Hypnosis: Questions on Safety, Certification, and Effectiveness - Psychiatry

Share to:

Hypnosis Inquiry


Hello Dr.
Huang: Recently, a friend of mine may undergo this treatment, and I have researched some information about hypnosis online.
However, there is a lack of shared resources on this topic, so I have some questions to ask:
1.
Is the NGH International Hypnosis Certification a formal license? In Taiwan, is it necessary to have a medical or psychological professional qualification to practice hypnosis, or is having the NGH certification sufficient?
2.
What are the side effects or potential risks of failure associated with hypnosis? For example, like in the movie "Inception," could a hypnotist maliciously implant negative thoughts?
3.
There is a concept of past lives in hypnosis; is there any scientific basis for this? For instance, could the images of past lives I see simply be projections from my subconscious mind?
4.
How effective is hypnosis for issues such as lack of self-confidence, binge eating disorder, or stuttering?
5.
When a person is hypnotized, is it possible for them to be asked to do something against their will or moral values? Can a person's character be changed due to hypnosis?
Thank you for your assistance!

Mr. Y, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2014/11/27

Dr. Huang Weiqin reply Psychiatry


To the inquiring netizen: Hello! 1.
As far as I know, NGH should be considered a form of training certification rather than a professional license issued by the state or government.
Currently, there are no regulations regarding hypnosis practices in Taiwan.
2.
Hypnosis is considered a high-intensity psychological intervention; the assessment of side effects or the determination of success/failure depends on the methods and objectives of each individual case, making it difficult to generalize or draw conclusions (and movie portrayals tend to be exaggerated).
3.
The concepts of past lives and reincarnation lack scientific evidence to verify their truthfulness (though they may be projections of one's subconscious).
4.
Successful cases of treatment by hypnotists can be beneficial (similar to surgery, where a physician with sufficient skill and experience tends to have a higher rate of successful and satisfactory outcomes).
5.
This should cover the main points in a brief response.
Thank you for your inquiry.

Reply Date: 2014/11/27

More Info


Hypnosis is a fascinating and often misunderstood therapeutic technique that has garnered interest for its potential applications in various psychological and medical contexts. Your questions touch on several important aspects of hypnosis, including certification, safety, effectiveness, and ethical considerations. Let’s address each of your inquiries in detail.

1. Certification and Professional Qualifications: The National Guild of Hypnotists (NGH) is one of the largest and oldest organizations dedicated to the practice of hypnosis. While the NGH certification is recognized within the field of hypnosis, it is not a medical or psychological license. In many countries, including the United States, practicing hypnosis as a therapeutic tool typically requires a background in a relevant field, such as psychology, psychiatry, or social work. Therefore, while someone can obtain an NGH certification, it is advisable that they also hold a professional license to ensure they are qualified to address any psychological issues that may arise during hypnosis.

2. Risks and Side Effects: Hypnosis is generally considered safe when conducted by a trained professional. However, there are potential risks, including the possibility of false memories or the exacerbation of underlying psychological issues. The portrayal of hypnosis in films, such as "Inception," often exaggerates its capabilities and can lead to misconceptions. In reality, a trained hypnotist cannot implant thoughts or control a person against their will. The effectiveness of hypnosis largely depends on the individual's susceptibility and willingness to engage in the process.

3. Past Life Regression: The concept of past life regression is a controversial topic within the field of hypnosis. While some practitioners claim to facilitate experiences of past lives, there is no scientific evidence to support the existence of past lives. Many psychologists believe that the images and narratives experienced during such sessions are more likely to be manifestations of the subconscious mind rather than actual memories. This highlights the importance of understanding that hypnosis can evoke vivid imagery that may not correspond to reality.

4. Effectiveness for Specific Issues: Hypnosis has been shown to be effective for various conditions, including anxiety, phobias, and certain behavioral issues like overeating or stuttering. For individuals lacking self-confidence, hypnosis can help by promoting positive affirmations and altering negative thought patterns. However, results can vary significantly from person to person, and it is often most effective when combined with other therapeutic approaches, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT).

