Sciatica: Treatment Options and Recovery Insights

Referred Sciatica Pain

Thank you, Dr.
Shih, for your response! My father experiences numbness in his left foot primarily when standing; he does not have discomfort when sitting or lying down.
He has undergone conservative treatment for the past year and a half, consulting both Western and Traditional Chinese medicine.
He has had numerous sessions of spinal traction and electrical therapy.
Dr.
Hsu from the Department of Orthopedic Surgery at National Taiwan University mentioned that traction has limited effectiveness and that surgery is necessary for correction.
Could you please clarify what you mean by the 90% success rate regarding rehabilitation treatments? When you mention recovery in one to two weeks, are you referring to the healing time after high-frequency thermal therapy? However, I have heard that this is a symptomatic treatment, and some individuals only start to feel improvement after two to three treatment sessions.
Then, after some time (if lucky, it may last nearly a year without recurrence), the sciatic pain returns! I would appreciate any further explanation you can provide.
Thank you.

A-Jia, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2012/11/05

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics

Conservative treatment is effective only in the early stages of a disease.
If there has been a prolonged period of treatment without improvement, surgical intervention should be considered.
There are many surgical options available, but the choice of method depends on the location and nature of the pathology.
However, most patients tend to experience improvement.
You may want to take your father to see a second physician to seek a second opinion.
It is important for the doctor to review the imaging studies and the patient's condition to make an informed judgment.
Spinal surgery, when performed by experts, is not as dangerous as many people might think.
With careful and cautious execution, most procedures yield positive outcomes.

Reply Date: 2012/11/05

More Info

Sciatica, characterized by pain radiating along the path of the sciatic nerve, typically manifests in the lower back, buttocks, and down one leg. It can result from various underlying conditions, including herniated discs, spinal stenosis, or degenerative disc disease. The symptoms can range from mild discomfort to severe pain, often accompanied by numbness, tingling, or weakness in the affected leg.
In your father's case, the left leg numbness primarily occurring while standing suggests a possible mechanical issue, such as nerve compression or irritation, which may not be as pronounced in seated or lying positions. This is a common presentation in sciatica, where certain postures alleviate or exacerbate symptoms.

Regarding treatment options, conservative management is often the first line of approach. This includes physical therapy, medication (such as NSAIDs for pain relief), and alternative therapies like acupuncture or chiropractic adjustments. Physical therapy typically focuses on exercises to strengthen the core and back muscles, improve flexibility, and promote proper posture. Modalities like heat therapy, electrical stimulation, and ultrasound can also be beneficial in reducing pain and inflammation.

You mentioned that your father has undergone numerous sessions of physical therapy, including traction and electrical stimulation, without significant improvement. While these treatments can be effective for some, they may not provide relief for everyone, particularly if there is a structural issue that requires more invasive intervention.

Dr. Hsu's recommendation for surgery may be warranted if conservative treatments fail and if imaging studies (like MRI) indicate a significant structural problem, such as a herniated disc pressing on the sciatic nerve. Surgical options can include discectomy (removal of the herniated portion of the disc) or laminectomy (removal of part of the vertebra to relieve pressure on the nerve). The success rate of these surgeries can be high, often cited around 90%, particularly for patients with clear indications for surgery.

The recovery time post-surgery can vary. While some patients may experience relief within a few weeks, others may take longer to heal fully. The mention of "high-frequency thermal therapy" likely refers to a specific modality used in physical therapy to promote healing and reduce pain. This treatment can be beneficial in the postoperative phase to manage pain and facilitate recovery, but it is not a substitute for addressing the underlying issue.

It's important to note that while surgery can provide significant relief, it does not guarantee that symptoms will not return. Some patients may experience recurrent sciatica due to ongoing degenerative changes in the spine or other factors. Therefore, a comprehensive rehabilitation program post-surgery is crucial to strengthen the back and prevent future episodes.

In conclusion, if your father has not found relief through conservative measures, it may be time to consider surgical options, especially if imaging studies support this course of action. Post-surgical rehabilitation will play a vital role in recovery and long-term management of sciatica. It is essential to maintain open communication with healthcare providers to ensure that all treatment options are thoroughly discussed and tailored to your father's specific needs.

Similar Q&A

Effective Rehabilitation Treatments for Sciatica Pain Relief

Hello, Doctor: What rehabilitation treatments are available for sciatica? Is recovery possible? Thank you!

Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
Hello, sir: Thank you for your inquiry. I would like to respond to your question and provide the following suggestions: 1. Sciatica is usually caused by a herniated disc or bone spurs that compress the nerve. If the compression is excessive, leading to decreased muscle strength...

Effective Treatments for Sciatic Nerve Pain: Affordable Solutions

How can sciatica be treated? Can you help me with some methods that don't require spending money?

Dr. Zhang Yuanyi reply Neurosurgery
Dear Mr. Yang, Sciatica is generally caused by nerve compression due to a herniated disc or complications from spinal stenosis. It is important to pay attention to posture and consider using a lumbar support for health maintenance. Treatment options may include physical therapy ...

Understanding Sciatica: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options

Hello, Director Shi: About three years ago, I started experiencing a sharp pain that extends down my left buttock. At first, I didn't think much of it. However, recently, I have been experiencing severe pain when bending over or lifting my leg. I went to a nearby hospital fo...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
If sciatica has just occurred within a few weeks, conservative treatment can be adopted. Conservative treatment refers to medication combined with rehabilitation, and most patients can recover. If there is no improvement after more than a month of conservative treatment, further ...

Alternative Treatments for Sciatica: Beyond Surgery Options Explained

Doctor: Hello, is surgery the only way to cure sciatica? Are there other methods? I have had spinal displacement due to a car accident for several years now and have been relying on acupuncture and manual therapy from a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner to alleviate the p...

Dr. Xiao Furen reply Neurosurgery
Sciatica is actually a symptom, and it is important to identify the underlying cause. In your case, the symptoms may be due to a lumbar vertebral slip caused by trauma. If conservative treatment is ineffective, surgical stabilization may need to be considered. For details regardi...