Genital Herpes: Can Asymptomatic Partners Test Negative? - Urology

More Info

---

Genital herpes is primarily caused by two types of herpes simplex virus (HSV): HSV-1 and HSV-2. While HSV-1 is commonly associated with oral herpes, it can also cause genital infections, particularly in the context of oral-genital contact. Conversely, HSV-2 is more frequently linked to genital herpes.
In your case, it is indeed possible for one partner to test negative for HSV-2 while the other tests positive, even in a monogamous relationship. This discrepancy can occur for several reasons:
1. Asymptomatic Shedding: Many individuals infected with HSV-2 may not exhibit any symptoms. This phenomenon is known as asymptomatic shedding, where the virus is present on the skin or mucous membranes without causing visible lesions. As a result, the infected partner may not realize they have the virus, leading to a negative test result.

2. Timing of Testing: The timing of the test can also play a crucial role. If the partner who tested negative was recently exposed to the virus, it may take time for antibodies to develop to detectable levels. Typically, it can take several weeks to months for the body to produce enough antibodies for a reliable test result. Therefore, if the test was conducted too soon after exposure, it might yield a false negative.

3. Testing Methodology: Different tests have varying sensitivities and specificities. Some tests may be more reliable for detecting HSV-1 than HSV-2, and vice versa. If the partner was tested using a method that is less sensitive to HSV-2, it could result in a negative outcome despite an actual infection.

4. Immune Response: Individual immune responses can vary significantly. Some people may have a stronger immune response that keeps the virus in check, preventing symptoms and potentially affecting the test results. This does not mean they are not infected; rather, their immune system may be managing the virus effectively.

5. Cross-Reactivity: In some cases, tests may show cross-reactivity, where the antibodies for one type of HSV may interfere with the detection of another type. This can lead to confusing results, especially if the testing methodology is not specific enough.

In your situation, since you have tested positive for both HSV-1 and HSV-2, it is essential to consider the implications for your partner and any future sexual activity. It is advisable for your partner to consult with a healthcare provider for further evaluation, which may include retesting after a suitable period or using a different testing method to ensure accuracy.

Moreover, it is crucial to communicate openly with your partner about your diagnosis and the potential for transmission. Safe sex practices, including the use of condoms, can help reduce the risk of spreading the virus, even if one partner is asymptomatic. Additionally, antiviral medications can be prescribed to manage outbreaks and decrease the likelihood of transmission.

In summary, it is entirely plausible for one partner to test negative for HSV-2 while the other tests positive, especially in the context of asymptomatic shedding and the timing of testing. If there are concerns about the accuracy of the tests or the implications for both partners, seeking further medical advice is recommended.