Bisphosphonates and Current Medical Treatment for Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI)
Dear Dr.
Lin,
I am an Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI) patient.
I have been taking Fosamax (Alendronate) once a week from 2002 to 2015 for about 13 years.
I remember that before starting medication, from September 2006 to December 2009, I had not experienced any major fractures for approximately 14 years (although I had frequent fractures during childhood).
However, I did have some pain in my lower leg and other areas that might have been due to hairline fractures, but I could not confirm this as I never underwent any examinations.
After starting the medication, on September 19, 2003, I fell and fractured my right femur into three pieces.
In March 2007, the intramedullary nail in my right femur broke, and it was replaced.
Since then, the fracture site has not healed! On January 16, 2015, I fractured my right forearm while supporting myself during a movement, and it has been nearly 7 months without complete healing! (After the fracture, I recalled that about six months prior, I had experienced discomfort and weakness in the same area, which felt similar to a sprain but never improved.
I suspect that there might have been a hairline fracture rather than a sprain at that time, but since I did not undergo any examinations, I can only speculate now...)
I have several questions regarding bisphosphonate therapy and current medical treatments for OI:
1.
Are there better treatment options for OI available in Taiwan and abroad?
2.
Does taking Fosamax lead to bones that were previously less prone to fractures becoming more susceptible to fractures?
3.
Can Fosamax make fracture sites more difficult to heal?
4.
Should Fosamax be discontinued during the fracture healing period?
5.
If discontinuation is necessary, how long should it be stopped?
6.
Are there any examinations needed before discontinuing to assess if it is appropriate to stop the medication immediately?
7.
Will discontinuing Fosamax have negative effects?
8.
Will I need to take it again in the future?
9.
Besides calcium supplements and Fosamax, are there any better medications available?
10.
Are Fosamax and PROTOS (teriparatide) considered the same type of medication? Is the effect of PROTOS better?
11.
What methods can improve non-union fractures? For example, extracorporeal shock wave therapy?
I apologize for the numerous questions, and I appreciate your answers in advance.
Niming, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2015/08/19
Dr. Lin Ruli reply Rare Disease
1.
Are there better treatment options for Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI) in Taiwan and abroad? There are ongoing clinical trials for stem cell transplantation.
2.
Does taking Fosamax (Alendronate) lead to previously strong bones becoming more prone to fractures? No, it does not.
3.
Can Fosamax cause fracture sites to heal poorly? It is possible.
4.
Is it necessary to discontinue Fosamax during the fracture healing period? Yes, it is necessary to stop taking Fosamax.
5.
If discontinuation of Fosamax is required, how long should it be stopped? It is recommended to stop for 1-3 months, depending on the situation.
6.
Are there any assessments needed before discontinuing Fosamax to determine if it is appropriate to stop immediately?
7.
Will discontinuing Fosamax lead to worse outcomes? No, it will not.
8.
Will there be a need to take it again later? Yes, it may be necessary.
9.
Currently, besides calcium supplements and Fosamax, are there any better medications available? Some individuals use parathyroid hormone.
10.
Are Fosamax and PROTOS (a bone supplement) the same medication? They are different, but have similar effects.
Is the effect of PROTOS better? There are no relevant studies to confirm this.
11.
What methods can improve poorly healed fractures? It is advisable to consult an orthopedic surgeon, for example, extracorporeal shock wave therapy.
Reply Date: 2015/08/19
More Info
Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI), commonly known as "brittle bone disease," is a genetic disorder characterized by fragile bones that break easily, often with little or no apparent cause. The management of OI has evolved over the years, particularly with the use of bisphosphonates like Zoledronic acid (Fosamax) to help increase bone density and reduce fracture rates. However, the treatment landscape is continually advancing, and it is essential to understand both the benefits and potential drawbacks of these therapies.
1. Current Advances in OI Treatment: In recent years, there have been significant advances in the treatment of OI. Bisphosphonates remain a cornerstone of therapy, as they inhibit osteoclast activity, which helps to reduce bone resorption and increase bone density. However, newer treatments, such as monoclonal antibodies (e.g., Romosozumab), are being explored for their potential to stimulate bone formation. Gene therapy is also on the horizon, with research focusing on correcting the underlying genetic defects that cause OI.
2. Effects of Bisphosphonates: While bisphosphonates like Fosamax have been shown to reduce the incidence of fractures in OI patients, there is some concern about their long-term effects. Some studies suggest that prolonged use may lead to an accumulation of the drug in the bone, potentially resulting in oversuppression of bone turnover. This could theoretically lead to an increased risk of atypical fractures or delayed healing, particularly in patients with existing fractures.
3. Fracture Healing and Bisphosphonates: There is ongoing debate regarding whether bisphosphonates affect fracture healing negatively. Some evidence suggests that bisphosphonates may delay healing, particularly in patients with fractures that are already complicated. Therefore, it may be prudent to consider a temporary cessation of bisphosphonate therapy during the acute healing phase of a fracture.
