Exploring Online Claims of Kidney Disease Remedies: Fact or Fiction? - Internal Medicine

Share to:

The internet is circulating information about dialysis therapy?


Hello Dr.
Wu, I came across a post online regarding a treatment for kidney disease that could allow patients to avoid dialysis.
The original link is: https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=355286714492436&set=a.339031006118007.79174.254704714550637&type=1&ref=nf.
The content is as follows:
A secret to avoid dialysis—spreading this could bring immense merit.
If I had received this secret 25 years ago, perhaps my child would not lament: "Everyone has a mother, but I do not!" My family has been growing lychee for over 50 years, and obtaining lychee seeds is so easy, yet I did not realize it was a treasure.
Even my closest person wasted 14 years on dialysis, ultimately succumbing to the illness.
There are many dialysis patients in Taiwan; perhaps someone around you is undergoing dialysis.
As the author said, "A dead horse is treated as a live horse," there may be those willing to give it a try.
Please share this remedy; saving one person is equivalent to saving a family, which is immensely meritorious! Thank you to everyone who has shared this secret.
Most major hospitals have a "Hemodialysis Room," filled with various tubes of different sizes.
This is where dialysis takes place, where blood is drawn from the body through a vein to a machine that removes waste and harmful substances from the blood.
The first time entering the "Hemodialysis Room," the feelings are a mix of panic and helplessness.
The path to dialysis is primarily due to kidney function failure, leading to an inability to excrete urine.
After a period of catheterization with no improvement, one has no choice but to resort to dialysis.
My kidney function failed mainly due to long-term diabetes.
With a 20-year history of diabetes, I lost interest in life.
There were times I seriously considered ending my life, but then I thought about my children who have not yet established their own families.
I also considered the pain my family and friends would endure if I took my own life.
Although I suffer from illness, if my escape would bring greater suffering to my family, I would bravely continue living with my affliction.
I had a strong aversion to remedies.
For 20 years, I only followed Western medicine's advice, and despite many friends and relatives offering folk remedies, I politely declined them all.
However, after entering the "Dialysis Room," seemingly fighting against death, I suddenly realized that rather than waiting for death, it might be better to try something that could offer a glimmer of hope.

After my second dialysis session, my aunt's family came to visit and asked if I wanted to try a remedy that promised I would no longer need dialysis.
I expressed my willingness to give it a try.
That afternoon, my aunt brought me a pot of kidney soup, which I divided into two servings.
The next day, I drank another pot (about one and a half bowls) and also ate half a pig's kidney.
That day, I noticed an improvement in urination.
On the third day, I was supposed to undergo dialysis again, but after the doctor examined me, he said I could temporarily skip it.
After about a week of drinking the kidney soup, the doctor was astonished to say that my kidney function had gradually improved, and I could be discharged.
The remedy from my aunt's family is: seven fresh lychee seeds, crushed and wrapped in gauze, along with a pig's kidney, sliced thinly, cleaned of the white sinew, placed in a large bowl with two bowls of the second rinse water from rice, and steamed in a rice cooker for about half an hour.
Then, drink the soup all at once for it to be effective.
Personally, I was able to avoid dialysis early thanks to this remedy, which is truly meritorious, and I hope it can help others in similar situations.
I would like to verify the authenticity of this information and seek your assistance in clarifying this matter.
Thank you :) Wishing you all the best.

Lawren, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2012/02/25

Dr. Wu Jiyu reply Internal Medicine


Dear Lawren: Regarding this widely circulated information, Dr.
Wu has also received inquiries about the five principles of medication promotion by the Department of Health: 1.
Do not listen to radio recommendations 2.
Do not believe in miraculous effects 3.
Do not buy from street vendors or night markets 4.
Do not consume medications given by others 5.
Do not recommend to others.
The Nephrology Department of Changhua Hospital cares about you.

Reply Date: 2012/02/25

More Info


The claims regarding remedies for kidney disease, particularly those suggesting that certain foods or concoctions can eliminate the need for dialysis, should be approached with skepticism. While anecdotal evidence, such as personal testimonials, can be compelling, it is essential to rely on scientific evidence and clinical guidelines when evaluating the efficacy of any treatment for kidney disease.

Kidney disease, particularly in its advanced stages, often leads to a significant decline in kidney function, necessitating interventions like dialysis or kidney transplantation. The kidneys play a crucial role in filtering waste products from the blood, regulating electrolytes, and maintaining fluid balance. When kidney function deteriorates, these processes become impaired, leading to a buildup of toxins in the body, which can be life-threatening.

