Is Circumcision Necessary? Insights from Urology Experts on Foreskin Restoration - Urology

Share to:

Preputial restoration surgery?


How do urologists view the necessity of circumcision? The procedure is quite expensive, so I'm unsure if it's necessary.
My situation is that due to obesity, my penis is only partially exposed and appears to be retracted towards my abdomen.
I have a complete phimosis that definitely requires surgery.
I've seen some news reports that make me worry about potential mistakes or regrets after the procedure, so I'm uncertain whether to go to a major hospital or a plastic surgery clinic.
I look forward to your response, thank you!

Lurén Jiǎ, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2012/01/16

Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology


Bystander A: Hello, being overweight, the results of a typical circumcision surgery are often not satisfactory.
Personally, I do not advocate for undergoing the procedure.

Reply Date: 2012/01/16

More Info


Circumcision is a surgical procedure that involves the removal of the foreskin from the penis. It has been a topic of debate among medical professionals, particularly in the field of urology, regarding its necessity and benefits. The decision to undergo circumcision can depend on various factors, including medical, cultural, and personal preferences.

From a medical standpoint, circumcision can be beneficial in certain situations. For instance, it may be recommended for individuals who experience recurrent urinary tract infections, phimosis (a condition where the foreskin cannot be retracted), or balanitis (inflammation of the glans). In these cases, circumcision can alleviate symptoms and prevent future complications. Additionally, some studies suggest that circumcision may reduce the risk of sexually transmitted infections, including HIV, and penile cancer, although these risks are relatively low in the general population.

In your specific situation, where you mention having a condition referred to as "full phimosis" and experiencing issues related to obesity, it is essential to consult with a qualified urologist. They can evaluate your condition thoroughly and discuss the potential benefits and risks of circumcision in your case. If the foreskin is causing discomfort or hygiene issues, circumcision may be a reasonable option.

Regarding foreskin restoration, this is a non-surgical approach that some individuals pursue to regain the appearance of a foreskin. Techniques can include the use of devices or manual stretching methods. However, it is crucial to understand that these methods do not restore the original function of the foreskin, and results can vary significantly among individuals. Restoration can be a lengthy process and may not provide the desired outcome for everyone.

The cost of circumcision can vary widely depending on the healthcare facility, the surgeon's expertise, and whether the procedure is deemed medically necessary. If the circumcision is performed for medical reasons, insurance may cover part or all of the costs. However, if it is considered elective or cosmetic, you may be responsible for the entire expense. It is advisable to discuss the financial aspects with your healthcare provider and inquire about payment options or financial assistance programs.

In terms of where to have the procedure done, it is generally recommended to seek care from a reputable urologist or a specialized clinic rather than a cosmetic surgery center. Urologists have the training and experience to handle any complications that may arise during or after the procedure. They can also provide you with comprehensive pre-operative and post-operative care, ensuring a smoother recovery process.

Ultimately, the decision to undergo circumcision should be made after careful consideration and consultation with a healthcare professional. They can help you weigh the potential benefits against the risks and costs involved, guiding you toward the best choice for your individual circumstances. If you have concerns about the procedure or its implications, do not hesitate to express them during your consultation. Open communication with your doctor is key to making an informed decision that aligns with your health needs and personal preferences.

Similar Q&A

Choosing Between Circumcision and Foreskin Restoration: A Guide for Young Men

Hello, I am 20 years old, but I have been hesitant about whether to undergo circumcision or preputial restoration. From the information I've gathered, I understand that circumcision can leave unsightly scars and may involve prolonged pain. I've also seen the benefits of...


Dr. Li Xinyi reply Urology
There seems to be a concept known as "foreskin restoration" online, but there is no definitive literature to support it. In principle, I cannot provide recommendations on this matter. Personally, I do not believe in it, as the portion that is cut off has its blood suppl...

[Read More] Choosing Between Circumcision and Foreskin Restoration: A Guide for Young Men


Circumcision vs. Foreskin Restoration: Which is Better for You?

Hello, doctor... I've been troubled by phimosis for a long time... I would like to ask you, as I've found too much information online and it's hard to distinguish between what's true and what's not. Which treatment would be better? Thank you for your guid...


Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Concern: Hello, we need to examine the type of foreskin to determine whether surgery is necessary. In fact, in most cases, circumcision is not required. If there are any unclear points, feel free to ask again, and we can discuss and research further. This response is from Dr. Hsu...

[Read More] Circumcision vs. Foreskin Restoration: Which is Better for You?


Understanding Foreskin Restoration: Is It Safe and Necessary?

Hello, doctor. My foreskin has always covered the entire glans (at least 95%), even when erect. Does this count as "phimosis"? Is circumcision necessary? Additionally, I've recently heard about a procedure called "foreskin restoration." Is this a safe and...


Dr. Lai Ronghao reply Urology
Hello Mr. Kobayashi: I apologize for my lack of knowledge, as I have not heard of the so-called foreskin restoration surgery, and therefore cannot answer your question. I suggest that if you have any concerns, you should visit a urology clinic for further evaluation.

[Read More] Understanding Foreskin Restoration: Is It Safe and Necessary?


Understanding Phimosis: When Is Circumcision Necessary for Urinary Issues?

According to the payment standards set by the Health Insurance Bureau, the indications for circumcision due to phimosis are as follows: 1. Paraphimosis 2. History of recurrent balanitis 3. Scarring of the foreskin affecting urination or penile erection 4. Foreskin excision requir...


Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Hello, this point depends on the clinical judgment of the physician. Generally, to meet the third criterion, the clinician will find a hard lump on the patient's foreskin, which is scar tissue that appears whiter and is usually not painful. Your situation still needs to be e...

[Read More] Understanding Phimosis: When Is Circumcision Necessary for Urinary Issues?


Related FAQ

Circumcision

(Urology)

Foreskin

(Urology)

Post-Circumcision

(Urology)

Frenulum Of The Foreskin

(Urology)

Foreskin

(Dermatology)

Post-Vasectomy

(Urology)

Masturbation

(Urology)

Pubic Hair

(Urology)

Cryptorchidism

(Urology)

Vas Deferens

(Urology)