Patellar Fractures: Treatment Options and Recovery Insights

There is a suspected fracture at the one-third point of the left knee patella?

Hello Dr.
Shi,
I apologize for bothering you.
In July 2014, I hit my left knee against the handle of a plastic waist-high table.
The impact was quite forceful (similar to suddenly standing up from a chair), and it hurt a lot at the time, but I didn't pay much attention to it, thinking the bruise would heal in a few days.
I only realized there was a problem a month later when I felt discomfort after sprinting during practice, which led to knee inflammation that lasted for 4-5 days and then resolved on its own.
I usually have no issues walking, but my job requires frequent intense physical activity (I wear a knee brace), and afterward, every time I exercise or accidentally bump my knee (while wearing the brace), it becomes inflamed for 4-5 days.
Each time the inflammation occurs, I am unable to walk normally, but since I can walk normally when not inflamed, I didn't think much of it.
It wasn't until around May 2015 that the inflammation became too painful, and I had just been assigned to the New Taipei City Security Team's Thunder Squad, which caused significant inconvenience at work.
That’s when I decided to go to the hospital for an X-ray, which revealed a fracture in my patella.
However, orthopedic doctors at various hospitals, including Yadong Hospital, Shubei Hospital, and Wan Fang Hospital, all told me that it was a congenital issue and advised me to avoid intense exercise, wear a knee brace, and informed me that no one operates on such conditions.
Director Zhang Zhihong from Yadong Hospital even mentioned a specific medical term and showed me images of similar X-rays, which indeed resembled mine.
However, I don't understand why every doctor insists it is congenital when my X-ray even shows fragments of bone (which I personally speculate).
When I asked my mother, she said that I had undergone a full-body X-ray examination as a child, and this condition was not detected.
Due to the demands of my job (wearing over 3 kg of heavy equipment while climbing stairs) and my personal exercise needs, this situation has caused me extreme distress in my life.
I would like to ask if I insist on surgery to use steel pins to secure the fractured bone, will it improve my quality of life? Or will I still experience inflammation after intense exercise even if the bone is pinned back together? Thank you for taking the time to read and respond, I appreciate it!

Mr. Hsieh, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2015/09/20

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics

Without seeing the actual X-ray, it is difficult to determine whether the surgery has been beneficial for you.
However, based on your description, it seems that your patella may be congenitally bipartite, meaning that the kneecap is composed of two separate pieces.
This condition occurs in about 1% of the population, but only 2% of those individuals experience symptoms (you can refer to images on Wikipedia for more information).
Surgery is not helpful in this case; it is advisable to try using a knee brace or taking medication for treatment, and also to minimize weight-bearing activities as much as possible.

Reply Date: 2015/09/20

More Info

Understanding patellar fractures and their treatment options is crucial for anyone experiencing knee pain or discomfort, especially after a traumatic event. Based on your description, it appears that you have been dealing with a significant knee injury that has led to persistent inflammation and pain, particularly during physical activities.

Overview of Patellar Fractures
Patellar fractures can occur due to direct trauma, such as a fall or a collision, or from indirect forces, such as sudden muscle contractions. The patella, or kneecap, plays a vital role in knee mechanics, providing leverage for the quadriceps muscle and protecting the knee joint. Fractures can be classified as either non-displaced, where the bone cracks but maintains its proper alignment, or displaced, where the bone fragments are misaligned.

Symptoms and Diagnosis
Common symptoms of a patellar fracture include:
- Severe pain at the front of the knee
- Swelling and bruising
- Difficulty in straightening the leg
- A popping or cracking sound at the time of injury
Diagnosis typically involves physical examination and imaging studies, such as X-rays or MRI, to assess the extent of the injury and determine the best course of action.

Treatment Options
1. Conservative Management:
- Rest and Ice: Initially, resting the knee and applying ice can help reduce swelling and pain.

- Physical Therapy: Once the acute pain subsides, physical therapy can be beneficial in restoring strength and range of motion.

- Bracing: A knee brace may provide support and stability during the healing process.

2. Surgical Intervention:
- If the fracture is displaced or if there are multiple fragments, surgical intervention may be necessary. This typically involves the use of screws or pins to hold the bone fragments in place.

- Surgery can help restore the normal anatomy of the patella, which may improve function and reduce the likelihood of future complications.

Recovery Insights
Recovery from a patellar fracture can vary significantly based on the severity of the injury and the treatment approach. Generally, the following timeline can be expected:
- Initial Healing: The first 6-8 weeks post-injury are crucial for bone healing. During this time, weight-bearing activities may be limited.

- Rehabilitation: After the initial healing phase, physical therapy becomes essential. Patients can expect to gradually return to normal activities within 3-6 months, depending on the injury's severity and adherence to rehabilitation protocols.

- Return to Sports: For athletes or individuals engaged in high-impact activities, a return to full activity may take longer, often requiring 6 months or more of rehabilitation.

Considerations for Surgery
If you are considering surgery, it is essential to weigh the potential benefits against the risks. While surgery may improve your knee's stability and function, it does not guarantee that you will be free from pain or inflammation during high-impact activities. Post-surgical rehabilitation will be critical in achieving the best outcomes.

Conclusion
In conclusion, while your X-ray findings suggest a patellar issue that may require surgical intervention, it is essential to have a thorough discussion with an orthopedic surgeon who specializes in knee injuries. They can provide a tailored treatment plan based on your specific condition, activity level, and overall health. If surgery is deemed appropriate, following the prescribed rehabilitation program will be crucial for a successful recovery and return to your desired activities. Always consider seeking a second opinion if you feel uncertain about the recommendations provided by your current healthcare providers.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Left Knee Dislocation with Patellar Fracture: Treatment Options

Hello, Doctor. On December 13, 2015, I injured my knee while jumping to play basketball. After an MRI, the doctor diagnosed me with "left knee dislocation with associated patellar fracture." During the process, the doctor informed me that I could not undergo rehabilitat...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Patellar fractures that are non-displaced can be treated conservatively. However, if there is displacement, surgical intervention is necessary. If the articular surface is intact and undamaged, healing will result in a condition similar to normal. Therefore, the choice of treatme...

Patellar Fractures: Cast vs. Pins - Which Treatment is Best?

The treatment for a patellar fracture may involve either casting or the use of bone screws. The choice between these options depends on the type and severity of the fracture. Generally, surgical fixation with bone screws is preferred for displaced fractures, as it allows for bett...

Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello: The treatment for a patellar fracture is determined by the size of the gap at the fracture site and its location, which will dictate whether casting or surgical internal fixation is necessary. Regardless of whether a cast or surgical treatment is used, a recovery period of...

Effective Rehabilitation Strategies After Patellar Fracture Recovery

Hello, Director Chen! I injured my left knee patella due to a fall and had it in a cast for 6 weeks. After the cast is removed, what would be the best way to rehabilitate? Thank you!

Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
1. If the wound is not healed, laser and ultrasound therapy (from the outside) can be used initially, along with strengthening exercises for the thigh muscles. 2. Once the wound has healed, hydrotherapy can be added to improve flexibility, gradually increasing weight-bearing on t...

Understanding Patellar Fractures: Recovery, Treatment, and Risks

Due to a fall, the left knee directly impacted the floor, resulting in a patellar fracture. After undergoing internal fixation surgery with steel pins and wires, it has been two and a half months, but the left knee remains swollen and there is still weakness in performing straigh...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Patellar fractures rarely accompany ligament injuries; however, a definitive diagnosis still requires examination and assessment by a physician. Once the bone has healed, engaging in physical activity is unlikely to pose issues. After fracture healing, it is generally advisable t...