Why Hair Loss Treatments Fail: Androgenetic Alopecia

Despite exhausting all treatment options, hair loss continues?

Hello Dr.
Wu, I am 30 years old this year.
My family has a history of androgenetic alopecia.
Eight years ago, I was diagnosed by a physician with signs of male pattern baldness and started taking Finasteride (柔沛) for over three years.
I then switched to Dutasteride (波斯卡) for more than two years, and now I am using Minoxidil (法路寧).
I have been undergoing medical treatment for more than eight years, but my hair loss continues without improvement.
I once thought it might be an issue with my shampoo, so I switched to a hair loss shampoo (落健), but the shedding is still severe.
After each shower, I lose at least 30 strands of hair, and I also notice hair loss while washing my hair.
I lose at least 70 strands daily, and this happens every day.
My lifestyle and diet are normal.
I would like to ask the doctor if there could be any reasons that make the aforementioned treatments ineffective? My brother is also taking Minoxidil, and he has seen significant improvement, but I have not.
Could you please tell me the possible reasons and potential ways to improve this situation? Thank you!

Mr. An, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2014/01/13

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology

The current medications approved by our health authorities for the treatment of male pattern baldness are Finasteride 1mg and topical Minoxidil.
Rogaine, Proscar, and Folligen are all medications that contain either 1mg or 5mg of Finasteride, and their effects are quite similar.
If, based on your description, these medications have not been effective for you, I recommend trying topical Minoxidil (2% or 5%).
Please note that this is a topical application, not a shampoo.
Lifestyle factors (such as staying up late, stress, smoking, and drinking alcohol) and genetic influences also play a significant role.
If the results remain unsatisfactory, you may want to consider hair transplantation.

Reply Date: 2014/01/13

More Info

Androgenetic alopecia, commonly known as male pattern baldness, is a hereditary condition that affects many men and can lead to significant hair loss over time. Your situation, having tried multiple treatments over the past eight years without satisfactory results, is not uncommon. There are several factors that could contribute to the ineffectiveness of hair loss treatments, and understanding these can help guide your next steps.

1. Genetic Factors
Genetics plays a crucial role in androgenetic alopecia. The condition is influenced by the sensitivity of hair follicles to dihydrotestosterone (DHT), a derivative of testosterone. If your hair follicles are particularly sensitive to DHT, even the most effective treatments may not yield the desired results. This sensitivity can vary significantly between individuals, which explains why your brother may have seen improvement while you have not.

2. Treatment Adherence and Timing
Consistency in treatment is vital for effectiveness. If there were periods during your treatment where you missed doses or did not apply topical treatments as prescribed, this could hinder progress. Additionally, starting treatment at an earlier stage of hair loss often yields better results. If your hair follicles have already miniaturized significantly, it may be more challenging to reverse the process.

3. Treatment Selection
You mentioned using several medications, including Finasteride (Propecia) and Minoxidil (Rogaine). While these are among the most commonly prescribed treatments, they do not work for everyone. Some individuals may require a combination of treatments or alternative therapies. For instance, some patients benefit from low-level laser therapy or platelet-rich plasma (PRP) treatments, which can stimulate hair growth.

4. Underlying Health Conditions
Certain health issues, such as hormonal imbalances, thyroid disorders, or nutritional deficiencies, can exacerbate hair loss. It's essential to have a comprehensive evaluation to rule out any underlying conditions that could be contributing to your hair loss. Blood tests to check hormone levels, iron, and vitamin D can provide valuable insights.

5. Stress and Lifestyle Factors
Chronic stress can lead to hair loss, known as telogen effluvium, which can complicate the picture of androgenetic alopecia. While you mentioned that your lifestyle is normal, it’s worth considering if there are any stressors in your life that could be impacting your hair health. Additionally, habits such as smoking can negatively affect circulation and overall health, potentially impacting hair growth.

6. Psychological Impact
The psychological effects of hair loss can also play a role in treatment efficacy. Anxiety and depression related to hair loss can lead to a cycle of stress that exacerbates the problem. Seeking support from mental health professionals or support groups may be beneficial.

Recommendations
Given your situation, here are some steps you might consider:
- Consult a Specialist: A dermatologist or a trichologist specializing in hair loss can provide a more tailored approach. They may suggest alternative treatments or a combination of therapies.

- Evaluate Your Current Regimen: Discuss with your doctor the possibility of switching to a different medication or adding treatments like PRP or laser therapy.

- Check for Underlying Conditions: A thorough medical evaluation can help identify any health issues that may be contributing to your hair loss.

- Consider Lifestyle Changes: Incorporating stress management techniques, a balanced diet rich in vitamins and minerals, and avoiding smoking can improve overall health and potentially benefit hair growth.

- Stay Informed: Research ongoing clinical trials or emerging treatments for androgenetic alopecia, as the field is continually evolving.

In conclusion, while androgenetic alopecia can be challenging to treat, understanding the various factors at play can help you make informed decisions about your treatment options. Collaboration with healthcare professionals and a comprehensive approach to your health can lead to better outcomes.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Male Pattern Baldness: Causes, Treatments, and Future Solutions

Symptoms (Location, Description): I have been diagnosed with androgenetic alopecia by a dermatologist, and there is a family history of hair loss on my father's side. My questions are as follows: 1. Can excessive stress cause hair loss (alopecia areata)? 2. Are the treatment...

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
1. The most common cause of alopecia areata is stress. 2. I'm not very familiar with Edlanza; you might want to inquire further. 3. Protein shampoos do not promote hair growth. 4. Male pattern baldness cannot be cured; it can only be delayed or improved. 5. For surgi...

Understanding Male Pattern Baldness: Causes and Alternative Treatments

Doctor, I just visited a physician who informed me that my hair loss is severe. If anemia or other physical factors are ruled out, it may be androgenetic alopecia. I would like to know how androgenetic alopecia typically develops. Additionally, are there any methods to improve it...

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
There is generally a genetic predisposition, and it can be treated, with earlier intervention being better.

Understanding Male Pattern Baldness: Medication Effects and Alternatives

Hello, in recent years, I have been experiencing hair loss and visited the hospital. After a blood test, the doctor found that I have iron and zinc deficiencies (ferritin 28, zinc 680), but also noted that my hair loss appears to be genetically linked to androgenetic alopecia. Co...

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
If male pattern baldness is confirmed, a combination of oral medication and topical hair growth solutions will yield the best results.

Understanding Hair Loss: Causes and Solutions After Hormonal Treatments

Hello Doctor, I underwent endometriosis surgery around July 2016 and received hormonal suppressants for six months, which induced a pseudo-menopausal state. After that, I switched to birth control pills for treatment. Around June 2017, I stopped the medication due to severe side ...

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
It is necessary to conduct an examination, and if needed, a blood test should also be performed.