Lumbar osteophytes
My wife is 28 years old, and her symptoms are as follows: (1) She experiences occasional sharp pain and swelling in the arch of her right foot when sitting for long periods (this occurs less frequently in more comfortable seating, but is more likely to happen in bus seats).
She does not have any lower back pain and walks normally; (2) She occasionally feels mild electric shock-like sensations or slight tingling in both ankles and calves, but there is no weakness in her foot muscles or sensory loss.
Previously, a neurologist performed an X-ray examination and attributed the first symptom to bone spurs.
She has been undergoing lumbar traction and exercise for about three months, with some improvement (though the first symptom can still occur).
I would like to ask the doctor: (1) Did the previous doctor determine whether the bone spurs are simply due to osteophyte formation or if there are other issues, such as lumbar spinal stenosis? (2) Given her current rehabilitation progress and symptoms, is surgery necessary? (3) Regarding the second symptom, could it potentially be a secondary issue stemming from the first symptom?
Chao Ren, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2011/10/25
Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery
Due to the incomplete information provided, I can only offer general advice.
According to numerous studies, bone spurs and symptoms are often not correlated.
Our surgical approach primarily focuses on decompression and stabilization; generally, bone spurs merely indicate that your spine is experiencing overuse and is undergoing self-repair.
The main issues typically involve herniated discs or spinal stenosis.
Therefore, surgery is not primarily aimed at addressing bone spurs.
Without your specific data, I cannot advise whether surgery is necessary.
If conservative treatment has been effective for you, or if you can accept your current condition, you may consider avoiding surgery.
However, if neurological symptoms worsen, surgery may be considered to resolve the issue, provided that you meet the surgical indications.
Essentially, lumbar spine surgery is considered a quality-of-life procedure, so if you can accept your current quality of life, surgery is not mandatory.
Lastly, I recommend seeking a second opinion; without an in-person consultation, it is impossible to make a diagnosis or provide recommendations for further treatment.
My clinic hours are Monday, Wednesday, and Thursday mornings; if you need further advice, I suggest visiting our clinic for a discussion.
Reply Date: 2011/10/25
More Info
Understanding lumbar bone spurs, also known as osteophytes, is crucial for addressing the symptoms and determining the appropriate treatment options. Your wife's symptoms, particularly the occasional sharp pain and swelling in the arch of her right foot during prolonged sitting, alongside the mild electric-like sensations in her ankles and calves, warrant a thorough evaluation.
1. Understanding Bone Spurs
Bone spurs are bony projections that develop along the edges of bones, often in response to joint damage or degeneration. They are commonly associated with conditions like osteoarthritis, where the cartilage that cushions the joints wears down, leading to increased friction and inflammation. In the lumbar region, bone spurs can form due to degenerative disc disease or spinal stenosis, which is a narrowing of the spinal canal that can compress nerves.
2. Symptoms and Diagnosis
The symptoms your wife is experiencing can be indicative of several underlying issues. The sharp pain and swelling in her foot, particularly when sitting in less supportive seats, may suggest that the position is exacerbating nerve compression or irritation. The absence of back pain and normal walking patterns are positive signs, but the intermittent nature of her symptoms raises concerns about potential nerve involvement.
The previous X-ray findings suggesting bone spurs could indicate that they are contributing to her symptoms. However, it is essential to differentiate whether these are isolated bone spurs or if they are associated with other conditions like lumbar spinal stenosis. An MRI may be warranted to provide a clearer picture of the spinal structures and any potential nerve compression.
3. Treatment Options
Given that your wife has been undergoing traction and exercise therapy for about three months with some improvement, it suggests that conservative management is effective to some extent. Physical therapy can help strengthen the muscles around the spine, improve flexibility, and alleviate pressure on the nerves.
If her symptoms persist or worsen, further intervention may be necessary. Surgical options, such as decompression surgery or laminectomy, may be considered if there is significant nerve compression leading to debilitating symptoms. However, surgery is typically a last resort after conservative treatments have been exhausted.
