Water-cooled radiofrequency ablation for lower back pain?
Hello Doctor: My mother fell at the end of August last year and was diagnosed with a compression fracture of the first lumbar vertebra.
She underwent a cryoablation procedure immediately, and on the same day post-surgery, she experienced severe left lumbar pain.
The doctor assessed it as a muscle strain and administered anti-inflammatory and pain relief injections before discharging her.
Since her discharge, my mother's lower back and back pain have not improved.
During this time, she consulted a neurosurgeon, and an MRI did not reveal any abnormalities.
She also underwent extracorporeal shockwave therapy, which initially provided significant pain relief, but after 1-2 weeks, the pain returned.
In early December, she began seeing a rehabilitation specialist and started rehabilitation (the doctor suspected nerve compression).
She has undergone over 10 sessions of spinal traction and electrical stimulation therapy, but her back pain has worsened, making it impossible for her to sit or stand; she can only lie flat.
On February 13, she underwent a cryoanalgesia procedure (as recommended by the neurosurgeon), and now, a week later, there has been no improvement in her back pain.
The treating physician mentioned that it may take two weeks for her back pain to gradually improve.
My questions are: 1.
How long after the cryoanalgesia procedure should we expect to see results, and is there a possibility of treatment failure? 2.
Given my mother's severe back pain, what further steps can be taken?
Ms. Tseng, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2019/02/22
Dr. Lai Zhaokang reply Neurosurgery
Hello: 1.
Water-cooled radiofrequency ablation is primarily used for treating lumbar disc herniation, but it can also be applied in pain nerve block procedures.
2.
Low-temperature bone cement is injected into vertebral fractures to accelerate the stabilization of the fracture.
Both procedures are excellent minimally invasive treatments; however, they target different pathological conditions and may yield varying results depending on the physician performing them.
3.
I recommend that you take your mother to another spinal specialist for evaluation to identify the source of her pain, which will allow for targeted treatment.
4.
Even within the same specialty and hospital, different physicians may have varying perspectives, diagnoses, treatment approaches, and surgical techniques.
Best wishes.
// Dr.
Lai Chao-Kang, Director of Spinal Neurosurgery, Changhua Hospital.
Reply Date: 2019/02/22
More Info
Water-cooled radiofrequency ablation (RFA) is a minimally invasive procedure used to manage chronic pain, particularly in cases where conservative treatments have failed. This technique involves using radiofrequency energy to target and disrupt nerve pathways that transmit pain signals. In your mother's case, the procedure was performed after a series of treatments that did not yield significant relief from her chronic back pain following a vertebral compression fracture.
1. Timeframe for Effectiveness and Potential for Failure:
The effectiveness of water-cooled RFA can vary from patient to patient. Generally, patients may start to notice improvements in their pain levels within a few days to a couple of weeks post-procedure. However, it is not uncommon for some patients to experience a delay in pain relief, particularly if there is significant underlying pathology or if the nerve pathways are particularly resistant to treatment. In your mother's case, the physician indicated that it might take up to two weeks for her pain to begin to improve.
As for the potential for treatment failure, while RFA is generally effective, there are instances where patients may not experience the desired relief. Factors contributing to this can include the complexity of the underlying condition, the presence of additional pain sources, or even the technique used during the procedure. It is essential to maintain open communication with the treating physician to monitor progress and discuss any concerns.
2. Next Steps for Severe Back Pain:
Given that your mother has not experienced any improvement in her back pain one week after the RFA, it is crucial to consider further evaluation. Here are some potential next steps:
- Follow-Up with the Physician: It is important to follow up with the physician who performed the RFA. They may recommend imaging studies, such as an MRI or CT scan, to assess for any complications or to evaluate the status of the spine and surrounding structures.
- Pain Management Specialist: If the current treatment plan is not effective, consulting with a pain management specialist may provide additional options. They can explore other interventions, such as additional nerve blocks, spinal cord stimulation, or alternative medications.
- Physical Therapy: If not already part of the treatment plan, a tailored physical therapy program focusing on strengthening and stabilizing the back may help alleviate pain and improve function.
