Is Radiation Therapy Necessary After Chemotherapy for Stage II Triple-Negative Breast Cancer? - Oncology

Share to:

In stage II triple-negative breast cancer, the necessity of radiation therapy after chemotherapy followed by surgery depends on several factors, including the size of the tumor, lymph node involvement, and the margins of the surgical resection. Radiation therapy is often recommended to reduce the risk of local recurrence, especially if there are positive lymph nodes or if the surgical margins are not


Hello, I am a stage II triple-negative breast cancer patient with no lymph node metastasis.
After 12 cycles of chemotherapy with paclitaxel, both mammography and ultrasound showed no cancer cells.
The pathology report after the lumpectomy also indicated no cancer cells.
Is there a need for radiation therapy? Thank you for your response.

A Fang, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2016/11/06

Dr. Chen Yunfang reply Oncology


Hello: You underwent chemotherapy before surgery, right? It is remarkable that no cancer cells were found in the pathology report, as the probability of this happening is usually only 30%.
You are quite fortunate, as patients with such results tend to live long and well.
Regarding your question, I believe you will definitely need to undergo radiation therapy.
This should have been mentioned before the surgery.
As long as you choose "partial" mastectomy, radiation therapy is necessary regardless of whether cancer cells are present or what stage you are in.
This rule applies universally, no matter which hospital you are treated at.
Since you only had a partial mastectomy, there is no way to guarantee that there are no residual cancer cells left in the remaining breast tissue.
To ensure complete eradication, postoperative radiation therapy is strongly recommended.
Thank you for your question!

Reply Date: 2016/11/06

More Info


In the context of Stage II triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC), the necessity of radiation therapy after chemotherapy and surgery is a nuanced topic that requires careful consideration of various factors. Given your situation, where you have undergone 12 cycles of chemotherapy with paclitaxel, followed by a lumpectomy that showed no residual cancer cells, it is indeed a positive outcome. However, the decision regarding radiation therapy should be based on established guidelines and the specifics of your case.

For Stage II TNBC, even in the absence of lymph node involvement, radiation therapy is generally recommended after breast-conserving surgery (lumpectomy). This recommendation stems from the understanding that TNBC is an aggressive subtype of breast cancer with a higher risk of local recurrence compared to other types. The primary goal of radiation therapy in this context is to eliminate any microscopic residual cancer cells that may remain in the breast tissue, which cannot be detected through imaging or pathology.

The standard practice is that if a patient opts for breast-conserving surgery, radiation therapy is typically part of the treatment plan, regardless of the pathological findings post-surgery. This is because there is no way to guarantee that all cancer cells have been removed, and radiation therapy significantly reduces the risk of local recurrence. Studies have shown that patients who receive radiation therapy after lumpectomy have better long-term outcomes compared to those who do not.

In your case, the fact that no cancer cells were found in the pathology report is indeed encouraging and suggests a favorable response to the chemotherapy. However, it does not eliminate the need for radiation therapy. The rationale is that even with a complete pathological response, there may still be residual microscopic disease that could lead to recurrence if not adequately treated with radiation.

Moreover, the timing of radiation therapy is also crucial. Ideally, radiation should begin within a few weeks after surgery to maximize its effectiveness. Delays in starting radiation therapy can potentially increase the risk of recurrence, although the exact impact of such delays can vary based on individual circumstances.

In summary, while your positive response to chemotherapy and the absence of cancer cells in the surgical specimen are excellent indicators, radiation therapy remains a critical component of the treatment plan for Stage II TNBC after lumpectomy. It is essential to discuss this with your oncologist, who can provide personalized recommendations based on your overall health, treatment response, and any other relevant factors. Following the standard treatment protocols will help ensure the best possible outcomes and minimize the risk of recurrence.

Similar Q&A

Is Local Radiation Necessary After Total Mastectomy for Stage IIB Triple-Negative Breast Cancer?

My mother, who is 77 years old, underwent a right total mastectomy and axillary lymph node dissection on January 20. The postoperative pathology report indicated triple-negative breast cancer, stage IIB T3N0M0, with a tumor size of 10 cm and a histological grade of III. There was...


Dr. Lai Yicheng reply Oncology
Dear Ms. Jojo, Thank you for your letter. I would like to respond as follows: Your mother has been diagnosed with right-sided breast cancer, T3N0M0, with a tumor size of 10 cm, grade 3, triple-negative, and stage IIB. 1. Adjuvant chemotherapy and radiotherapy are the standard ...

[Read More] Is Local Radiation Necessary After Total Mastectomy for Stage IIB Triple-Negative Breast Cancer?


Understanding Radiation Therapy After Chemotherapy for Triple-Negative Breast Cancer

Hello, my family member has been diagnosed with triple-negative breast cancer, measuring over 4 cm in the left breast. They underwent neoadjuvant chemotherapy (8 cycles), and by the 6th cycle, the ultrasound could no longer detect the tumor. They completed all 8 cycles of chemoth...


Dr. Chen Sirong reply Oncology
Ms. Zhu / 52 years old / Female 1. Does the family member only need radiation therapy for the left breast? Is it the entire left breast or just the area where the tumor was previously located? A: The radiation field for the breast includes the area below the collarbone, above ...

[Read More] Understanding Radiation Therapy After Chemotherapy for Triple-Negative Breast Cancer


Understanding Post-Breast Cancer Treatment Options and Chemotherapy Insights

Hello, Dr. Lai! I would like to inquire about the follow-up treatment for breast cancer. The report states the following: Size: 22mm, Lymph nodes: no metastasis, Margins: clear, Distant metastasis: none, Stage: IIA, Classification: Luminal B type, ER: >90%, PR: 3%, HER2: 1+, K...


Dr. Lai Yicheng reply Oncology
Dear Miss Debbie, Thank you for your letter. Here is my response: HER2 is positive [+++], which indicates that targeted therapy can reduce the risk of recurrence or metastasis by one-third. If HER2 is positive [++], further FISH testing is required to confirm whether targeted ...

[Read More] Understanding Post-Breast Cancer Treatment Options and Chemotherapy Insights


Understanding Chemotherapy for Stage IIA Breast Cancer: Key Insights and Concerns

I am about to undergo chemotherapy and I'm feeling very anxious, so I would like to ask for help! My mother is 68 years old and has a long history of hypertension (she is on medication to control it). On March 28, she underwent a modified radical mastectomy (MRM) due to brea...


Dr. Fan Sheng reply Oncology
Grade indicates the differentiation of breast cancer cells, with Grade III showing poor differentiation, meaning the cancer cells are more aggressive and have a higher likelihood of metastasis and recurrence. This is an indicator for the need for chemotherapy. The other two indic...

[Read More] Understanding Chemotherapy for Stage IIA Breast Cancer: Key Insights and Concerns


Related FAQ

Radiation Therapy

(Oncology)

Terminal Stage

(Oncology)

Lymph Node Cancer

(Oncology)

Bile Duct Cancer

(Oncology)

Side Effects Of Chemotherapy

(Oncology)

Breast Cancer

(Surgery)

Breast Cancer

(Breast and Thyroid)

Other

(Oncology)

Multiple Myeloma

(Oncology)

Aplastic Anemia

(Oncology)