Controversy Over Breath Alcohol Testing: Discrepancies in Results - Internal Medicine

More Info

---

The situation you described regarding discrepancies in breath alcohol testing raises important questions about the reliability of breathalyzers and the factors that can influence their results. In your case, you recorded a breath alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.11 mg/L using the Alco-Sensor IV, while a subsequent blood test two hours later indicated no detectable alcohol (<10 mg/dL). This discrepancy can be attributed to several factors.

Firstly, it is essential to understand how breathalyzers work. Breathalyzers estimate blood alcohol content based on the amount of alcohol present in the breath. The device measures the concentration of alcohol vapor in the breath, which is then converted into an estimated BAC. However, breath alcohol testing can be influenced by various factors, including the calibration of the device, the time elapsed since drinking, and even the individual's metabolic rate.

In your case, you consumed alcohol 13.5 hours prior to the breath test. Generally, alcohol is metabolized at a rate of approximately 0.015% BAC per hour. Given your weight of 76 kg and the amount of alcohol consumed (600 ml of 5% beer, which is roughly equivalent to 30 grams of pure alcohol), it is plausible that your body would have metabolized most, if not all, of the alcohol by the time of the breath test. This could explain why the blood test showed no detectable alcohol.

The possibility of a false positive from the breathalyzer cannot be ruled out. Factors such as residual mouth alcohol from recent consumption, the presence of certain substances (like mouthwash or breath fresheners), or even the calibration of the device can lead to inaccurate readings. Additionally, the Alco-Sensor IV, like many breathalyzers, may have a margin of error, which can contribute to discrepancies between breath and blood tests.

Moreover, the timing of the tests is crucial. The breath test was conducted shortly after drinking, while the blood test was performed two hours later. Alcohol levels can fluctuate significantly during this period, and the breathalyzer may have detected residual alcohol that was not representative of your actual BAC at the time of the blood test.

In conclusion, while the breathalyzer indicated a BAC of 0.11 mg/L, the subsequent blood test showing no alcohol suggests that the breath test may have been inaccurate. It is advisable to consider the context of alcohol consumption, the timing of tests, and the potential for device error when interpreting breath alcohol results. If you find yourself in a similar situation in the future, it may be beneficial to request a blood test immediately after a breath test to provide a more accurate assessment of your BAC. Always remember that individual metabolism, the type of alcohol consumed, and the time elapsed since drinking can significantly influence alcohol testing results.