What is the level of risk?
Dr.
Kang: After undergoing an MRI, it has been confirmed that the intervertebral discs at my sixth and seventh cervical vertebrae are compressing the nerves.
The rehabilitation specialist has advised me twice to consider surgical treatment from a neurosurgeon.
However, I lack the courage to proceed, and the rehabilitation has not yielded significant results.
Recently, I have been experiencing a sharp pain in the area around my scapula, as if a knife is cutting into me, with the pain radiating from my neck down to my left middle finger.
I feel I must seriously consider the option of surgery.
The issue is, I have not received a clear answer regarding the risks involved.
Perhaps my treating physician believes that since it is a neurosurgeon performing the surgery, he is hesitant to provide a definitive answer.
Please provide me with more information so that I can carefully consider my options.
Thank you.
Xiao Tai
Xiao Tai, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2001/02/02
Dr. Pan Yingda reply Rehabilitation
If a herniated disc is confirmed and the symptoms have not lasted long (no more than six months), surgery may be quite effective.
Our concern is not the risks of surgery (which are minimal with current techniques), but rather the fear of undergoing surgery without improvement.
If the surgery does not resolve the issue, many more aggressive treatments may no longer be viable.
If many problems, such as posture correction, are not addressed beforehand, the issues may still persist after the surgery.
Reply Date: 2001/02/02
More Info
When considering neck surgery, particularly for issues related to cervical discs that are compressing nerves, it is crucial to understand both the potential risks and the benefits of the procedure. Your concerns are valid, especially given the severity of your symptoms, which include significant pain radiating from your neck to your left hand. Here’s a comprehensive overview of what you need to know about the risks associated with neck surgery.
Understanding the Risks
1. Surgical Risks: Like any surgical procedure, neck surgery carries inherent risks. These can include:
- Infection: There is always a risk of infection at the surgical site, which can complicate recovery.
- Bleeding: Excessive bleeding during or after surgery can occur, requiring additional interventions.
- Nerve Damage: Given that the surgery involves delicate structures near the spinal cord and nerves, there is a risk of accidental nerve damage, which could lead to weakness, numbness, or pain in the arms or hands.
- Anesthesia Risks: Reactions to anesthesia can occur, which may lead to complications, especially in patients with pre-existing health conditions.
2. Postoperative Complications: After surgery, patients may experience:
- Persistent Pain: Some patients report ongoing pain even after surgery, which may be due to nerve irritation or other factors.
- Scar Tissue Formation: Scar tissue can develop around the surgical site, potentially leading to further nerve compression or pain.
- Hardware Complications: If implants (like titanium plates or screws) are used, there is a small risk they may loosen or fail, necessitating further surgery.
3. Long-term Risks:
- Adjacent Segment Disease: After surgery, the segments of the spine above or below the surgical site may experience increased stress, leading to degeneration in those areas over time.
- Chronic Pain Syndromes: Some patients may develop chronic pain syndromes post-surgery, which can be challenging to manage.
Factors Influencing Risk
- Patient Health: Your overall health, age, and any underlying conditions (like diabetes or obesity) can influence surgical outcomes and risks.
- Surgeon Experience: The skill and experience of the surgeon performing the procedure can significantly impact the likelihood of complications. It is advisable to seek a surgeon who specializes in cervical spine surgery and has a good track record.
- Type of Procedure: Different surgical techniques (e.g., anterior cervical discectomy vs. posterior approaches) have varying risk profiles. Discuss with your surgeon the specific technique they recommend and why.
Making an Informed Decision
Given your symptoms and the recommendation for surgery, it is essential to weigh the risks against the potential benefits. Surgery may alleviate your pain and improve your quality of life, especially if conservative treatments like physical therapy have not provided relief. However, if you are hesitant, consider the following steps:
1. Seek a Second Opinion: Consulting another neurosurgeon or orthopedic spine specialist can provide additional insights and help you feel more confident in your decision.
2. Discuss Non-Surgical Options: Ask your healthcare provider about alternative treatments, such as pain management strategies, physical therapy, or injections, that might help alleviate your symptoms without surgery.
3. Understand the Procedure: Request detailed information about the specific surgical procedure, including what to expect during recovery and how long it typically takes to return to normal activities.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the decision to proceed with neck surgery should be made after careful consideration of the risks, benefits, and your personal circumstances. Open communication with your healthcare team is vital to ensure you have all the information needed to make an informed choice. Remember, addressing your symptoms sooner rather than later may prevent further complications and improve your overall quality of life.
Similar Q&A
Neck Injury from Car Accident: Surgery Risks for 63-Year-Old Patient
In a car accident, the cervical vertebrae C3 and C4 have been damaged, causing nerve compression (Taichung). I am unsure which physician to consult. The patient is 63 years old, has diabetes, and fatty liver. Is surgery an option? What are the risks involved?
Dr. Zhang Yuanyi reply Neurosurgery
Dear James, 1. You can consult any neurosurgeon. 2. Whether surgery is necessary depends on the severity of the compression and the presence of related symptoms. 3. There are always risks associated with surgery. Wishing you safety and health. Sincerely, Dr. Zhang Yuan-yi ...[Read More] Neck Injury from Car Accident: Surgery Risks for 63-Year-Old Patient
Potential Complications of Throat Removal Surgery: What to Expect
Hello Doctor: My brother-in-law was diagnosed with throat cancer over a decade ago, and recently his throat has developed ulcers. The doctor has suggested a surgical removal. However, my brother-in-law currently weighs less than 40 kilograms and just underwent tracheostomy and ga...
Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Hello, due to the patient's history of multiple surgeries and the complexity of their condition, the physician has valid reasons for recommending surgery. It is advisable to discuss further with the attending physician. If there are concerns about potential complications, it...[Read More] Potential Complications of Throat Removal Surgery: What to Expect
Understanding the Risks: Neck Impacts and Brain Injury Concerns
In the past, I often played around with friends, frequently hitting each other on the back of the neck. Recently, I came across a report stating that this could lead to brain injuries, which has made me very concerned. I am unsure if this is true, and it has led me to question wh...
Dr. Shao Guoning reply Neurosurgery
Hello, if the neck is injured and the internal carotid artery or vertebral artery is affected, it can immediately cause dizziness due to ischemic symptoms. If there are no such symptoms, there is no need to worry.[Read More] Understanding the Risks: Neck Impacts and Brain Injury Concerns
Understanding Lipoma Surgery: Risks, Specialists, and Recovery
Hello Doctor, I would like to inquire about some questions regarding lipoma surgery for my father. He has a lipoma located at the center of the back of his neck, which he had checked about ten years ago. At that time, it was determined to be benign, so he did not undergo surgery ...
Dr. Chen Bingze reply Surgery
Hello, if this tumor is indeed a malignant sarcoma, it would not be possible for it to remain for over a decade; there would likely be many issues arising within a year. Tumors located in the posterior neck area are primarily addressed by surgical or plastic surgeons. The risks a...[Read More] Understanding Lipoma Surgery: Risks, Specialists, and Recovery
Related FAQ
(Rehabilitation)
Neck Pain(Rehabilitation)
Neck Stiffness(Rehabilitation)
Post-Spinal Surgery(Rehabilitation)
Shoulder And Neck Pain(Rehabilitation)
Torticollis(Rehabilitation)
Neck Strain(Orthopedics)
Post-Cervical Spine Surgery(Neurosurgery)
Electromyography(Rehabilitation)
Neck(Otolaryngology)