressed in conjunction with anticoagulation therapy.
In summary, while nattokinase may have some potential benefits, it should not be used as a replacement for warfarin in the treatment of DVT. The best course of action is to follow the prescribed treatment plan, maintain regular follow-ups with healthcare providers, and discuss any concerns or side effects experienced during the treatment. This collaborative approach ensures that your father receives the safest and most effective care for his condition.
Similar Q&A
Are There Any Other Precautions When Taking Natto Enzyme?
Are there any other contraindications for consuming natto enzymes?
Dr. Huang Shenggang reply Pharmacology
Natto is rich in vitamin K, which is related to the promotion of blood coagulation (hemostatic effect). For patients taking the anticoagulant Warfarin, it can counteract the effects of the anticoagulant.[Read More] Are There Any Other Precautions When Taking Natto Enzyme?
Managing Deep Vein Thrombosis: Medication Side Effects and Treatment Options
On August 10, I underwent lower limb angiography to confirm deep vein thrombosis. The physician prescribed Warfarin in round pink tablets, with an initial dosage of 0.5 tablets. However, due to elevated blood test results, the dosage was adjusted to 0.3 tablets, taken for two day...
Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology
Hello, You-Wen. Regarding the orthopedic surgery for treating the embolism, it is possible to remove the steel pins during the procedure. There are also various medications available that can be discussed with your physician for a potential change in treatment. Changhua Hospital ...[Read More] Managing Deep Vein Thrombosis: Medication Side Effects and Treatment Options
Natto vs. Lecithin: Which is Better for Preventing Vascular Thrombosis?
Hello Doctor, I am inquiring on behalf of my father, who is 71 years old. Could you please advise which is more effective for preventing vascular embolism: "natto (enzyme)" or "lecithin"? How should one choose between the two? Thank you. My father is currentl...
Dr. Bu Shiyun reply Cardiology
Both of these belong to dietary supplements and have different functions. Taking them together does not cause any conflict, as long as you adhere to the recommended dosage and do not exceed it.[Read More] Natto vs. Lecithin: Which is Better for Preventing Vascular Thrombosis?
Does Nattokinase Really Dissolve Blood Clots? A Neurology Perspective
Is it true that the currently popular natto kinase advertised on the market can dissolve vascular blockages and is it significantly beneficial for related conditions?
Dr. Lai Lunxiang reply Neurology
Hello, I apologize, but this falls under the category of food, which is different from pharmaceutical treatment of diseases. The medical industry cannot critique or make recommendations regarding such items due to liability concerns.[Read More] Does Nattokinase Really Dissolve Blood Clots? A Neurology Perspective
Related FAQ
(Cardiology)
Atrial Fibrillation(Cardiology)
Vein(Cardiology)
Vsd(Cardiology)
Drug Interactions(Cardiology)
Lightheadedness(Cardiology)
Pulmonary Hypertension(Cardiology)
Ablation(Cardiology)
Medication Consultation(Cardiology)
Atrial Septal Defect(Cardiology)