4. Duration of Cessation: The duration for which bisphosphonates should be paused during fracture healing is not universally established and may depend on individual patient factors, including the type and location of the fracture. Typically, a period of 3-6 months may be considered, but this should be guided by clinical judgment and regular monitoring.
5. Monitoring Before Stopping Bisphosphonates: Before discontinuing bisphosphonates, it is advisable to conduct a thorough assessment, including imaging studies to evaluate the status of the fracture and bone density measurements to assess the overall bone health. This will help determine if stopping the medication is appropriate and safe.
6. Potential Negative Impacts of Stopping Treatment: Discontinuing bisphosphonates may lead to a rebound effect, where bone resorption increases, potentially leading to a higher risk of fractures. Therefore, any decision to stop treatment should be made cautiously and in consultation with a healthcare provider.
7. Future Treatment Considerations: If bisphosphonates are discontinued, it may be necessary to explore alternative therapies. Other medications, such as teriparatide (Forteo), which is a parathyroid hormone analog, can stimulate bone formation and may be considered, especially in patients with severe osteoporosis.
8. Comparative Effectiveness of Medications: PROTOS (also known as abaloparatide) is another treatment option that has been shown to improve bone density and reduce fracture risk in postmenopausal women with osteoporosis. While both PROTOS and bisphosphonates aim to improve bone health, they work through different mechanisms, and their effectiveness can vary based on individual patient profiles.
9. Improving Non-Union Fractures: For fractures that are not healing properly, additional interventions such as physical therapy, nutritional support (including adequate calcium and vitamin D), and possibly surgical intervention may be necessary. Techniques like extracorporeal shock wave therapy (ESWT) have also been explored for enhancing fracture healing.
In conclusion, the management of Osteogenesis Imperfecta is multifaceted and requires a personalized approach. It is crucial to work closely with a healthcare provider to monitor the effects of bisphosphonates, assess fracture healing, and consider alternative therapies as needed. Ongoing research continues to provide hope for improved treatments that can enhance the quality of life for individuals living with OI.
Similar Q&A
Are There Side Effects of AREDIAR Treatment for Osteogenesis Imperfecta?
Hello Dr. Lin: I would like to inquire about bisphosphonate treatment (AREDIAR treatment) for osteogenesis imperfecta. Is it a periodic treatment? Are there any significant side effects associated with this treatment? Could it cause any inconvenience in daily life? Which large ho...
Dr. Lin Xuanpei reply Rare Disease
Dear online user Xiao Yang: The bisphosphonate treatment (AREDIA therapy) for osteogenesis imperfecta requires monthly injections. The efficacy is generally better in patients who are not yet adults, and there is less consensus on whether adult patients still need long-term tre...[Read More] Are There Side Effects of AREDIAR Treatment for Osteogenesis Imperfecta?
Understanding Osteogenesis Imperfecta: Diagnosis and Treatment Options
Dear Dr. Jian, I would like to inform you that my twins were born on March 20. Upon birth, they were found to have a tendency to fracture easily. An X-ray examination revealed multiple fractures in both babies, and they exhibit the same symptoms. They have now been transferred t...
Dr. Jian Yingxiu reply Rare Disease
If the patient is a "glass child," bisphosphonate medications used for osteoporosis may be considered to increase bone density and reduce the frequency of fractures. However, there is a potential risk of hypocalcemia as a complication, so the timing of use should be tho...[Read More] Understanding Osteogenesis Imperfecta: Diagnosis and Treatment Options
Understanding Osteogenesis Imperfecta: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment
Hello Dr. Lee: Could you please explain what osteogenesis imperfecta is? I have not found much information, so I would appreciate your introduction. Thank you!
Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello, in response to your inquiry: Osteogenesis Imperfecta, commonly known as "brittle bone disease," is a condition caused by mutations in type I collagen. Approximately 1 in 20,000 newborns is affected by this disorder. The clinical manifestations vary significantly ...[Read More] Understanding Osteogenesis Imperfecta: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment
Understanding Osteogenesis Imperfecta: Diagnosis and Treatment Options
Hello, doctor: What examinations are performed during the initial visit for a patient with Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI)? What follow-up examinations are conducted afterward? In Taiwan's healthcare system, besides calcium supplements and bisphosphonate medications, are there ...
Dr. Lin Ruli reply Rare Disease
What examinations are performed during the initial consultation for a patient with Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI)? After bone density tests, biochemical tests, and X-ray examinations, what follow-up tests are conducted? In Taiwan's healthcare system, aside from calcium supplem...[Read More] Understanding Osteogenesis Imperfecta: Diagnosis and Treatment Options
Related FAQ
(Rare Disease)
Osteogenesis Imperfecta(Orthopedics)
Brittle Bone Disease(Rare Disease)
Rare Disease Treatment(Rare Disease)
Ichthyosis(Rare Disease)
Congenital Metabolic Disorders(Rare Disease)
G6Pd Deficiency(Rare Disease)
Whole Exome Sequencing(Rare Disease)
Osteoporosis(Orthopedics)
Zygomatic Bone(Orthopedics)