Depression and Panic Disorder: Medical Evaluation Insights - Psychiatry

Share to:

Hello, doctor?


Hello, doctor.
Recently, I visited a psychiatrist who diagnosed me with a major depressive episode and panic disorder.
Since I sought help only about a week after the onset of my symptoms, I have seen some improvement after starting medication.
However, I am unsure if my condition meets the criteria for exemption from military service.
If I go for a re-evaluation and am not experiencing symptoms at that time, how will the doctor determine whether I had such symptoms? Thank you, doctor!

taih, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2002/11/29

Dr. Zheng Jingming reply Psychiatry


Hello: In addition to observing symptoms, physicians will also consider the patient's medical history.
The duration of treatment and current condition have not been specified, and the situation may vary.
Please refer to the following regulations: For major depressive disorder, if a patient has been treated for over one year (with complete medical records) and has not recovered, resulting in significant social functioning impairment, they are classified as "immune"; if the treatment has been ongoing for less than one year, they are classified as "indeterminate" and require re-evaluation.
For neuroses (including panic disorder), if a patient has been treated for over one year (with complete medical records) and has not recovered, affecting their daily life and work, they are classified as "immune"; if the treatment has been ongoing for less than one year, they are classified as "indeterminate" and require re-evaluation.
Department of Psychiatry, Qishan Hospital, Dr.
Cheng Ching-Ming.

Reply Date: 2002/11/29

More Info


Hello! Thank you for reaching out with your concerns regarding your recent diagnosis of major depressive disorder and panic disorder. It’s great to hear that you’ve already seen some improvement with medication. Understanding the nuances of these conditions and how they relate to medical evaluations, especially in the context of potential disability or exemption from certain responsibilities, is important.

Firstly, it’s essential to recognize that both major depressive disorder and panic disorder can significantly impact daily functioning. Major depressive disorder is characterized by persistent feelings of sadness, hopelessness, and a lack of interest or pleasure in activities once enjoyed. Panic disorder, on the other hand, involves recurrent and unexpected panic attacks, which are sudden periods of intense fear or discomfort that can include physical symptoms like heart palpitations, shortness of breath, dizziness, and feelings of impending doom.

In terms of medical evaluations for disability or exemption, the process typically involves a comprehensive assessment by a qualified healthcare professional. This assessment may include a detailed history of your symptoms, their duration, and how they have affected your daily life. The healthcare provider will likely use standardized diagnostic criteria, such as those outlined in the DSM-5 (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders), to evaluate your condition.

If you are undergoing a re-evaluation and you are currently symptom-free or experiencing significantly reduced symptoms, the healthcare provider will consider several factors:
1. History of Symptoms: They will review your medical history, including the onset, duration, and severity of your depressive and panic symptoms. Even if you are not currently experiencing symptoms, a documented history of these conditions can be crucial.

2. Treatment Response: The provider will assess how well you have responded to treatment, including medication and any therapy you may have received. Improvement in symptoms is a positive sign, but it does not negate the previous diagnosis.

3. Functional Impairment: They will evaluate how your conditions have impacted your ability to function in daily life, including work, social interactions, and self-care. If your symptoms have led to significant impairment in these areas in the past, this will be taken into account.

4. Current Mental State: During the evaluation, the provider will assess your current mental state. They may use questionnaires or structured interviews to gauge your mood, anxiety levels, and overall mental health.

5. Documentation: Having thorough documentation from your treating physician about your diagnosis, treatment plan, and progress can support your case during the evaluation process. This documentation can include notes from therapy sessions, medication logs, and any other relevant medical records.

Regarding your concern about whether your current symptom-free status might affect your diagnosis, it’s important to understand that mental health conditions can be episodic. Many individuals experience periods of remission where symptoms are minimal or absent, followed by episodes of exacerbation. This cyclical nature is well recognized in the field of mental health.

If you are concerned about how your diagnosis might affect your eligibility for certain exemptions or benefits, it would be beneficial to discuss this directly with your healthcare provider. They can provide guidance tailored to your specific situation and help you understand how your diagnosis and treatment history align with the criteria for any exemptions you are considering.

In summary, while being symptom-free at the time of re-evaluation may influence the assessment, your history of major depressive disorder and panic disorder, along with the impact these conditions have had on your life, will be crucial in determining your overall status. Open communication with your healthcare provider will be key in navigating this process. Wishing you continued improvement and support on your journey to better mental health!

Similar Q&A

Understanding Anxiety, Panic, and Depression: A Student's Struggle

I am a fifth-year design student in college, and I have been experiencing significant academic pressure lately. About two weeks ago, I had an emotional outburst due to stress, which led to intense anxiety in the following days, making me fearful of pressure. This anxiety has affe...


Dr. Qiu Junda reply Psychiatry
Hello. Currently, it seems that we should maintain the diagnosis of Adjustment Disorder with Anxiety and Depressed Mood. This means that the emotional responses arising from stress (Stress-Related Adjustment Disorder) can include symptoms such as compulsions, anxiety, panic, and ...

[Read More] Understanding Anxiety, Panic, and Depression: A Student's Struggle


Overcoming Panic and Anxiety Without Medication: A Personal Journey

Doctor, I went to the hospital and was diagnosed with panic disorder and anxiety, but I don't want to take medication because it makes things worse and I can't even sleep. I really want to overcome my psychological barriers on my own! However, it seems like my body is n...


Dr. Chen Wenyu reply Psychiatry
Hello, Sky: In response to the two letters regarding autonomic nervous system disorders and neuroses, it is important to note that these conditions often involve some degree of depression or anxiety, and therefore, these terms are no longer commonly used in psychiatry. What makes...

[Read More] Overcoming Panic and Anxiety Without Medication: A Personal Journey


Understanding Anxiety and Depression: How Are Mental Health Issues Diagnosed?

Hello, doctor. I have a somewhat unconventional question. I discovered that I have severe sleep apnea and underwent surgery, but the improvement has not been sufficient; I still feel fatigued, excessively sleepy, with swollen eyes, a heavy head, and a sense of mental emptiness an...


Dr. Liang Sunyuan reply Psychiatry
Hello, both depression and anxiety disorders have their diagnostic criteria, which include the patient's subjective feelings as well as objectively observable signs. Physical and psychological symptoms often influence each other; when mood is low, the body may also feel fati...

[Read More] Understanding Anxiety and Depression: How Are Mental Health Issues Diagnosed?


Understanding Stress, Anxiety, and Tension: When to Seek Help

Hello, doctor. I would like to consult whether my following conditions are influenced by a mental health issue and whether I should seek medical help for improvement. I apologize for the lengthy content... I easily feel nervous and stressed, experiencing symptoms such as hand tre...


Dr. Zhang Gengjia reply Psychiatry
Dear Selina, From your description in your letter, I can clearly sense your discomfort and anxiety. It is difficult to determine the exact nature of your discomfort and diagnosis at this moment, but it is likely related to anxiety combined with depression or anxiety disorders. I...

[Read More] Understanding Stress, Anxiety, and Tension: When to Seek Help


Related FAQ

Panic Disorder

(Psychiatry)

Depression

(Psychiatry)

Anxiety

(Psychiatry)

Emotions

(Psychiatry)

Stress

(Psychiatry)

Psychosomatic Disorders

(Psychiatry)

Ptsd

(Psychiatry)

Emotional Instability

(Psychiatry)

Breathing

(Psychiatry)

Neurotic Disorder

(Psychiatry)