Hip and Thigh Muscle Issues After a Fall: Key Insights - Orthopedics

Share to:

Hip joint and thigh muscle issues?


Hello, doctor! On March 16, during my trip, I accidentally fell to the right while pushing a large suitcase on an escalator.
At that time, I was unable to stand on my right leg at all, and my family had to carry me back home.
Four hours later, my family doctor came to examine me.
While lying flat, the doctor raised my right leg to a 90-degree angle towards my chest without causing any pain or discomfort, and there was no redness or swelling.
However, when my thigh tilted slightly to the left, I felt a discomfort similar to a strain, and I was hesitant to tilt to the right.
At that time, I only had a bruise on the outer side of my right leg.
Pressing on the muscles and bones near the groin showed no abnormalities.
Therefore, the doctor only prescribed anti-inflammatory and pain relief medication for me to take as needed.
I started taking the anti-inflammatory medication on March 19 and continued until March 29, without taking any pain relief medication during that period.
From March 17 to March 29, I gradually regained strength in my right leg with the help of assistive devices, and I could stand on one leg.
I massaged my leg slightly every day and occasionally used assistive devices to walk.
However, when transitioning from a sitting position to standing, I would support myself with both hands, and occasionally, at certain angles or postures, I would feel a severe discomfort or pain near the outer side of my right leg connecting to my hip, as if a muscle was being pulled.
Once I stood straight, the pain would subside, but I found it increasingly difficult to exert strength in my right leg.
From March 29 to March 31, I stopped taking the anti-inflammatory medication.
I am unsure if this is the reason, but my right leg has become increasingly weak, although I can slightly lift my leg and move without joint pain.
Currently, I feel a sensation similar to dislocation.
I have several questions: 1) Would an MRI help in understanding my condition? I am currently abroad.
2) What do you think is my problem? Is it serious? 3) Can resting lead to gradual recovery? 4) Do I need to continue taking anti-inflammatory medication? 5) My right leg muscles have noticeably atrophied; will this affect my walking in the future? Can massage slow down muscle atrophy? 6) Should I return to Taiwan for medical treatment as soon as possible? I am scheduled to return to Taiwan on April 16 and urgently need your response.
Thank you very much!

Liu Xiaojie, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2018/03/31

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics


1.
It may not be necessary to do so.

2.
A contusion of the right hip is the most likely diagnosis.

3.
It is possible.

4.
If it is not very painful, medication may not be needed.

5.
Gradually resuming movement will help the muscles recover.

6.
It is advisable to seek medical attention as soon as possible.

Reply Date: 2018/03/31

More Info


Understanding hip and thigh muscle issues after a fall is crucial, especially for someone who has experienced a significant injury. Based on your description, it seems you have encountered a complex situation involving potential muscle strain, possible ligament involvement, and the effects of immobilization on muscle atrophy. Let’s break down your concerns and provide insights into each of your questions.

1. MRI Utility: An MRI can be incredibly helpful in assessing soft tissue injuries, including muscles, tendons, and ligaments. Given that you are experiencing discomfort and a sensation similar to dislocation, an MRI could reveal any underlying issues such as muscle tears, ligament sprains, or even joint effusion that may not be visible on an X-ray. If you have access to MRI services while abroad, it may be worth considering, especially if your symptoms persist or worsen.

2. Nature of the Problem: From your description, it appears that you may be dealing with a combination of muscle strain and possibly some instability in the hip joint. The fact that you feel discomfort when moving your leg in certain positions suggests that there may be some soft tissue involvement. The absence of swelling and bruising is a good sign, but the persistent discomfort and difficulty in bearing weight indicate that this is not a trivial injury. It is essential to monitor your symptoms closely.

3. Rest and Recovery: Rest is a fundamental part of recovery from any musculoskeletal injury. It allows the body to heal and reduces the risk of further injury. However, complete immobilization can lead to muscle atrophy, which you are already noticing. Gentle range-of-motion exercises and gradual weight-bearing activities, as tolerated, can help maintain muscle function and prevent stiffness. It’s crucial to strike a balance between rest and activity.

4. Anti-inflammatory Medication: If you are experiencing significant discomfort, continuing anti-inflammatory medication may be beneficial. These medications can help reduce inflammation and pain, allowing you to engage in rehabilitation exercises more comfortably. However, if you have concerns about taking these medications, especially if you have a history of adverse reactions, consult with a healthcare provider for alternatives.

