Cranberries for the prevention of kidney stones?
Hello, doctor.
A few days ago, I had a ureteral stone and underwent endoscopic removal.
I've heard that cranberry is good for the urinary system, but I also read online that cranberry is not recommended for those with a tendency to form stones, as it can acidify the urine and potentially worsen the situation.
Is this true?
Niming, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/01/20
Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Hello, if there are any unclear points, feel free to ask again for further discussion and research.
Cranberries can reduce urinary tract infections and are indeed effective for certain types of stones caused by infections.
Cranberries can acidify urine, which helps prevent the growth of most urinary tract bacteria; however, this acidification can also lead to the precipitation of certain components, potentially resulting in stone formation.
For general non-specific stones, there are two main recommendations: 1.
Drink plenty of water: Maintaining a daily urine output of 1500cc will almost eliminate the risk of stone formation (there are nearly 1000 urologists nationwide, and currently, none have experienced stone formation).
2.
Reduce salt intake: The core of most stones is closely related to sodium.
Limit consumption of beverages, broths (such as hot pot or thick soups), and dipping sauces (like chili sauce and soy sauce).
This message is from Dr.
Hsu Wei-Kai, Director of Urology at Taitung Hospital, Department of Health, Executive Yuan, who cares about your health.
Reply Date: 2011/01/20
More Info
Cranberries have long been associated with urinary health, particularly in the prevention of urinary tract infections (UTIs). However, when it comes to kidney stones, the relationship is more complex and nuanced.
Firstly, it is essential to understand the types of kidney stones. The most common types are calcium oxalate stones, uric acid stones, struvite stones, and cystine stones. Each type has different dietary implications. For individuals prone to calcium oxalate stones, dietary oxalate is a significant concern, as high oxalate intake can contribute to stone formation. Cranberries, while beneficial in some respects, are relatively high in oxalates, which could potentially pose a risk for those with a predisposition to this type of stone.
The concern regarding cranberries and kidney stones primarily revolves around their effect on urine pH. Cranberries are known to acidify urine, which can be beneficial in preventing certain types of UTIs but may not be ideal for individuals with uric acid stones. Uric acid stones form in acidic urine, so consuming cranberries could exacerbate this condition by further lowering urine pH. Therefore, for someone with a history of uric acid stones, it would be wise to limit cranberry consumption.
On the other hand, if you have a history of calcium oxalate stones, the situation is a bit different. While cranberries do contain oxalates, the overall impact of cranberry juice on stone formation is still debated. Some studies suggest that moderate consumption of cranberry juice may not significantly increase the risk of stone formation, especially if it is balanced with adequate hydration and a diet low in other high-oxalate foods.
Moreover, cranberries contain compounds that may help prevent the adhesion of bacteria to the urinary tract, which is beneficial for overall urinary health. This property is particularly useful for individuals prone to recurrent UTIs, which can sometimes accompany kidney stones.
In conclusion, whether or not to include cranberries in your diet after experiencing kidney stones largely depends on your specific type of stone and overall dietary habits. If you have a history of uric acid stones, it may be best to avoid cranberries due to their potential to acidify urine. Conversely, if your stones are primarily calcium oxalate, moderate consumption might be acceptable, provided you maintain a balanced diet and stay well-hydrated.
It is always advisable to consult with a healthcare provider or a dietitian who specializes in kidney health to tailor dietary recommendations to your specific needs. They can provide personalized advice based on your medical history, the type of kidney stones you have, and your overall health status. Additionally, they can help you understand the importance of hydration, dietary balance, and other lifestyle factors that play a crucial role in preventing future stone formation.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Kidney Stones: Do Lemon and Cranberry Juice Help?
1. Is calcium oxalate kidney stones caused by an acidic environment in the body? I've heard that drinking cranberry juice can help prevent inflammation, but isn't cranberry acidic? Can it neutralize acidity? 2. Can drinking lemon juice or cranberry juice help prevent ...
Dr. Liu Jianting reply Urology
There are many causes of kidney stones, but it is not solely due to excessive acidity in the body. Individuals who have previously had stones are advised to drink plenty of water, consume more fruits and vegetables, and limit alcoholic beverages. It is also recommended to avoid e...[Read More] Understanding Kidney Stones: Do Lemon and Cranberry Juice Help?
Nutrition Tips: Foods to Avoid for Calcium Oxalate Kidney Stones
1. If kidney stones are identified as calcium oxalate stones, it is advisable to limit the intake of foods high in oxalates. These include spinach, rhubarb, beets, nuts, chocolate, tea, and certain berries. Additionally, reducing sodium and animal protein intake can also be benef...
Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! If calcium oxalate stones are already confirmed, both calcium ions and oxalate in the diet need to be restricted simultaneously, with the latter being more important. Generally, calcium oxalate stones are difficult to control; sometimes, even with strict dietary restrictio...[Read More] Nutrition Tips: Foods to Avoid for Calcium Oxalate Kidney Stones
Post-Surgery Dietary Guidelines: Supplements and Foods to Avoid After Spleen and Pancreas Removal
Due to splenectomy and distal pancreatectomy, the surgeon mentioned that there may be a future risk of developing stones. I would like to ask if it is safe to take cranberry extract capsules (500 mg, purchased from Costco), as I found information online suggesting that excessive ...
Dr. Chen Jiaming reply Surgery
Based on your description, it is unclear why you underwent splenectomy and distal pancreatectomy, so it is also unclear which organ your surgeon was referring to regarding the stones (gallstones? kidney stones? etc.). As for cranberry concentrate tablets, the purpose of your use ...[Read More] Post-Surgery Dietary Guidelines: Supplements and Foods to Avoid After Spleen and Pancreas Removal
Should Calcium Oxalate Stone Patients Avoid Grapes and Cranberry Juice?
Hello, doctor: Should individuals with calcium oxalate stones limit their intake of grapes? I am unsure if the cranberry juice you recommend, which contains grape juice, could negatively affect those with kidney stones.
Dr. Lin Hexing reply Urology
Cranberry juice products are available that do not contain grape juice. You can choose the pure cranberry juice from the brand "Yuxianpei," which is a deep red color, and you won't have to worry about the presence of grape juice.[Read More] Should Calcium Oxalate Stone Patients Avoid Grapes and Cranberry Juice?
Related FAQ
(Urology)
Urinary Tract Stones(Urology)
Stones(Urology)
Cystitis(Urology)
Urine(Urology)
Ureteroscopic Lithotripsy(Urology)
Holding Urine(Urology)
Chronic Kidney Disease(Urology)
Nocturia(Urology)
Urethral Infection(Urology)