Fluctuating ELISA Test Results for STD Concerns

Q: Fluctuating ELISA Test Results for STD Concerns

Xiao Lian： Hello, each medical institution uses different brands of reagents for testing, so under different conditions, each institution will have its own standard values (which are the safe values). <br>In fact, even when a person has blood drawn at the same testing facility at

Please provide more context or specific information

Hello, doctor.
I broke up with my ex-boyfriend two years ago, and later I heard from his friends that he cheated on me during our relationship and had one-night stands before we got together.
I'm very worried about the possibility of contracting a sexually transmitted infection (STI) or AIDS.
Therefore, in December of the previous year, I went to Linkou Chang Gung Memorial Hospital for an ELISA test, and the result was 0.383.
I followed up with another test in April of last year, which showed 0.475.
However, I still felt anxious, so in October, I went to Taipei Veterans General Hospital for another ELISA test, and the result was 0.267.
In early January of this year, I went to the STD Prevention and Treatment Center in Wanhua and received a result of 0.309.
Although the doctors have told me that I am not infected, and I have not had any sexual activity with anyone since breaking up with my ex-boyfriend, I still have some fears.

Could you please explain why the values I received are different and fluctuate? The second and third tests had a difference of over 0.2.
What does this mean? Does it indicate an increase or decrease in the number of latent viruses in my body? I have been feeling very anxious these past few months; please help me.

Xiao Lian, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2013/02/03

Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology

Xiao Lian: Hello, each medical institution uses different brands of reagents for testing, so under different conditions, each institution will have its own standard values (which are the safe values).
In fact, even when a person has blood drawn at the same testing facility at different times, they may receive different test results.
For example, the blood glucose level in your body will never yield the same value with consecutive blood draws.
So how can you trust what your actual blood glucose level is? Therefore, in medicine, the normal values for tests are not just a single number; they are generally presented as a range.
As long as the result falls within a reasonable range, it is considered normal.
For instance, if a test has a normal range of 1 to 5.5, and you get a result of 1.1 while I get 3.0, both results are normal.
If you are still concerned, it is advisable to undergo HIV screening, which typically requires follow-up testing after more than one year.
This means that from the date of your last sexual encounter, if your blood test one year later is normal, you do not need to worry.
Additionally, it is best to test for other related diseases, such as syphilis and hepatitis B.
If you have any further questions or need clarification, feel free to ask, and we can discuss and research together.
Online answers should only serve as a reference; if necessary, you should seek medical care at a healthcare facility.
This message is from Dr.
Hsu Wei-Kai, Chief of Urology, Taitung Hospital, Department of Health, Executive Yuan.

Reply Date: 2013/02/03

More Info

Understanding fluctuating ELISA test results can be quite concerning, especially when it comes to sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) like HIV. Your situation raises several important points that need to be addressed to alleviate your worries and clarify the implications of your test results.

Firstly, it's essential to understand that the ELISA (Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay) test is a common screening tool for HIV and other infections. However, it is not infallible and can yield varying results due to several factors. The fluctuations you observed in your test results—0.383, 0.475, 0.267, and 0.309—can be attributed to several reasons:
1. Testing Variability: Different laboratories may use different testing kits and methodologies, which can lead to variations in results. Each lab has its own reference ranges and standards, which can affect the interpretation of your results. For instance, a result of 0.383 may be considered negative in one lab but could be interpreted differently in another.

2. Biological Variability: Human bodies are not static; they can exhibit biological variability. Factors such as hydration levels, stress, immune response, and even the time of day can influence test results. Just like blood sugar levels can fluctuate, so can the markers that ELISA tests measure.

3. Window Period: If there was any potential exposure to HIV, it's crucial to consider the window period—the time between potential exposure to HIV and the point when the test can accurately detect the virus. For most tests, this period can range from a few weeks to several months. If you were tested too soon after potential exposure, it might not accurately reflect your status.

4. False Positives and Negatives: ELISA tests are highly sensitive, meaning they can detect the presence of antibodies even in very low concentrations. However, this sensitivity can also lead to false positives, where the test indicates a positive result even when the virus is not present. This is why confirmatory tests, such as the Western blot or PCR tests, are essential for a definitive diagnosis.

5. Immune Response: Your immune system's response to infections can also cause fluctuations in test results. If your body is producing antibodies in response to an infection, the levels can vary over time, leading to different readings on subsequent tests.

Given that all your results have been below the threshold for a positive diagnosis and that you have not engaged in sexual activity since your breakup, it is reassuring that your doctors have indicated you are not infected. However, if you are still feeling anxious, it may be beneficial to have a follow-up consultation with a healthcare provider who specializes in infectious diseases or sexual health. They can provide more personalized advice and may recommend additional testing or monitoring.

In summary, fluctuating ELISA test results can be due to a combination of testing variability, biological factors, the window period, and the nature of the immune response. It is crucial to interpret these results in the context of your overall health and any potential exposure risks. If you have ongoing concerns, seeking further medical advice and possibly retesting after a suitable period may help provide peace of mind. Remember, maintaining open communication with your healthcare provider is key to addressing your fears and ensuring your health is monitored appropriately.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Syphilis Testing: ELISA Results and Concerns Explained

A 36-year-old male with a BMI of 30 and no sexual experience presents with a slightly raised, round, dark-colored lesion on his buttocks that has been present since elementary school. The lesion tends to spread and itch during times of fatigue, illness, or stress. When scratched,...

Dr. Du Mingyi reply Urology
If the test results are negative, then they are negative. Please do not self-diagnose.

Understanding False Positives in STD Testing: What You Need to Know

Hello Doctor, on July 6th, I had an encounter with a girl with a complicated relationship (we used a condom throughout). Three weeks later, at the end of July, I underwent STI screening, which came back negative. On October 9th, I went to a hospital in Taoyuan for anonymous testi...

Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology
Hello: I would like to provide some suggestions for your reference. Anonymous screening for sexually transmitted infections (STIs) should include HIV testing. Since screening is a preliminary examination, a definitive diagnosis requires a second test using the Western blot method...

Understanding Urological Concerns: Navigating Test Results and Symptoms

On April 14, I engaged in high-risk sexual behavior. On May 14, I went to a testing facility, and the report showed negative for Chlamydia DNA. On June 14, I went to another testing facility, and the report showed Chlamydia IgG 8.4 (-) with a reference value of 0-16 (units: RU/ml...

Dr. Li Yilun reply Urology
Laboratory test results may vary due to discrepancies between different laboratories, so it is essential to correlate them with clinical presentations. In males, chlamydia often manifests as urethritis, characterized by painful urination and white or clear discharge from the uret...

Understanding Fluctuating HSV-2 Test Results: What You Need to Know

Hello Doctor, I had sexual intercourse around October two years ago, and three months later I underwent testing. The result showed that my IgG for type 2 herpes simplex virus was 1.29, which is abnormal (the standard is <0.9 for no infection, 0.9-1.1 for past infection, and &g...

Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology
Hello: Sometimes one's own immunity may indeed overcome the virus, but not everyone is the same. Therefore, it is possible to return to normal after a period of time. Wishing you good health.