Wrist sprain
Hello doctor, I have been suffering from a wrist sprain for over four months.
An X-ray showed no fractures.
I have undergone acupuncture, taken medication, and received ultrasound, electrical therapy, and shortwave therapy, but it still hasn't healed after such a long time.
I then visited a traditional Chinese medicine clinic, and the practitioner said that my scaphoid bone in the wrist is misaligned.
He adjusted it with a pop sound, and I felt much more comfortable immediately.
However, can this really lead to complete recovery? He mentioned that a four-month-old injury could heal in a week because it was just a bone misalignment, so I would like to hear your opinion on this.
Nìmíng, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2015/12/30
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
If the scaphoid bone in the wrist is displaced, it can be extremely painful, and the joint may be completely immobile.
An X-ray can immediately determine whether there is a displacement.
A wrist sprain may also involve ligament damage, and recovery will take some time; it cannot be resolved instantly by simply stretching or manipulating the bones.
Reply Date: 2015/12/30
More Info
Wrist sprains are common injuries that can occur due to a fall, awkward landing, or overuse. They involve the stretching or tearing of ligaments that support the wrist joint. The healing time for wrist sprains can vary significantly based on the severity of the injury, the treatment methods employed, and individual healing responses.
In your case, it has been over four months since your wrist sprain, and despite undergoing various treatments such as acupuncture, medication, ultrasound, and electrical therapy, you have not experienced significant improvement. The X-ray results indicating no fractures are a positive sign, but persistent pain and discomfort can be frustrating.
The suggestion from the practitioner at the martial arts center that your scaphoid bone (舟狀骨) might be misaligned is an interesting perspective. The scaphoid is one of the small bones in the wrist and plays a crucial role in wrist stability and function. If it is indeed misaligned, it could contribute to ongoing pain and limited mobility. The "pop" sound you heard during the adjustment may indicate that the bone was repositioned, which could potentially relieve some of the discomfort.
However, it is essential to approach this situation with caution. While some practitioners may have success with manual adjustments, it is crucial to ensure that any manipulation is performed by a qualified professional who understands the anatomy and mechanics of the wrist. Improper adjustments could lead to further injury or complications.
In terms of treatment options, if you have not already done so, consider the following:
1. Physical Therapy: A physical therapist can provide targeted exercises to strengthen the wrist, improve flexibility, and enhance overall function. They can also employ modalities such as ultrasound or manual therapy to aid in recovery.
2. Immobilization: Depending on the severity of your sprain, using a wrist brace or splint may help stabilize the joint and allow for healing. This can prevent further strain on the ligaments during the recovery process.
3. Rest and Activity Modification: It is crucial to allow your wrist adequate time to heal. Avoid activities that exacerbate the pain, and gradually reintroduce movements as tolerated.
4. Consultation with a Specialist: If your symptoms persist, consider seeing an orthopedic specialist who can provide a more in-depth evaluation. They may recommend imaging studies, such as an MRI, to assess soft tissue injuries or other underlying issues that may not be visible on X-rays.
5. Alternative Therapies: In addition to acupuncture, some patients find relief through therapies such as chiropractic care or osteopathic manipulation. Again, ensure that these treatments are provided by licensed professionals.
6. Surgical Options: In rare cases where conservative treatments fail, surgical intervention may be necessary to address underlying issues, such as ligament tears or bone misalignments.
In conclusion, while the practitioner’s adjustment may provide temporary relief, it is essential to continue monitoring your symptoms and seek further evaluation if necessary. Healing from a wrist sprain can take time, and patience is crucial. If you do not see improvement in the coming weeks, consider revisiting your healthcare provider to discuss additional treatment options or referrals to specialists. Remember, the goal is to restore function and alleviate pain, allowing you to return to your normal activities safely.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Wrist Issues: Swelling After a Fall and Treatment Options
Two weeks ago, I fell and landed on my right hand. The next day, I went to a local hospital for an X-ray, which showed no fractures. I have been using a wrist brace for the past two weeks (which has made daily activities easier), but I noticed that the back of my hand has swollen...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Wrist sprains sometimes do not involve fractures, but the ligaments or the wrist joint capsule can still be injured. Generally, soft tissue injuries require about six weeks to heal, so it is important to protect your wrist during this time and avoid excessive use. If the joint be...[Read More] Understanding Wrist Issues: Swelling After a Fall and Treatment Options
Effective Rehabilitation Strategies for Prolonged Ligament Injuries
I have been suffering from a dislocated elbow and wrist injury from a car accident for seven months. I have seen both traditional Chinese medicine and Western medicine for over a month. The Western doctors performed a CT scan and MRI, determining that I have a wrist ligament inju...
Dr. Xu Zhenrong reply Rehabilitation
The letter mentions that a car accident resulted in an elbow dislocation and wrist injury seven months ago. Imaging studies show no skeletal issues, only a wrist ligament injury. Ligaments are specialized soft tissues that connect joints. After the injury, in addition to medicati...[Read More] Effective Rehabilitation Strategies for Prolonged Ligament Injuries
Understanding Wrist Injuries: Recovery, Treatment Options, and Rehabilitation
Hello Dr. Lee, I injured my wrist in June of this year, and it has been five and a half months since then. Initially, an orthopedic doctor at the clinic diagnosed me with possible injuries to the scapholunate ligament and the triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) using X-rays...
Dr. Li Yanheng reply Rehabilitation
1. It is fine to have a splint made at the rehabilitation department, but a fixed splint may significantly limit mobility. It is recommended to continue using a Velcro wrist brace, and both can be used alternately. 2. You can go to the rehabilitation outpatient clinic for evalu...[Read More] Understanding Wrist Injuries: Recovery, Treatment Options, and Rehabilitation
Dealing with Wrist Injuries: Recovery Tips and Expert Advice
On November 26th, I was playing arm wrestling with my classmates, and as a result, my wrist was bent downwards, making a popping sound. Since the injury, it has improved somewhat, but when I rotate it, there is still a sound like something is stuck in the tendon. I went to the ho...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
It sounds like you may have injured a tendon or ligament. Usually, applying heat can help, and if the pain persists, you can take some pain relievers to alleviate the symptoms. Complete recovery typically takes about six to twelve weeks, and it's important to commit to rehab...[Read More] Dealing with Wrist Injuries: Recovery Tips and Expert Advice
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Wrist(Rehabilitation)
Mommy'S Wrist(Orthopedics)
Ankle Sprain(Rehabilitation)
Ankle Joint Injury(Orthopedics)
Fracture Healing(Orthopedics)
Hand Fracture(Orthopedics)
Wrist Injury(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Tendonitis(Orthopedics)
Distal Radioulnar Joint Dislocation(Orthopedics)