4. Connection Between Symptoms
Regarding the second symptom of electric-like sensations in her ankles and calves, it is possible that this could be related to the first symptom. Nerve irritation or compression in the lumbar spine can lead to referred sensations in the lower extremities. This phenomenon occurs when the nerves that innervate the foot and leg are affected by issues in the lumbar region.
Conclusion
In summary, your wife's symptoms could be related to lumbar bone spurs, but further diagnostic imaging, such as an MRI, would be beneficial to assess the extent of any spinal issues. Conservative treatments like physical therapy and lifestyle modifications should continue, and if symptoms do not improve, a discussion about surgical options may be warranted. It is crucial to maintain open communication with her healthcare provider to monitor her condition and adjust treatment as necessary.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Lumbar Bone Spurs: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options
Hello Dr. Wang: For about a week, I have been experiencing slight numbness in the tips of my toes and calves. Today, I went to an orthopedic clinic for an X-ray and found out that I have bone spurs in my lumbar spine. The doctor mentioned that this is likely the cause of my sympt...
Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello: In response to your questions, here are the answers: 1. Individuals over the age of 20 may show signs of degenerative diseases such as bone spurs on X-rays. 2. Poor posture and excessive weight-bearing can lead to spinal degeneration and the formation of bone spurs. 3. Per...[Read More] Understanding Lumbar Bone Spurs: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options
Understanding Bone Spurs: Causes, Treatments, and Dietary Tips
Hello, Dr. Hsieh! Recently, my father (50 years old) has been experiencing lower back pain and went to the hospital for an examination. The doctor informed him that he has bone spurs. Could you please explain what bone spurs are, what causes them, and what the correct treatment o...
Dr. Xie Tianjie reply Orthopedics
Generally, bone spurs in the lower back are primarily caused by the spine enduring prolonged pressure or previous injuries, leading to the formation of protruding bony growths next to the bones. Bone spurs can be identified through X-rays; however, there are countless causes of c...[Read More] Understanding Bone Spurs: Causes, Treatments, and Dietary Tips
Understanding Bone Spurs: Impact on Military Life and Treatment Options
I am an active-duty military personnel who has just completed training. Due to pain in my shoulder, I sought medical attention at Taipei Veterans General Hospital. After imaging, the doctor diagnosed me with posterior bone spur syndrome, commonly known as bone spurs. I would like...
Dr. Luo Zhongwei reply Orthopedics
Dear Ah Kai, There are many causes of knee pain. Even orthopedic surgeons may misdiagnose if they are not specialized in sports medicine. I recommend that you visit the Department of Sports Medicine at Taipei Veterans General Hospital to see Director Ma for further evaluation. ...[Read More] Understanding Bone Spurs: Impact on Military Life and Treatment Options
Understanding Bone Spurs: Seeking Effective Treatment for Chronic Pain
Hello Doctor: I was diagnosed with a lumbar bone spur in October 2003 at Linkou Chang Gung Memorial Hospital. However, the physical therapist was unclear about the main cause of my pain, and my attending physician was also unable to provide a correct diagnosis. After less than th...
Dr. Xu Zhenrong reply Rehabilitation
Dear Miss Hsieh, In your letter, you mentioned that in October 2003, an examination at Linkou Chang Gung Memorial Hospital revealed bone spur formation causing lower back pain, and that rehabilitation treatment seemed to have no improvement. In addition to the pain, you also exp...[Read More] Understanding Bone Spurs: Seeking Effective Treatment for Chronic Pain
Related FAQ
(Neurosurgery)
Lumbar Spine(Neurosurgery)
Sciatica(Neurosurgery)
Foot Numbness(Neurosurgery)
Lumbar Fracture(Orthopedics)
Coccyx(Neurosurgery)
Post-Spinal Surgery(Orthopedics)
Cramps(Neurosurgery)
Lower Back Pain(Neurology)
Back(Neurosurgery)