5. Ethical Considerations: A common concern about hypnosis is the potential for a hypnotist to manipulate a subject into performing actions against their will or moral beliefs. However, ethical hypnotists adhere to strict guidelines that prioritize the well-being and autonomy of their clients. While hypnosis can influence behavior, it cannot make someone act against their core values or beliefs. Moreover, significant personality changes due to hypnosis are unlikely; rather, hypnosis can help individuals access and modify existing behaviors and thought patterns.

In conclusion, hypnosis can be a valuable tool in the therapeutic arsenal, particularly for issues related to anxiety, self-esteem, and certain behavioral disorders. However, it is crucial to approach it with a clear understanding of its limitations and the importance of working with qualified professionals. If your friend is considering hypnosis, encourage them to seek practitioners with appropriate credentials and a solid ethical foundation. As with any therapeutic intervention, informed consent and a clear understanding of the process are essential for a positive experience.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Paranoia: Overcoming Fear of Infection and Harm

Hello, doctor. I previously engaged in sexual activities, and although I had a period of abstinence and later tested negative for sexually transmitted infections, I have been unable to shake off my fears since then. I am constantly worried about the possibility of contracting STI...


Dr. Liang Sunyuan reply Psychiatry
Hello Mr. Lin: It is recommended to shift your focus to other aspects of daily life, such as work, study, exercise, and hobbies, to dilute excessive worry with positive life experiences. If the distress persists, seeking medical assistance may be beneficial.

[Read More] Understanding Paranoia: Overcoming Fear of Infection and Harm


Overcoming Specific Phobias: Strategies for Managing Fear in Confined Spaces

Hello, Dr. Lee. I have been feeling what I believe to be a form of claustrophobia. Whenever I stay in a confined space for too long, I start to feel anxious and have an overwhelming urge to escape, especially in unfamiliar environments. However, once I become familiar with the sp...


Dr. Li Zhengfeng reply Psychiatry
Hello: First of all, welcome to your letter. According to what you mentioned, it seems that you are currently experiencing a phobia, which is a type of anxiety disorder. Treatment options include pharmacotherapy as well as psychotherapy or behavioral therapy. The etiology of phob...

[Read More] Overcoming Specific Phobias: Strategies for Managing Fear in Confined Spaces


Can a Doctor Diagnose Mental Health Issues You Can't Discuss?

Thank you, doctor, for answering my questions last time. Regarding my previous inquiry, I would like to ask again. I don't feel comfortable discussing my issues with my parents because I'm afraid that if I tell them and they take me to see a doctor, it might turn out th...


Dr. Wu Menghuan reply Psychiatry
Hello: You mentioned that "hiccups, hand tremors, sweating, dry heaving, facial flushing, and a blank mind" only occur in specific situations, which you previously described as "being on stage, performing, facing a crowd, or speaking with unfamiliar or unknown indi...

[Read More] Can a Doctor Diagnose Mental Health Issues You Can't Discuss?


Understanding Fear of the Unknown: Is It a Mental Health Issue?

I often feel intense fear in unfamiliar environments and around strangers or people I'm not familiar with (though I do experience this with familiar people, it's less frequent). For instance, I find it difficult to open the door or speak when standing in front of a clas...


Dr. Zhang Gengjia reply Psychiatry
Dear Sir/Madam, The issue you mentioned seems, on the surface, to be a lack of self-confidence. However, living in this world often brings about a persistent pressure that echoes a voice deep within, saying, "Not enough, not enough; you haven't done enough." I hop...

[Read More] Understanding Fear of the Unknown: Is It a Mental Health Issue?


Related FAQ

Hypnosis

(Psychiatry)

Cbt

(Psychiatry)

Breathing

(Psychiatry)

Sleepwalking

(Psychiatry)

Psychological Counseling

(Psychiatry)

Consultation

(Psychiatry)

Voyeurism

(Psychiatry)

Social Interaction

(Psychiatry)

Involuntary Psychiatric Treatment

(Psychiatry)

Fear

(Psychiatry)