5. Muscle Atrophy and Walking: Muscle atrophy can indeed affect your walking ability, as the muscles play a critical role in stabilizing and moving the leg. Engaging in light exercises and physical therapy can help mitigate muscle loss. Massage may provide temporary relief and improve circulation, but it is not a substitute for active rehabilitation exercises. Focus on gentle stretching and strengthening exercises as you progress.

6. Returning to Taiwan for Medical Care: If your symptoms do not improve or worsen, it would be prudent to seek medical attention as soon as possible. Given that you are experiencing significant discomfort and potential muscle atrophy, a thorough evaluation by a healthcare professional is essential. If you can manage your symptoms and perform basic activities, you might consider waiting until your scheduled return. However, if you feel that your condition is deteriorating, prioritize your health and seek care sooner.

In summary, your situation requires careful monitoring and a balanced approach to rest and rehabilitation. If possible, seek imaging studies to clarify the extent of your injury, and consider consulting a healthcare provider for tailored advice on managing your symptoms and facilitating recovery. Remember, your health should always come first, and addressing these issues promptly can help ensure a smoother recovery process.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Left Hip and Thigh Pain: Causes and Treatment Options

I have been experiencing pain in my left hip and thigh after squatting for too long or standing up straight after climbing high. I can't stand up immediately and feel like I might fall. I'm not sure if it's nerve pain or muscle pain. Sometimes, I just need to lie f...


Dr. Yin Xinbei reply Rehabilitation
Based on the description, it is possible that there is inflammation of the thigh muscles/tendons, but sciatica cannot be ruled out. Further clinical examination is necessary for a more accurate diagnosis, and it is recommended to schedule an appointment with a rehabilitation medi...

[Read More] Understanding Left Hip and Thigh Pain: Causes and Treatment Options


Understanding Hip Pain After a Fall: Rehabilitation Options for Seniors

Hello, Doctor! My mother is nearly 60 years old and two weeks ago, she fell in the bathroom, landing hard on the floor. She immediately experienced a significant bruise on her hip but did not pay much attention to it. However, two weeks later, she is now experiencing pain from he...


Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
1. It may be piriformis syndrome (a small muscle that externally rotates the femur) or sciatica due to lumbar intervertebral disc herniation. 2. Both of these conditions can be evaluated and managed by a rehabilitation specialist. 3. Treatment typically includes lumbar tracti...

[Read More] Understanding Hip Pain After a Fall: Rehabilitation Options for Seniors


Effective Rehabilitation Techniques for Thigh Pain After Hip Surgery

Hello, Doctor. I was in a car accident in mid-February and underwent a hip joint reconstruction surgery. The doctor informed me that no artificial joint was installed; only screws and plates were used. It has been over three months since the surgery. I had a follow-up appointment...


Dr. Zheng Shunping reply Rehabilitation
Hello: This issue was addressed by Dr. Hsu Chen-Jung from the Rehabilitation Department of Taipei Hospital on June 1, 2004. The response is as follows: Mr. Yulong, you have sustained a comminuted fracture of the hip joint due to a car accident and have undergone internal fixation...

[Read More] Effective Rehabilitation Techniques for Thigh Pain After Hip Surgery


Why Am I Limping After a Thigh Fracture? Understanding Recovery

Hello, I fractured my thigh on June 4th, and it has been three months since then. I can now walk with crutches, but my walking is still unsteady. I am currently undergoing rehabilitation. I would like to know if I will continue to walk this way in the future.


Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, postoperative limping may be primarily due to changes in leg length or muscle weakness. Generally, a typical femoral fracture should not result in a change in leg length (please consult your attending physician for confirmation). It is possible that muscle strength is insu...

[Read More] Why Am I Limping After a Thigh Fracture? Understanding Recovery


Related FAQ

Post-Femoral Fracture Surgery

(Orthopedics)

Leg Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Fall

(Orthopedics)

Dislocation

(Orthopedics)

Tibia And Fibula Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Legs

(Orthopedics)

Ankle Fracture Recovery

(Orthopedics)

Sports Injury

(Orthopedics)

Post-Fracture Rehabilitation

(Orthopedics)

Fasciitis

(Orthopedics)