Does Sitting Cross-Legged Cause Scoliosis and Leg Length Discrepancy?

Scoliosis, leg length discrepancy, and sitting posture are related?

Recently, I came across a news report suggesting that children should avoid crossing their legs (sitting with one leg over the other) because it could lead to scoliosis and leg length discrepancies.
Is this really that serious? In today's era, there is a strong emphasis on various forms of education and proper posture.
I remember that in my time, we were simply told to sit up straight, and parents didn't pay as much attention to these details.
Nowadays, there are many concerns, and I worry about whether my child might develop scoliosis or leg length discrepancies in the future.
However, it's really challenging to get children to sit properly.
Is crossing legs or sitting with one leg over the other truly severe enough to cause scoliosis and leg length discrepancies? Thank you, doctor.

Miss Wang, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2019/10/21

Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics

Is sitting cross-legged or with one leg over the other really serious enough to cause scoliosis and leg length discrepancy? Scoliosis can occur due to 1.
congenital neuromuscular disorders, 2.
degenerative scoliosis, and the most common type is idiopathic scoliosis during adolescence.
None of these conditions are caused by sitting cross-legged; rather, sitting in this position can lead to unilateral muscle tension imbalances, which may result in pain.
There are many causes for leg length discrepancy, including congenital vascular abnormalities and acquired fractures, but these are not related to posture.
Thank you.

Reply Date: 2019/10/21

More Info

Sitting cross-legged, or "crisscross" sitting, is a common posture among children and adults alike. Concerns have been raised regarding its potential impact on spinal health, particularly in relation to scoliosis (a lateral curvature of the spine) and leg length discrepancy. However, the relationship between sitting posture and these conditions is not as straightforward as it may seem.

Firstly, scoliosis is typically a complex condition influenced by a variety of factors, including genetics, neuromuscular conditions, and structural anomalies. While poor posture can contribute to discomfort and may exacerbate existing spinal issues, there is no conclusive evidence that sitting cross-legged directly causes scoliosis. In fact, many individuals with scoliosis do not exhibit any specific postural habits that can be definitively linked to the development of the condition.
Similarly, leg length discrepancy can arise from various causes, including congenital factors, trauma, or conditions affecting bone growth. While sitting in a cross-legged position might lead to temporary asymmetries in muscle tension or joint positioning, it is unlikely to result in a permanent leg length discrepancy. The human body is remarkably adaptable, and temporary postures typically do not lead to long-term structural changes.

That said, there are some considerations to keep in mind regarding sitting cross-legged. Prolonged periods in this position may lead to discomfort or strain in the hips, knees, and lower back, particularly if the individual has pre-existing musculoskeletal issues. Additionally, children may find it challenging to maintain proper spinal alignment while sitting in this position for extended periods. This could potentially lead to muscle imbalances or discomfort, which might be misinterpreted as a more serious condition.

Encouraging children to adopt a variety of sitting positions can be beneficial. Alternating between sitting cross-legged, sitting with feet flat on the ground, and standing can promote better posture and reduce the risk of discomfort. Teaching children about proper ergonomics and the importance of movement throughout the day is crucial. Regular breaks to stand, stretch, and change positions can help mitigate any potential negative effects of prolonged sitting.

In conclusion, while it is important to encourage good posture and body mechanics in children, the fear that sitting cross-legged will lead to scoliosis or leg length discrepancies may be overstated. Instead, fostering an environment where children can move freely and adopt various postures will likely be more beneficial for their overall musculoskeletal health. If there are concerns about a child's posture or any signs of discomfort, it is advisable to consult with a healthcare professional, such as a pediatrician or physical therapist, who can provide tailored advice and interventions.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Leg Length Discrepancy vs. Scoliosis: Expert Insights

Dear Director Chen: It seems that I have a leg length discrepancy. Two days ago, I experienced lower back pain and visited a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner for spinal manipulation. The practitioner mentioned that my legs are of unequal length. However, a friend with a ...

Dr. Chen Xianchang reply Rehabilitation
Hello, sir: Thank you for your inquiry. Here are the responses to your questions and some recommendations: 1. To determine if the lengths of both legs are equal, measure from the anterior superior iliac spine (ASIS) while lying flat, extending through the center of the knee to ...

Understanding Scoliosis and Leg Length Discrepancy: Treatment Options and Concerns

I have scoliosis of about 30 degrees, which has also resulted in leg length discrepancy. Recently, I found some information online regarding non-invasive spinal manipulation therapy (which seems to involve electrical treatment and wearing a brace). Can this truly correct scoliosi...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Scoliosis occurring in the thoracolumbar region may lead to pelvic tilt, resulting in discrepancies in leg length. Correcting the scoliosis can improve the phenomenon of leg length inequality. Both the theoretical and clinical methods you mentioned lack significant evidence of ef...

Understanding Hip and Lower Back Discomfort: Causes and Solutions

Hello, I have a dull, occasional mild pain around my left hip joint extending to the lower left back. I usually like to sit cross-legged or elevate my leg, and I tend to shift my weight to the left. Could this be related? Are there any ways to improve it? The symptoms are quite m...

Dr. Wang Zhaomin reply Rehabilitation
Sitting cross-legged or with legs crossed is not a good sitting posture and may lead to musculoskeletal issues. It is important to adopt a proper sitting posture, use cushions, and choose an appropriate chair to provide adequate support for the lower back. This can help prevent e...

Understanding Inability to Cross Legs: Causes and Treatment Options

The inability to sit cross-legged from a young age may be due to various factors, including anatomical variations or musculoskeletal issues. The observation of your legs appearing to be in an "external rotation" or "duck-footed" position could indicate a condi...

Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello: In response to your inquiry regarding your hip and knee joints, I recommend that you consult an orthopedic physician nearby. I believe you will receive the best answers to your concerns. Wishing you all the best! Dr. Li Wen-Lin, Orthopedic Department, Keelung Hospital.