Inquiry about the contents of the medical diagnosis report?
Hello Doctor,
I would like to ask you some questions regarding the medical certificate.
Recently, I suffered an ankle sprain, and I informed my company that I would be unable to work during that time.
They requested that I provide a rehabilitation certificate or a statement indicating that my condition would not hinder my ability to work once I recovered.
After undergoing acupuncture treatment for a while, I feel much better.
The doctor has performed acupressure on me, and I no longer experience pain while walking.
Therefore, I requested a certificate from the clinic doctor, but the doctor said they could not state "recovered" in the certificate.
Instead, they suggested that I could tell my company that the diagnosis certificate indicates I am fine.
However, I am confused as to why they cannot state recovery in the diagnosis certificate.
I then asked the doctor if they could provide alternative wording, but they did not give me a clear answer.
I have searched extensively but found no similar articles or complete answers, so I am unsure what content I can ask the doctor to provide that would be acceptable to them.
Without such a certificate, I may not be able to return to work, and I do not want to lose this job.
Therefore, I would like to ask you, given this situation, what is the most favorable wording I can request from the doctor that they would be willing to provide? Is it acceptable for the doctor to state "currently recovering" or "no significant issues for work"? Thank you!
P.S.
I understand that doctors cannot arbitrarily issue content in a diagnosis certificate, so I realize that my request may seem unreasonable.
However, I truly do not want to give up my job, so I apologize for asking these questions.
I sincerely hope you can provide assistance and advice!
Qing, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/10/19
Dr. Zhang Weidong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Hello, Qing: Regarding the issuance of the medical certificate, here are my opinions for your reference.
It is not necessary for other physicians to cooperate, to avoid causing you any inconvenience.
If the patient requires it, I will write based on what I have observed.
I cannot issue the certificate according to the patient's or the company's requests.
Based on your condition, if after examination (with fractures or hematomas ruled out, and physical examination showing no abnormalities), the affected area can move normally, I would state, "The affected area has returned to normal activity after treatment, but caution is still advised during activities," or similar wording.
However, it is challenging to write that there is no impact on work or that the patient has fully recovered, as there may still be residual injuries or issues beyond our examination capabilities.
Such guarantees cannot be made.
What we can assure is based on observable evidence, and the wording must be carefully considered, as these documents carry legal weight.
Physicians must be responsible for the medical certificates they issue.
I hope this helps you.
Zhang Weidong, Department of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Changhua Hospital.
Reply Date: 2016/10/19
More Info
Navigating the complexities of medical documentation, especially in the context of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) and recovery from an injury, can be quite challenging. Your situation regarding the ankle sprain and the subsequent need for a medical certificate to return to work is not uncommon. Here’s a comprehensive overview of how to approach this issue.
Understanding Medical Certificates
1. Purpose of Medical Certificates: Medical certificates serve as official documentation from a healthcare provider that confirms a patient's medical condition and their ability to perform work-related duties. These documents are crucial for employers to understand an employee's health status and any necessary accommodations.
2. Types of Medical Documentation: There are generally two types of medical documentation you might encounter:
- Diagnosis Certificates: These indicate the nature of the injury or illness but may not specify recovery status.
- Fitness for Work Certificates: These explicitly state whether an individual is fit to return to work and may include any limitations or recommendations for modifications in duties.
Your Situation
In your case, you have undergone acupuncture treatment for an ankle sprain and feel significantly improved. However, the physician at your clinic is hesitant to issue a certificate stating that you are "recovered." This reluctance could stem from several factors:
- Medical Standards: Physicians often adhere to strict medical guidelines when issuing certificates. They may prefer to avoid using terms like "recovered" unless they are confident that the patient has fully healed, as this could expose them to liability if complications arise later.
- Legal and Ethical Considerations: Doctors must ensure that any statements made in a medical certificate are accurate and reflect the patient's true condition. They may be concerned about the implications of stating recovery if there is still a risk of re-injury or if the patient has not undergone a complete assessment.
Recommendations for Your Medical Certificate
1. Requesting Alternative Wording: Since your doctor is unwilling to state that you are fully recovered, you might consider asking for alternative phrases that still convey your improved condition. For example:
- "Patient has shown significant improvement and is able to perform daily activities without pain."
