Fistula Diagnosis: Navigating Conflicting Medical Opinions

Re-ask about the fallopian tubes?

Doctor, thank you for your response.
I have been diagnosed at a larger hospital in the city, and I found significant differences in the opinions of three doctors.
The first doctor (Mackay) stated after a colonoscopy that the fistula is severe, crossing the sphincter muscle, and that it would take two months post-surgery for tissue to grow back.
He also advised me to disregard the hemorrhoid issue and focus on treating the fistula, speaking firmly and not allowing me to ask questions about the hemorrhoids.
The second doctor (Cathay) said the fistula is not extensive, and the recovery time after surgery should not be too long.
He provided me with hemorrhoid ointment and instructed me to apply it before scheduling surgery.
This doctor also discouraged me from asking too many questions about the fistula, claiming it was too technical and that I should just follow the surgical protocol.
The third doctor (Department of Health Hospital) stated that he did not see a fistula and suggested it was an ulcer, indicating that surgery was unnecessary.
The differing judgments from these three doctors have caused me considerable distress, and I am unsure whom to trust.
Additionally, some doctors do not allow patients to obtain complete information, which has left me quite disappointed in the doctor-patient relationship, prompting me to seek advice online.
May I ask: Is it difficult to assess a fistula? Why is there such a significant disparity in the doctors' judgments? Should I consider getting a diagnosis from a fourth hospital (such as one in Taipei)?

Mr. Lin, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/04/15

Dr. Hou Yongji reply Surgery

Based on your description, a correct diagnosis cannot be made.
The diagnosis of anal diseases includes medical history, visual examination, digital examination, and even endoscopy (anoscopy, sigmoidoscopy).
If you still cannot agree with the previous physician's diagnosis, you may seek a fourth specialist's opinion.
Thank you.

Reply Date: 2011/04/15

More Info

Understanding the diagnosis of a fistula, especially when faced with conflicting opinions from multiple medical professionals, can be quite challenging and stressful. It’s important to recognize that medical diagnoses, particularly those involving complex conditions like fistulas, can sometimes lead to differing interpretations based on the physician's experience, the diagnostic tools used, and the specific details of the patient's case.

Fistula Diagnosis and Conflicting Opinions
A fistula is an abnormal connection between two body parts, often resulting from inflammation, infection, or surgery. In the context of your situation, the differing opinions from the three doctors you consulted can stem from several factors:
1. Variability in Clinical Experience: Each physician may have different levels of experience and expertise regarding fistulas and related conditions. Some may have a more conservative approach, while others might be more aggressive in their treatment recommendations.

2. Diagnostic Techniques: The methods used to diagnose a fistula can vary. For example, a colonoscopy may provide a direct view of the intestinal tract, but it may not always reveal all fistulas, especially if they are small or located in difficult-to-see areas. Imaging studies like MRI or CT scans can also provide additional information that may not be visible during a colonoscopy.

3. Interpretation of Symptoms: Symptoms can overlap between conditions, such as fistulas and hemorrhoids. The presence of pain, bleeding, or discharge can lead to different interpretations based on the physician's focus and expertise.

4. Communication Style: Some doctors may prioritize a straightforward approach, focusing on what they believe is the most pressing issue, while others may take the time to address multiple concerns, including related conditions like hemorrhoids.

Should You Seek a Fourth Opinion?
Given the significant discrepancies in the opinions you've received, it may be beneficial to seek a fourth opinion, especially from a specialized center or a hospital known for its expertise in gastrointestinal disorders. Here are some steps you can take:
1. Gather All Medical Records: Ensure that you have copies of all relevant medical records, including imaging studies, colonoscopy reports, and any treatments you have undergone. This information will be crucial for any new physician to make an informed assessment.

2. Consider a Specialist: Look for a gastroenterologist or a colorectal surgeon who specializes in fistulas and related conditions. A specialist may have more experience in diagnosing and treating complex cases.

3. Prepare Questions: When you meet with the new doctor, prepare a list of questions and concerns. This will help ensure that you get a comprehensive understanding of your condition and treatment options.

4. Discuss All Symptoms: Be open about all your symptoms, including those related to hemorrhoids, as they may influence the diagnosis and treatment plan.

Conclusion
Navigating conflicting medical opinions can be frustrating, but it is essential to advocate for your health. Seeking a fourth opinion, particularly from a specialist, can provide clarity and help you make informed decisions about your treatment. Remember, it’s your right as a patient to seek the best possible care and to understand your condition fully. Don't hesitate to ask questions and express your concerns during consultations. Your health and peace of mind are paramount, and obtaining a clear diagnosis is a crucial step in your treatment journey.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Fistulas: Seeking Clarity in Surgical Diagnosis

Hello Dr. Ke, in mid-June, I developed a cyst between my anus and scrotum, so I went to a nearby surgical clinic for drainage. After about a week with a dressing, it healed. However, three to four days later, it swelled up again, and I returned to the same surgical clinic for dra...

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
The distinction between a fistula and a sebaceous cyst can only be confirmed through a physical examination. If the condition is still in the acute inflammatory phase, it may be difficult to ascertain, as both the fistula and the internal opening may not be clearly visible at thi...

Exploring Alternative Methods for Diagnosing Anal Fistulas

Doctor, I saw someone on the forum asking, "Is there a high probability of an anal fistula being misdiagnosed as not having one?" and your response was that it is possible. I have the same concern as her, and my issue has been ongoing for a long time. It used to flare u...

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Textbooks mention that magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can be used to diagnose complex anal fistulas, and fistulography is also one of the diagnostic methods. However, both of these diagnostic techniques are utilized for confirming the presence of anal fistulas when the exact tr...

Is It an Anal Fistula? Understanding Urgency for Surgical Treatment

Hello doctor, I would like to ask if this is an anal fistula? If so, I would like to know about the urgency of surgery. Thank you.

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Based solely on photos, it is not possible to definitively diagnose an anal fistula. A necessary condition for diagnosis is the physical examination to feel for a hard fistula tract. It is advisable to consult a colorectal specialist for a thorough examination. While the urgency ...

Determining Anal Fistula: Key Signs and Diagnostic Criteria

Doctor, six months ago I had an abscess on the right side of my anus, which was drained in a proctology clinic. Recently, during a follow-up visit, the doctor said that an anal fistula has formed. I have seen three doctors: one said it is a fistula and noted the presence of disch...

Dr. Lin Zhiguang reply Surgery
If there has been a history of abscess formation, the likelihood of developing an anal fistula is high. Typically, outpatient drainage is not sufficient for a complete cure of the fistula. Surgical intervention is usually required to effectively address the fistula tract. It is r...