Choosing the Right Specialist for Neurological Rehabilitation Needs

Which specialty should I consult?

Recently, the foreign caregiver's contract has expired, and we need to reopen the Barthel Index assessment.
However, during a follow-up visit to the "Rehabilitation Department" of a large hospital, the doctor stated that the patient could walk with assistance and could not provide the assessment.
The elder has an aneurysm that affected the right side of the brain (unlike a typical stroke that severely impacts the limbs), but they still require supervision while walking, often needing to touch walls to understand when to turn, and occasionally turning in the wrong direction.
During the day, they need to wear adult diapers to go out for walks, and if they do not go at a fixed time, they may defecate in the diaper.
When asked questions, if I ask again after a minute, the answers vary! They can provide broad answers but do not give precise responses.
Is this considered adequate rehabilitation? Does this mean they can live independently like a normal person, allowing family members to work without worry? Are we consulting the wrong department to reopen the Barthel Index assessment? Urgent~~~

Hong, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2012/05/28

Dr. Gao Chunde reply Neurology

The Barthel Index is a scale used to assess a patient's overall ability to perform activities of daily living.
You can obtain a copy online, at a service desk, or from an agency to review it yourself.
Additionally, you can evaluate the patient from an impartial and objective perspective.
In the past, a score of 35 or below was required to apply for foreign caregivers; however, in the future, it may be possible to apply for assistance with a score of 60 or below for individuals aged 80 and above, although the start date for this change has not yet been confirmed.
If your evaluation indicates a good chance of qualifying, you may consider consulting a neurologist or another rehabilitation specialist, but it is essential to respect the professional assessment of the physician at that time.

Reply Date: 2012/05/28

More Info

Choosing the right specialist for neurological rehabilitation is crucial, especially when dealing with complex cases such as a patient recovering from a brain aneurysm. In your situation, it seems that the rehabilitation needs are not being adequately addressed by the current healthcare provider. Here are some key points to consider when seeking the right specialist for your loved one’s rehabilitation needs.

Understanding the Condition
First, it’s essential to understand the specific neurological deficits resulting from the brain aneurysm. Damage to the right hemisphere of the brain can lead to various challenges, including difficulties with spatial awareness, balance, and cognitive functions. The symptoms you describe—such as needing assistance while walking, confusion about direction, and issues with bowel control—indicate that the patient may require a comprehensive rehabilitation plan that addresses both physical and cognitive rehabilitation.

Importance of a Multidisciplinary Approach
Neurological rehabilitation often requires a multidisciplinary approach. This means that a team of specialists, including neurologists, physiatrists (rehabilitation physicians), physical therapists, occupational therapists, and speech-language pathologists, should be involved in the patient's care. Each specialist can address different aspects of recovery:
1. Physiatrist: A rehabilitation physician can assess the overall rehabilitation needs and coordinate care among various specialists.

2. Physical Therapist: They can work on improving mobility, balance, and strength, which are crucial for safe ambulation.

3. Occupational Therapist: They can help with activities of daily living (ADLs) and work on cognitive rehabilitation, which may include strategies to improve memory and problem-solving skills.

4. Speech-Language Pathologist: If there are communication or swallowing difficulties, this specialist can provide targeted therapy.

Evaluating the Current Rehabilitation Plan
From your description, it seems that the current rehabilitation plan may not be sufficient. The fact that the patient requires assistance to walk and has significant cognitive confusion suggests that more intensive therapy may be necessary. It’s important to have a thorough evaluation by a specialist who understands the complexities of neurological rehabilitation. If the current rehabilitation physician is not willing to provide the necessary assessments or referrals, it may be time to seek a second opinion.

Seeking the Right Specialist
To find the right specialist, consider the following steps:
1. Research Rehabilitation Centers: Look for rehabilitation centers that specialize in neurological conditions. These centers often have comprehensive programs and a team of specialists.

2. Consult with a Neurologist: A neurologist can provide insights into the specific needs of the patient and recommend appropriate rehabilitation specialists.

3. Ask for Referrals: Speak with other healthcare providers, such as primary care physicians, for recommendations on specialists who have experience with post-aneurysm rehabilitation.

4. Inquire About Assessments: When meeting with potential specialists, ask about their approach to assessing and treating patients with similar conditions. Ensure they are willing to conduct thorough evaluations, including cognitive assessments and functional mobility tests.

Conclusion
In summary, it appears that the current rehabilitation approach may not be adequately addressing the needs of your loved one. A multidisciplinary team that includes specialists in neurology and rehabilitation is essential for developing a comprehensive rehabilitation plan. It’s crucial to advocate for your loved one’s needs and seek out specialists who can provide the necessary assessments and therapies to improve their quality of life. If the current provider is not meeting these needs, do not hesitate to seek a second opinion or explore other rehabilitation facilities that specialize in neurological recovery.

Similar Q&A

Supporting Recovery: When to Involve Rehabilitation for Brain Injury Patients

Hello, Director! My nephew has been suffering from acute encephalitis for nearly a year. He gradually woke up from a coma with a Glasgow Coma Scale score of 4. A few days ago, his attending physician accompanied him home, hoping to stimulate his awakening. Upon returning home, he...

Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
Hello, thank you for your inquiry. Here are my responses and recommendations: 1. You should consult a rehabilitation specialist to learn how to perform joint mobilization (both active and passive), proper positioning in bed and in a wheelchair to reduce muscle spasms, and vario...

Which Specialist to See for Neuroasthenia and Effective Treatments?

Which specialty should I see? What types of treatments are effective? What should I eat to improve my condition?

Dr. Huang Yingzhe reply Neurology
You can see a psychiatrist or a neurologist, and a family medicine physician is also an option. As for treatment, it depends on the description of the condition!

Choosing the Right Specialist for Dizziness and Headaches: ENT or Neurology?

Hello, could you please advise which department a patient should choose for their first outpatient visit based on their condition (ENT, Neurology, or Neurosurgery)? Additionally, what basic tests should be conducted (and are they covered by health insurance)? Do major hospitals i...

Dr. Xu Jiazhen reply Otolaryngology
Hello: In response to your inquiry, please visit the otolaryngology department at major hospitals for evaluation of dizziness. If there are related conditions, you will be referred to a neurologist and other relevant specialties for joint diagnosis and treatment. Thank you.

Confused About Which Specialist to See for Neurological Issues?

Hello doctor, my mother-in-law fell and had brain surgery five years ago. For the first two to three years after the surgery, her movements were slower, but she was still able to move around and take care of herself. However, in the past year, she seems to be gaining more weight ...

Dr. Gao Chunde reply Neurology
A consultation with a neurologist can be considered to assess for cognitive decline in the elderly or other neurodegenerative diseases, or to evaluate if the aforementioned conditions are accompanied by emotional issues. However, it is crucial to first rule out any potential side...