the Use of Tissue Coagulation Devices for Hemorrhoid Treatment - Surgery

Share to:

Using a tissue coagulator to address hemorrhoid issues?


Hello, I would like to ask you a question.
I have an issue with external hemorrhoids.
Although they are not painful at the moment, they are very itchy and tend to bleed easily.
After seeing a doctor, he suggested surgery.
He mentioned that the current method involves using a tissue coagulation device.
What I don't understand is how this differs from traditional surgery; is it just the instruments that are different? What are the side effects or complications associated with this method? Will it have the same risk of incontinence or fecal leakage as traditional surgery? Thank you!

juju, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2015/11/21

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery


The methods and principles of hemorrhoid surgery are the same; they involve separating the hemorrhoidal tissue from the anal sphincter and then excising it.
Therefore, the use of different instruments only results in variations in blood loss.
The side effects and complications are similar across techniques.
Hemorrhoid surgery typically does not lead to incontinence; this is often used by physicians as a scare tactic to deter patients from undergoing the procedure.
It is important for patients and physicians to have a thorough discussion about whether surgery is the only solution and to reach a consensus on the prognosis together.

Reply Date: 2015/11/21

More Info


The use of tissue coagulation devices for hemorrhoid treatment represents a significant advancement in the management of hemorrhoidal disease, particularly when compared to traditional surgical methods. These devices, often referred to as "coagulation devices" or "laser coagulation devices," utilize heat or electrical energy to coagulate tissue, effectively reducing blood flow to the hemorrhoids and promoting their shrinkage. This method is less invasive than traditional hemorrhoidectomy, which involves excising the hemorrhoids and can lead to more significant postoperative pain and complications.


Differences Between Tissue Coagulation and Traditional Surgery
1. Invasiveness: Traditional hemorrhoid surgery typically involves cutting away the hemorrhoidal tissue, which can lead to a longer recovery time and more postoperative pain. In contrast, tissue coagulation techniques are minimally invasive, often performed in an outpatient setting, and usually require only local anesthesia.

2. Recovery Time: Patients undergoing coagulation procedures generally experience a quicker recovery compared to those who have traditional surgery. This is largely due to the reduced trauma to surrounding tissues.

3. Pain Management: With traditional surgery, patients often require stronger pain management strategies postoperatively. In contrast, those treated with coagulation techniques typically report less pain and discomfort.

4. Complications: Traditional hemorrhoidectomy carries risks of complications such as bleeding, infection, and anal stenosis. While coagulation techniques also have risks, they tend to be lower. However, complications such as rectal bleeding or pain can still occur.


Potential Side Effects and Complications
While tissue coagulation devices are generally considered safe, there are potential side effects and complications to be aware of:
1. Pain and Discomfort: Some patients may experience pain or discomfort at the site of treatment, although this is usually less severe than with traditional surgery.

2. Bleeding: There is a risk of bleeding, particularly if the coagulation does not fully seal the blood vessels supplying the hemorrhoids.

3. Infection: As with any procedure, there is a risk of infection, although this risk is relatively low with minimally invasive techniques.

4. Recurrence: While coagulation can effectively reduce the size of hemorrhoids, there is a possibility of recurrence, especially if lifestyle factors contributing to hemorrhoid formation (such as constipation or prolonged sitting) are not addressed.

5. Fecal Incontinence: One of the most concerning complications of any hemorrhoid surgery is the risk of fecal incontinence. However, studies suggest that the risk of this complication is lower with tissue coagulation techniques compared to traditional hemorrhoidectomy. Nonetheless, it is not entirely absent, and patients should discuss their individual risk factors with their healthcare provider.


Conclusion
In summary, tissue coagulation devices offer a modern, less invasive alternative to traditional hemorrhoid surgery, with benefits such as reduced pain, quicker recovery, and lower complication rates. However, patients should be aware of the potential risks and discuss these with their healthcare provider to make an informed decision about their treatment options. If you have concerns about specific risks, such as fecal incontinence or recurrence, it is essential to address these with your doctor, who can provide personalized advice based on your medical history and the specifics of your condition.

Similar Q&A

Effective Treatment Options for Mixed Hemorrhoids: Banding vs. Topical Creams

Hello, doctor. I recently had an examination and was diagnosed with mixed hemorrhoids. The doctor mentioned that banding would be sufficient. Is this a viable option? Can I also use ointment to treat the small blood clots located at the external anal area?


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Hemorrhoids that are not swollen, painful, or bleeding generally do not require surgical intervention or ligation for symptom control and can often be managed with medication. Traditionally, ligation is indicated for internal hemorrhoids, and it is usually not recommended for mix...

[Read More] Effective Treatment Options for Mixed Hemorrhoids: Banding vs. Topical Creams


Is Laser Treatment for Hemorrhoids Effective and Safe?

Hello, doctor! I recently saw on a clinic's website that they offer laser treatment for hemorrhoids, claiming it can be done without hospitalization, allows for normal work afterward, requires no anesthesia, and results in no bleeding. They state that the treatment can be co...


Dr. Lin Hongmao reply Surgery
Dear friend, I have no experience with laser treatment for hemorrhoids, so I searched online and found comprehensive information provided by a physician on this issue. I am quoting it for your reference: "Laser Surgery for Hemorrhoids? It's Already Outdated! Hsinchu H...

[Read More] Is Laser Treatment for Hemorrhoids Effective and Safe?


Can Rubber Band Ligation Be Used for Mixed Hemorrhoids?

I had a hemorrhoid ligation at the hospital this past Monday. The doctor mentioned that the bleeding internal hemorrhoid should not cause any special issues at home. I was prescribed a suppository and medication to stop the bleeding, but I've been experiencing significant pa...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
The principle of rubber band ligation is that internal hemorrhoids do not have somatic nerve distribution, so there is no pain after ligation. However, ligation is not recommended for mixed hemorrhoids, as pain after the procedure is unavoidable. Now that the ligation has been pe...

[Read More] Can Rubber Band Ligation Be Used for Mixed Hemorrhoids?


Understanding Hemorrhoids: Treatment Options, Risks, and Benefits

Hello, Doctor. I have had hemorrhoids for several years. Previously, I visited a gastroenterologist due to rectal bleeding, and the doctor advised me to see a colorectal surgeon to consider treatment for my hemorrhoids. The colorectal surgeon initially prescribed an ointment for ...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
The management of hemorrhoids varies depending on the severity of symptoms. For mild cases, topical medications and improvement of bowel habits may suffice. If there is persistent bleeding, rubber band ligation can be performed. In cases of severe prolapse or recurrent bleeding, ...

[Read More] Understanding Hemorrhoids: Treatment Options, Risks, and Benefits


Related FAQ

Thrombosed External Hemorrhoid

(Surgery)

Hemorrhoid Ligation

(Surgery)

Internal Hemorrhoid Bleeding

(Surgery)

Hemorrhoids

(Surgery)

Hemorrhoid Ointment

(Surgery)

Rectal Bleeding

(Surgery)

Prolapsed Hemorrhoid

(Surgery)

Hemorrhoids

(Urology)

Hemorrhoids

(Gastroenterology and Hepatology)

Anal Fistula

(Surgery)