Managing Knee Degeneration in Elderly Patients: Alternatives to Surgery

Knee degeneration, after hyaluronic acid injection?

Hello, doctor.
My grandmother is 83 years old and suffers from Parkinson's disease and severe knee degeneration.
She has been regularly visiting the clinic and taking medications prescribed by both orthopedic and neurology specialists.
Previously, she received hyaluronic acid injections in her knee, but after more than a year, she stopped the treatments.

1.
Recently, she has been experiencing severe lower limb edema and some bruising.
I'm unsure if this is related to her knee issues or if further examinations are needed.

2.
Given her poor health, I am concerned that undergoing knee replacement surgery may be too much for her body to handle.
Are there other methods to address or alleviate her knee problems, or is knee replacement the best option? Thank you for your response.

An An, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2018/08/23

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics

1.
You may need to consult with doctors from other specialties.

2.
You can try platelet-rich plasma (PRP) therapy, but if your overall health is good, you might consider undergoing surgery.

Reply Date: 2018/08/23

More Info

Managing knee degeneration in elderly patients, especially those with multiple comorbidities, is a complex issue that requires a careful balance between the risks and benefits of surgical and non-surgical interventions. In the case of your grandmother, who is 83 years old and has Parkinson's disease along with severe knee degeneration, it is crucial to consider her overall health status and the potential risks associated with surgical procedures.

1. Understanding the Symptoms: The recent onset of severe lower limb swelling and bruising could be indicative of several issues. While it may be related to her knee problems, it could also stem from other causes such as venous insufficiency, heart issues, or even medication side effects. It is essential to consult her healthcare provider for a thorough evaluation to determine the underlying cause of these symptoms. This may involve imaging studies, blood tests, or referrals to specialists such as a cardiologist or a vascular surgeon.

2. Surgical Considerations: Given your grandmother's age and health conditions, including Parkinson's disease, the decision to undergo knee replacement surgery should be made with caution. While knee replacement can significantly improve quality of life and reduce pain, the risks associated with surgery, particularly in elderly patients with comorbidities, can be substantial. These risks include complications from anesthesia, infection, blood clots, and prolonged recovery times. The anesthesiologist's assessment of her ability to tolerate surgery is critical, and if they have indicated a high risk, it may be prudent to explore alternative treatments.

3. Non-Surgical Alternatives: There are several non-surgical options available to manage knee degeneration and alleviate pain:
- Physical Therapy: A tailored physical therapy program can help strengthen the muscles around the knee, improve flexibility, and enhance overall mobility. This can be particularly beneficial for patients with Parkinson's disease, as it may also help with balance and coordination.

- Medications: Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) can help manage pain and inflammation. However, given your grandmother's age and potential kidney issues, it is essential to consult her physician before continuing or starting any new medications.

- Injections: While she has previously received hyaluronic acid injections, other options such as corticosteroid injections may provide temporary relief from inflammation and pain. These injections can be repeated periodically, but their effectiveness may diminish over time.

- Assistive Devices: The use of braces or orthotic devices can provide support to the knee and improve function. Additionally, using a cane or walker can help with mobility and reduce the risk of falls, especially in patients with Parkinson's disease.

- Lifestyle Modifications: Weight management, if applicable, can significantly reduce the stress on the knees. Encouraging low-impact exercises such as swimming or cycling can also be beneficial.

- Alternative Therapies: Some patients find relief through acupuncture, massage therapy, or other complementary therapies. While the evidence for these treatments varies, they may provide additional pain relief and improve quality of life.

4. Decision-Making: Ultimately, the decision regarding whether to proceed with knee replacement surgery or pursue alternative treatments should involve a comprehensive discussion with her healthcare team. This should include her primary care physician, orthopedic surgeon, and any specialists involved in her care. They can provide insights into her specific health status, the potential benefits and risks of surgery, and the effectiveness of alternative treatments.

In conclusion, while knee replacement surgery can be a viable option for many patients, it is not the only solution, especially for elderly patients with complex health issues. A multidisciplinary approach that includes careful assessment, non-surgical interventions, and ongoing monitoring can help manage knee degeneration effectively while minimizing risks.

Similar Q&A

Knee Pain in Seniors: Alternatives to Surgery for Joint Issues

I would like to ask a question for my grandmother. She says that her knees are very painful, especially when standing, walking, or going up and down stairs. Previously, she saw a doctor who indicated that it was due to joint degeneration. Surgery was initially an option, but my g...

Dr. Shi Qiming reply Orthopedics
Hello: We recommend that you visit our orthopedic outpatient clinic for further examination and evaluation. It is not that an 80-year-old cannot undergo surgery, but rather that the patient's individual health condition needs to be assessed before making a decision. Thank yo...

Preparing for Joint Replacement: Insights on Osteoarthritis and Surgery

Hello, Doctor. My mother is experiencing knee pain at the age of 50 due to her excessive weight and frequent travel abroad. After getting an X-ray, the doctor informed us that she is in the advanced stage of joint degeneration. I noticed that the cartilage is completely gone (the...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
For patients over sixty years old with arthritis severe enough to require surgery, it is essential to first determine if the patient has any other underlying conditions, such as diabetes, hypertension, or heart disease. If such conditions are present, they should be treated or ma...

Essential Guide to Knee Replacement Surgery and Post-Op Care for Seniors

My grandfather has been experiencing knee pain and weakness for a long time. He visited an orthopedic doctor, who recommended scheduling surgery. He is expected to return to the hospital after some time. My grandfather enjoys gardening, and to avoid boredom, he insists on visitin...

Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello Xiaoyu: No amount of health supplements can compare to the filial piety of a granddaughter. In fact, there are no health supplements that have proven therapeutic effects for degenerative knee osteoarthritis. I suggest that you take the time to visit home more often or call ...

Managing Osteoarthritis in Diabetic Patients: Surgery and Alternatives

Dr. Shi's father is 70 years old and has a long-standing history of degenerative arthritis in his left knee, which has resulted in atrophy and deformity. He underwent a total knee replacement on his right knee 15 years ago. Due to his current conditions of diabetes and gout,...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
1. Diabetic patients can undergo surgery as long as their blood sugar is well controlled, typically around 150 or below. 2. An age of 70 is not considered high; as long as other bodily functions are adequate, the success rate is generally over 90%. 3. Rehabilitation after sur...