Boxers vs. Briefs: Is There Medical Evidence for the Best Choice?

Is there medical evidence?

I've heard that wearing boxers is better than wearing briefs.
Is there any medical evidence for this?

ham, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2002/07/08

Dr. Song Zhixian reply Urology

Smoking, alcohol consumption, hot water baths, and the warmth of Finnish saunas can impact fertility.
As for boxers and briefs, I have also heard from newspapers and magazines that there may be medical evidence regarding this, but I do not have specific data to reference.
Generally, as long as they are not too tight, they should not have an adverse effect.
For certain specific cases of male infertility, there are specially designed underwear that help maintain a lower temperature around the scrotum (approximately 1-2 degrees lower), which can aid in sperm production.

Reply Date: 2002/07/08

More Info

The debate between boxers and briefs has been a topic of discussion not only among men but also within the medical community. While personal preference plays a significant role in this choice, there are some medical considerations that may influence the decision.

Overview of Boxers vs. Briefs
Boxers are loose-fitting undergarments that provide more airflow and less support, while briefs are tighter and offer more support to the genital area. The choice between the two can impact comfort, temperature regulation, and even fertility.

Medical Considerations
1. Fertility and Sperm Production: One of the most discussed aspects of this topic is the potential impact of underwear choice on male fertility. Research has indicated that testicular temperature is crucial for optimal sperm production. The testes are located outside the body for a reason: they need to be cooler than the body's core temperature for effective sperm production. A study published in the journal *Human Reproduction* found that men who wore boxers had higher sperm counts compared to those who wore tighter-fitting underwear like briefs. The reasoning is that boxers allow for better airflow and lower temperatures, which may be beneficial for sperm health.

2. Comfort and Skin Health: Comfort is subjective, but some studies suggest that tighter underwear can lead to increased sweating and moisture retention, which may contribute to skin irritation or fungal infections. Boxers, being looser, may allow for better ventilation and reduce the risk of such issues. However, it is essential to choose materials that wick moisture away from the skin, regardless of the style.

3. Support and Physical Activity: For men who engage in sports or physical activities, briefs may provide better support and reduce the risk of injury or discomfort during movement. This support can be particularly important during high-impact activities. Conversely, boxers may be preferred for casual wear or lounging due to their comfort.

4. Health Conditions: Certain medical conditions may also influence the choice of underwear. For example, men with varicocele (enlarged veins in the scrotum) may benefit from the support that briefs provide. On the other hand, men prone to skin conditions may prefer boxers to minimize friction and irritation.

Conclusion
While there is some medical evidence suggesting that boxers may be better for sperm production due to temperature regulation, the choice between boxers and briefs ultimately comes down to personal preference and lifestyle. It is essential to consider factors such as comfort, activity level, and any specific health concerns when making this decision.

If you are concerned about fertility or any other health issues related to your choice of underwear, it may be beneficial to consult with a healthcare professional. They can provide personalized advice based on your individual health needs and lifestyle. Ultimately, the best choice is one that balances comfort, support, and health considerations.

Similar Q&A

Choosing the Right Underwear for Varicocele: Boxers vs. Briefs

Last October, I experienced pain in the left side of my scrotum, so I went to the hospital for an ultrasound examination. It was confirmed that I have a varicocele. However, the doctor did not provide any treatment. Occasionally, I still feel pain in my left testicle. I would lik...

Dr. Liu Jianting reply Urology
It is indeed difficult to choose; in fact, both triangular and square shapes are the same. Varicocele primarily results from poor venous return, which is especially noticeable when standing. Prolonged standing can sometimes lead to pain due to venous swelling. However, pain in th...

Do Supportive Underwear Improve Comfort and Health for Men?

I would like to ask the doctor about a type of underwear that has been popularized on foreign websites, known as "supportive underwear" or "pouch underwear." These have two straps designed to lift the testicles. Many users have shared their experiences, claimi...

Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology
Non-medical advice. However, I would like to mention that raising the testicles for heat dissipation is unreasonable; the testicles should be positioned away from the body for better cooling. I still recommend that you continue using what you were originally using.

Do Swim Trunks Affect Male Development During Adolescence?

I am a high school student, and during swimming class, I noticed that everyone wears square-cut swim trunks. A classmate mentioned that his dad told him not to wear briefs during the developmental period because it would affect growth, including underwear. Is this true?

Dr. Zhang Jianghu reply Urology
Hello, Zhi-Hsing: Wearing briefs or boxers actually has minimal impact. The main factors are how tight they are and whether they allow for ventilation or breathability. This is a response from Dr. Lai Rong-Hao, attending physician of the Urology Department at Hsinchu Hospital, Mi...

Post-Circumcision Care: Tight vs. Loose Underwear for Comfort

Doctor, I am Ah-Hui, who asked you two questions earlier. I would like to ask you another question. If I have just undergone a circumcision and the remaining foreskin is elastic enough to cover almost half of the glans, should I wear tight-fitting underwear or loose-fitting under...

Dr. Du Shixi reply Urology
Hello: I personally suggest being more relaxed. Wishing you good health.