- Multidisciplinary Approach: Sometimes, a multidisciplinary approach involving various specialists, including orthopedic surgeons, neurologists, and rehabilitation experts, can provide a more comprehensive treatment plan.
- Consideration of Surgical Options: If conservative measures continue to fail and if there is significant structural damage or nerve compression, surgical options may need to be reconsidered. This could involve decompression surgery or other interventions aimed at addressing the root cause of the pain.
In conclusion, while water-cooled RFA can be an effective treatment for chronic back pain, it is essential to monitor your mother's progress closely and maintain communication with her healthcare team. If her pain persists or worsens, further evaluation and alternative treatment options should be explored to ensure she receives the best possible care.
Similar Q&A
Effective Treatment Options for Chronic Buttock Pain: Is Radiofrequency Ablation the Answer?
Hello Dr. Su, I have been experiencing pain in my buttocks for over a year. The pain occurs only when sitting and is absent when I am not sitting. I have been diagnosed with Myofascial Pain and have undergone all forms of physical therapy, including heat therapy, traction, shortw...
Dr. Su Hongci reply Rehabilitation
Myofascial Pain Syndrome (MPS) is simply defined as the phenomenon of muscle pain in the skeletal muscles due to "overuse," along with various accompanying clinical symptoms. However, this condition is not an inflammatory response of the muscle itself; rather, it is cau...[Read More] Effective Treatment Options for Chronic Buttock Pain: Is Radiofrequency Ablation the Answer?
Exploring Pulsed Radiofrequency Electromagnetic Needling for Pain Relief
Hello Dr. Lai, my right wrist has been in pain since I was injured on September 15, 2011. It still hurts and I cannot lift heavy objects. I often feel nerve pain. Can pulsed radiofrequency electromagnetic therapy and thermal coagulation be used to treat my right ankle, which has ...
Dr. Lai Zhaokang reply Neurosurgery
Hello: Based on your description, if there are no fractures, the injury likely involves the surrounding tissues of the wrist and ankle joints, such as cartilage, ligaments, muscles, and tendons (of course, peripheral nerves may also be affected). The primary treatment is usually ...[Read More] Exploring Pulsed Radiofrequency Electromagnetic Needling for Pain Relief
Understanding High-Frequency Thermal Coagulation in Neurosurgery
Hello, doctor: What is the treatment method known as "high-frequency thermal coagulation"? I have cervical osteophytes, but I am unsure if this technique is well-established in Taiwan. Does it carry any risks? Please provide your insights. Thank you!
Dr. Shao Guoning reply Neurosurgery
Hello: In response to your question: The dorsal branch of the spinal nerve innervates the adjacent joints and intervertebral discs after exiting the spinal cord. A herniated intervertebral disc can cause referred pain when it does not compress the nerve root, often due to irritat...[Read More] Understanding High-Frequency Thermal Coagulation in Neurosurgery
Understanding Prostate Inflammation Treatment: Magnetic Chairs vs. Infrared Devices
Quote: Taitung Hospital / Urology / Dr. Hsu Wei-Kai: "The treatment range of the magnetic wave chair is quite limited, approximately 8-12 cm above the surface of the chair, with the effectiveness decreasing from the center. Generally, the effective range is about a 10 cm cir...
Dr. Xu Weikai reply Urology
Ah Hong: Hello, of course, some patients experience relief. I am not sure if magnetic wave chairs are superior to far infrared therapy. In this regard, rehabilitation physicians have more experience. Note: I personally have not used any far infrared devices. The so-called cocktai...[Read More] Understanding Prostate Inflammation Treatment: Magnetic Chairs vs. Infrared Devices
Related FAQ
(Neurosurgery)
Herniated Disc(Neurosurgery)
Cramps(Neurosurgery)
Lower Back Pain(Neurology)
Posterior Head(Neurosurgery)
Trigeminal Neuralgia(Neurosurgery)
Severe Palmar Hyperhidrosis(Neurosurgery)
Lumbar Spondylolisthesis(Neurosurgery)
Family Medicine(Neurosurgery)
Neurofibroma(Surgery)