- "Patient is fit to return to work with no significant limitations."
- "Patient is currently undergoing treatment and is responding well, with no major impediments to work."
2. Discussing Work Limitations: If there are any specific activities that you should avoid (like heavy lifting or prolonged standing), it might be beneficial to include that in the certificate. This shows that you are aware of your condition and are taking responsible steps to prevent re-injury.
3. Follow-Up Appointments: If your doctor is still hesitant, consider scheduling a follow-up appointment to discuss your progress in more detail. This could provide them with more confidence in your recovery status and may lead to a more favorable assessment.
4. Seeking a Second Opinion: If you feel that your current physician is not accommodating your needs, it might be worth seeking a second opinion from another healthcare provider who is familiar with your case and can provide a different perspective on your recovery.
5. Communicating with Your Employer: Keep an open line of communication with your employer about your situation. Explain your progress and the steps you are taking to ensure a safe return to work. Employers often appreciate transparency and may be willing to accommodate your situation while you secure the necessary documentation.
Conclusion
Navigating the requirements for a medical certificate can be complex, especially when dealing with recovery from an injury. It’s important to communicate openly with your healthcare provider about your needs while respecting their professional guidelines. By requesting alternative wording, discussing any necessary limitations, and possibly seeking a second opinion, you can work towards obtaining a certificate that meets both your needs and those of your employer. Remember, your health and safety should always come first, and ensuring a complete recovery is essential for your long-term well-being.
Similar Q&A
How to Obtain a Disability Certificate for Epilepsy in Taiwan
Hello Doctor: My brother has epilepsy and is unable to work. The village chief wants to help him apply for a medical certificate to obtain a disability handbook. He previously had a medical certificate from Taipei Women's and Children's Hospital, but it is from 80 years...
Dr. Du Haojie reply Neurology
A diagnostic certificate typically requires a thorough evaluation by a physician. If the criteria are met, an application for a disability handbook can be submitted.[Read More] How to Obtain a Disability Certificate for Epilepsy in Taiwan
What to Do If You Lose Your Sleep Medication and Health Cards?
Hello, Dr. Gu! I have a habit of taking sleeping pills, but two days ago, during a trip to the southern part of the island, I discovered that my sleeping pills, health insurance card, and disability handbook were all missing! Since my household registration is not on the main isl...
Dr. Chen Yuying reply Psychiatry
Hello MeiMei: You have used many exclamation marks, which shows that you must be very anxious. Your questions are divided into two parts. The first is about "losing your health insurance card" (the following is copied from the National Health Insurance Administration we...[Read More] What to Do If You Lose Your Sleep Medication and Health Cards?
How to Address Vaccine Proof Issues in Family Medicine Visits
Hello Dr. Hsu: Today I visited the Chiayi Municipal Hospital to see a family medicine doctor, but the physician said I need to provide proof of vaccination in order to receive a prescription. However, my medical records are over 10 years old and have already been destroyed. How s...
Dr. Xu Li'an reply Family Medicine
Dear Tina, This is a challenging issue because it straddles the edge of unreasonable regulations. Medical regulations state that medical records need to be kept for only ten years, and physicians are prohibited from falsifying documents. However, foreign requirements mandate tha...[Read More] How to Address Vaccine Proof Issues in Family Medicine Visits
How to Retrieve Old Psychiatric Records When Your Clinic Closes
Hello Doctor: My friend used to visit the same clinic for treatment, and after a period of improvement, he stopped going for a long time. Now he can no longer find that clinic, which has closed down. However, he did transfer his medical records to another clinic, but he doesn...
Dr. Chen Guangpeng reply Psychiatry
Hello, A-Qing online user: Regarding the question you raised, it is indeed quite challenging, almost like a detective game. I will try to brainstorm with you. After the clinic has closed, there are two possibilities: if the physician is still practicing, you should be able to fin...[Read More] How to Retrieve Old Psychiatric Records When Your Clinic Closes
Related FAQ
(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Postpartum Recovery(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Traditional Chinese Medicine(Rehabilitation)
Medication Consultation(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Heart(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Tongue(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Sciatica(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Cough(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Body Constitution(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Menopausal Disorders(Traditional Chinese Medicine)