Is this a recurrence of a herniated disc?
Six years ago, I underwent minimally invasive surgery to remove a portion of a herniated disc at the L4/L5 level due to pain and numbness in my left leg, and I recovered well.
However, two months ago, after sneezing, I noticed numbness from my right lower back down to my right calf, which only resolves when lying flat while sleeping.
There is no back pain, and I can walk, but the numbness in my foot is quite uncomfortable.
I have been undergoing rehabilitation for three weeks with no progress.
1.
Could this be a recurrence of the herniated disc?
2.
Is the numbness in my foot indicative of nerve compression?
3.
If there is no progress in rehabilitation, should I consider surgery again?
4.
Is there a possibility of performing minimally invasive surgery again?
Thank you!
Shan Yue, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/02/05
Dr. Lai Zhaokang reply Neurosurgery
1.
Does this count as a recurrence of a herniated disc? A: It is possible.
Please arrange for further examinations such as X-rays and MRI to confirm.
2.
Is the numbness in the foot due to nerve compression? A: It is possible, but it could also be due to other issues.
3.
If there is no progress with rehabilitation, should we consider another surgery? A: Yes, it depends on the results of the X-rays and MRI.
4.
Is there a chance for minimally invasive surgery again? A: Yes, but it will depend on the results of the X-rays and MRI.
Wishing you a speedy recovery.
Director of Spine and Neurosurgery, Changhua Hospital, Dr.
Lai Chao-Kang.
Reply Date: 2016/02/05
More Info
The symptoms you are experiencing, particularly the numbness in your right leg following a sneeze, raise important questions regarding the potential recurrence of a disc herniation or other underlying issues. Given your history of L4/L5 microdiscectomy six years ago, it is understandable to be concerned about the possibility of a recurrence.
1. Is this a recurrence of disc herniation?
While it is possible that your symptoms could indicate a recurrence of disc herniation, it is not definitive. Numbness in the leg can result from various conditions, including nerve compression, inflammation, or even muscular issues. The fact that you are not experiencing pain in your lower back and can walk without difficulty suggests that the situation may not be as severe as a full recurrence. However, the numbness itself is a sign that something is affecting the nerves in that area, which warrants further investigation.
2. Is the numbness a sign of nerve compression?
Yes, the numbness you are experiencing could indicate that a nerve is being compressed or irritated. This could be due to a variety of factors, including a new herniation, scar tissue from your previous surgery, or even changes in your spine's alignment. The fact that the numbness is alleviated when lying flat suggests that certain positions may relieve pressure on the affected nerve. It is crucial to have a thorough evaluation, possibly including imaging studies like an MRI, to determine the exact cause of your symptoms.
3. What if rehabilitation does not yield progress?
If rehabilitation does not lead to improvement after a reasonable period, it may be necessary to consider further diagnostic imaging and possibly surgical options. The decision to undergo surgery again would depend on the findings from imaging studies and the severity of your symptoms. If there is evidence of significant nerve compression or other issues that could be addressed surgically, a second operation might be warranted.
4. Is there a chance for a minimally invasive surgery again?
Yes, if surgery is deemed necessary, there is a possibility that a minimally invasive approach could be utilized again. Advances in surgical techniques have made it possible to perform various procedures with less tissue disruption, which can lead to quicker recovery times and less postoperative pain. However, the specific approach would depend on the findings from your evaluations and the surgeon's recommendations.
In summary, while your symptoms could suggest a recurrence of disc herniation, they could also stem from other causes. It is essential to consult with a spine specialist who can perform a comprehensive evaluation, including a physical examination and possibly imaging studies, to determine the best course of action. Rehabilitation is often a first-line treatment, but if symptoms persist, further intervention may be necessary. Always communicate openly with your healthcare provider about your symptoms and concerns to ensure you receive the most appropriate care.
Similar Q&A
Can You Self-Diagnose a Herniated Disc? Understanding Your Symptoms
Due to long-term prolonged sitting, I have recently experienced occasional sensations of tingling and numbness in my thighs and fingers. These sensations are brief, and sometimes I mistakenly think I've been bitten by a mosquito. I initially suspected a herniated disc, but w...
Dr. Lin Zhebin reply Family Medicine
Hello: 1. The primary symptom of a herniated disc is pain; if you only experience tingling or numbness, other causes should be considered. 2. The discomfort in your thigh may suggest lumbar nerve compression, while the discomfort in your fingers may indicate cervical nerve compre...[Read More] Can You Self-Diagnose a Herniated Disc? Understanding Your Symptoms
Post-Discectomy Concerns: Recurring Numbness and Hip Pain Explained
Hello, doctor! About two years ago, I underwent a simple lumbar discectomy, where only the herniated portion of the disc was removed. When I initially reviewed the MRI, the doctor mentioned that the nerve was severely compressed, and prior to the decompression surgery, my entire ...
Dr. Lai Zhaokang reply Neurosurgery
Hello: It is suspected that the likelihood of a protrusion recurrence is high. It is recommended to consult a neurosurgeon for evaluation and to arrange an MRI. Best wishes, Dr. Lai Chao-Kang, Changhua Hospital.[Read More] Post-Discectomy Concerns: Recurring Numbness and Hip Pain Explained
Understanding Disc Herniation: Symptoms, Surgery, and Recovery Concerns
Hello Doctor, at first, my fingers started to feel numb. I didn't pay much attention to it, but I went to a small clinic for an examination, and the doctor said there was no problem. However, my condition did not improve; in fact, it got worse. My feet also started to feel n...
Dr. Chen Changmu reply Neurosurgery
Spinal cord compression can cause numbness and pain. After decompression surgery, the improvement in pain is often most noticeable, but the numbness may take some time to resolve. Sometimes, if the compression has lasted too long, it may result in permanent spinal cord damage, wh...[Read More] Understanding Disc Herniation: Symptoms, Surgery, and Recovery Concerns
Understanding Foot Numbness: A Guide for Herniated Disc Patients
Hello doctor, I have a problem with lumbar disc herniation. I went for spinal traction and felt fine afterward, so I haven't gone back for almost a year without any recurrence. However, a few days ago, I went to buy rice because we ran out, and my lower back started to feel ...
Dr. Li Weiqiang reply Rehabilitation
A: Based on the symptoms described, it is very likely that a lumbar disc herniation is the cause. If possible, please visit a hospital's rehabilitation department for an examination and to arrange for rehabilitation therapy.[Read More] Understanding Foot Numbness: A Guide for Herniated Disc Patients
Related FAQ
(Neurology)
Foot Numbness(Neurosurgery)
Back Numbness(Neurosurgery)
Left Foot Numbness(Neurosurgery)
Herniated Disc(Neurosurgery)
Numbness In The Soles Of The Feet(Neurosurgery)
Foot Numbness(Orthopedics)
Thigh Nerve Pain(Neurosurgery)
Sciatica(Neurosurgery)
Leg(Neurology)