The anecdote you shared about a remedy involving lychee seeds and pig kidneys may sound promising, especially if the individual experienced a temporary improvement in kidney function. However, it is important to note that such improvements could be coincidental or due to other factors, such as changes in diet, hydration, or even the natural fluctuations in kidney function. There is no scientific evidence supporting the idea that consuming specific foods can reverse kidney disease or eliminate the need for dialysis.

In the medical community, treatments for kidney disease are based on extensive research and clinical trials. For instance, managing underlying conditions such as diabetes and hypertension is critical in slowing the progression of kidney disease. Medications, dietary modifications, and lifestyle changes are the mainstays of treatment. In some cases, nephrologists may recommend specific dietary restrictions, such as limiting protein intake or avoiding high-sodium foods, to reduce the workload on the kidneys.

Moreover, the concept of "natural" remedies often leads to the misconception that they are inherently safe or effective. Many natural substances can interact with medications or exacerbate existing health conditions. Therefore, it is crucial for patients to consult with healthcare professionals before trying any new treatment, especially those that are not supported by scientific evidence.

In summary, while the desire to find alternative treatments for kidney disease is understandable, it is vital to approach such claims critically. Relying on anecdotal evidence can be dangerous, as it may lead individuals to forgo proven medical treatments. Patients with kidney disease should work closely with their healthcare providers to develop a comprehensive treatment plan based on evidence-based practices. If you or someone you know is considering alternative remedies, it is advisable to discuss these options with a nephrologist or a qualified healthcare professional to ensure safety and efficacy.

Similar Q&A

Managing Water Intake for Patients with Chronic Kidney Disease

Hello Dr. Wu, My mother has a history of mild stroke, along with mild diabetes, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, high uric acid, proteinuria, and hematuria. Her estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) is currently around 50 and is gradually declining. Aside from controlling her...


Dr. Wu Jiyu reply Internal Medicine
Hello: Regarding your question, we will discuss it in two parts: (1) Based on the information you provided, your mother's estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) of 50 indicates that she is approximately in stage 3 of chronic kidney disease (CKD), which has a total of fi...

[Read More] Managing Water Intake for Patients with Chronic Kidney Disease


Exploring Herbal Remedies for Kidney Health: Myths and Facts

Hello! I would like to ask if it's true that some traditional Chinese medicines have the function of nourishing the kidneys. Thank you!


Dr. Liu Jianting reply Urology
Many people have heard about it, and while we cannot deny that traditional Chinese medicine has its benefits in certain areas, if there are indeed issues with the kidneys, it is best to visit a nephrologist or urologist for an examination. As for maintenance, simply maintaining a...

[Read More] Exploring Herbal Remedies for Kidney Health: Myths and Facts


Can Healthy Individuals Consume Nutritional Supplements for Chronic Kidney Disease?

Hello, Dietitian Huang. My family usually drinks a cup of milk in the morning, but recently they want to try something different. They are looking for a portable package form and found the Yi Fu Yi Neng Chong formula for chronic kidney disease available in portable packets at the...


Dr. Huang Yuru reply Nutrition
Hello, nutritional supplements for chronic kidney disease are one of the options for providing nutrition to patients with kidney disease. They are not recommended for use as regular supplements for individuals without renal dysfunction. Most nutritional products available on the ...

[Read More] Can Healthy Individuals Consume Nutritional Supplements for Chronic Kidney Disease?


Understanding Kidney Issues: Insights on Recovery and Dietary Considerations

Hello, my sister is 29 years old and has a history of refractory epilepsy for 23 years, is a carrier of hepatitis B, and has been diagnosed with schizophrenia for 2 years. She was hospitalized on July 31 due to cellulitis and developed sepsis, requiring intubation in the ICU. On ...


Dr. Wu Jiyu reply Internal Medicine
Based on the data you provided, this condition is classified as "acute kidney injury," which may be caused by cellulitis complicated by sepsis. The key point is that as the infection is brought under control, your kidney function will gradually improve. It is recommende...

[Read More] Understanding Kidney Issues: Insights on Recovery and Dietary Considerations


Related FAQ

Kidneys

(Internal Medicine)

Acute Renal Failure

(Internal Medicine)

Chronic Kidney Disease

(Urology)

Proteinuria

(Internal Medicine)

Kidneys

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Health Supplements

(Internal Medicine)

Hematuria

(Internal Medicine)

Health Report

(Internal Medicine)

Serum Creatinine

(Internal Medicine)

Gout

(Internal Medicine)