the Differences Between Valproate Sodium and Ten-Chuan Tian-Mian - Pharmacology

Share to:

Inquiry about medication?


This medication has a score line in the middle for splitting, and its composition is VALPROATE SODIUM 333 MG + VALPROIC ACID 145 MG.
What is the difference in efficacy compared to taking 600 MG of SODIUM VALPROATE (200 MG each) three times a day?

A-Q, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/04/02

Dr. Qiu Fuqiang reply Pharmacology


Hello, A-Q: The two medications you inquired about are (1) Depakine (sustained-release film-coated tablets, Valproate sodium 333mg, valproic acid 145mg FC Tab) and (2) Valnon E.C Tablets "S.C" (enteric-coated tablets, Sodium valproate 200mg).
Both belong to the class of antiepileptic drugs and have similar pharmacological effects.
However, due to the unique formulations of these two medications (one is a sustained-release film-coated tablet and the other is an enteric-coated tablet), please pay attention to the following administration guidelines: (1) Depakine: This medication is a sustained-release film-coated tablet, so when taking it, please swallow the whole tablet or cut it in half (do not crush or powder it), as it is a long-acting formulation.
(2) Valnon E.C Tablets "S.C": This medication is an enteric-coated tablet, so do not chew it (swallow it whole), as it is a short-acting formulation.
(3) Antiepileptic medications must be taken according to the physician's prescription, and regular liver function tests should be conducted; do not discontinue the medication on your own.

Reply Date: 2011/04/02

More Info


When comparing Valproate Sodium (333 mg) combined with Valproic Acid (145 mg) to Ten-Chuan Tian-Mian (200 mg Sodium Valproate), it is essential to understand that both medications are used primarily as anticonvulsants for the treatment of epilepsy and other neurological disorders. However, there are some differences in their formulations, pharmacokinetics, and clinical implications.


Composition and Formulation
1. Valproate Sodium + Valproic Acid: This combination provides both sodium valproate and valproic acid, which can have different absorption rates and effects in the body. The presence of valproic acid may enhance the overall bioavailability of the medication, potentially leading to more stable plasma levels of the active ingredients.


2. Ten-Chuan Tian-Mian: This formulation contains only sodium valproate. It is typically designed as a sustained-release or enteric-coated tablet, which can affect how the drug is released and absorbed in the gastrointestinal tract.


Pharmacokinetics
- Absorption: The combination of valproate sodium and valproic acid may lead to a quicker onset of action due to the faster absorption of valproic acid. In contrast, sodium valproate alone may have a more prolonged absorption phase, which can lead to a more gradual increase in drug levels in the bloodstream.


- Half-life: Both formulations have a similar half-life, generally ranging from 9 to 16 hours, but the peak plasma concentrations may differ due to the formulation differences. The combination may achieve peak levels more rapidly than sodium valproate alone.


Dosing Considerations
- Daily Dosage: In your case, taking three tablets of Ten-Chuan Tian-Mian (600 mg total) provides a consistent dosage of sodium valproate throughout the day. The combination of Valproate Sodium and Valproic Acid may require careful titration to achieve similar therapeutic levels, especially if the patient is switching from one formulation to another.

- Efficacy: Both medications are effective for seizure control, but the combination may offer advantages in terms of managing breakthrough seizures or achieving better control in patients who have not responded adequately to sodium valproate alone.


Side Effects and Monitoring
- Liver Function: Both medications can affect liver function, so regular monitoring of liver enzymes is crucial. The combination may have a slightly different side effect profile due to the presence of valproic acid, which can be more hepatotoxic in some patients.

- Gastrointestinal Effects: The enteric-coated formulation of Ten-Chuan Tian-Mian may reduce gastrointestinal side effects compared to the combination formulation, which can sometimes cause nausea or vomiting.


Conclusion
In summary, while both Valproate Sodium combined with Valproic Acid and Ten-Chuan Tian-Mian (Sodium Valproate) serve similar therapeutic purposes, their differences in formulation, absorption, and potential side effects may influence clinical decisions. It is essential to follow the prescribing physician's recommendations and monitor for efficacy and side effects when switching between these medications. Always consult with a healthcare provider before making any changes to medication regimens, as they can provide personalized advice based on individual health needs and responses to treatment.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Panic Disorder Treatment: Side Effects and Medication Efficacy

Hello, doctor. I have experienced a relapse of panic disorder for the third time recently. I am currently in the fourth week of treatment with Tianeptine Sodium (Taiwanese brand name: 替你憂-S). At the beginning, taking half a tablet caused side effects such as increased anxiety, he...


Dr. Lin Mianzhang reply Psychiatry
Hello Emily: After taking your medication this time, you are still experiencing occasional panic attacks, which could be due to two possible reasons. First, your panic disorder may have worsened, making the current dosage of your medication insufficient for complete control. Seco...

[Read More] Understanding Panic Disorder Treatment: Side Effects and Medication Efficacy


Switching from Zyprexa to Generic: Will It Affect My Mental Health?

Hello Doctor: I have autonomic nervous system dysfunction, which later developed into panic disorder. My panic disorder has stabilized significantly. The doctor has been prescribing me 10 mg of Entact and half a 0.25 mg of Xanax four times a day to alleviate my symptoms. I have b...


Dr. Xiao Minghong reply Psychiatry
Hello Ms. Ying; both Xanax and Klonopin contain alprazolam, and theoretically, they are classified the same with similar efficacy. However, in clinical practice, there are indeed cases where patients report different effects (either improved or worsened) after switching to a diff...

[Read More] Switching from Zyprexa to Generic: Will It Affect My Mental Health?


Comparing Sleep Medications: Jing An Ning vs. Ke Xian Ping for Insomnia

Is there a difference between "Jing An Ning 0.5mg" and "Clonazepam 0.5mg"? I have taken both for insomnia. If I need to use one of them long-term, which one is less likely to cause withdrawal symptoms?


Dr. Li Zhengfeng reply Psychiatry
Hello: These two medications have similar structures but are not identical. They are pharmacologically similar drugs. Long-term use depends on the individual's constitution to determine which one is more suitable and effective. It is recommended to taper off gradually when d...

[Read More] Comparing Sleep Medications: Jing An Ning vs. Ke Xian Ping for Insomnia


Understanding Autonomic Nervous System Disorders and Functional Gastrointestinal Issues

Thank you for your guidance. I would like to ask you again: (1) Current medication status: I started taking medication on June 11 of this year, originally three times a day. At 10:00 AM: Homagyl 25mg, Diazepam 1mg; at 9:30 PM: Foan 10mg, Homagyl 25mg, Diazepam 1mg. I have been ...


Dr. Chen Wenke reply Psychiatry
I apologize for the delayed response to your inquiry. Here are some references regarding medication reduction methods. Both approaches you mentioned—reducing the dosage or extending the duration of medication use—can achieve the goal of decreasing medication usage. However, it is...

[Read More] Understanding Autonomic Nervous System Disorders and Functional Gastrointestinal Issues


Related FAQ

Drug Interactions

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Drug Side Effects

(Pharmacology)

Dizziness

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Oral Contraceptives

(Pharmacology)

Drug Classification

(Pharmacology)

Drug Interactions

(Pharmacology)

Psychiatric Medications

(Pharmacology)

Weight Loss Products

(Pharmacology)

Medication

(Neurology)

Other

(Pharmacology)