Diabetes Treatment Options: Medication vs. Lifestyle Changes

Diabetes Treatment Guidelines

Hello Dr.
Lee,
My basic information is as follows: I have a family history of diabetes and was diagnosed with diabetes two years ago, with a fasting blood sugar of 113 and an HbA1c of 7.1 at that time.
My weight was in the 80s (kg).
Since then, I have been managing my condition with medication, diet, and exercise, and my levels have improved to the 100s/60s/60s.
Recently, I noticed that some individuals with similar or even worse numbers at diagnosis were advised by their doctors to manage their condition with diet and exercise alone.
I even saw someone share their experience of having a fasting blood sugar of 200 and an HbA1c of 8.x, and after six months of medication, diet, and exercise, their doctor said they could stop taking medication.
This has led me to feel confused about my diabetes treatment plan, so I would like to ask you:
1.
I started with medication management and was unaware of other options.
Why is there such a divergence (not needing medication)? Is it similar to the difference between a conservative approach and an aggressive approach?
2.
My current doctor believes that if I lose a bit more weight, I can reduce my Metformin dosage from two pills a day to one, but I will likely not stop using medication to assist in blood sugar control.
However, I see others managing well without medication, which is quite tempting.
Would you recommend seeking another doctor's evaluation of my situation?
I apologize for the somewhat disorganized questions; the temptation of possibly not needing medication is quite strong...
Thank you for taking the time to respond!

Panghuang, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2020/09/02

Dr. Li Jian reply Internal Medicine

1.
Lifestyle modifications combined with medication management yield better results; relying solely on diet and exercise to control blood sugar is more likely to fail.
Having medication assistance makes it easier to achieve targets.

2.
If significant weight loss can be achieved, there is indeed a chance to reverse diabetes, and even discontinue blood sugar medications.
Wishing you success in your weight loss journey!

Reply Date: 2020/09/02

More Info

Hello! Thank you for your thoughtful questions regarding diabetes treatment options and the differences in management strategies. It's great to see that you're actively engaged in understanding your health and the various approaches to managing diabetes.

1. Medication vs. Lifestyle Changes: The management of diabetes can indeed vary significantly between individuals, and this often leads to different treatment approaches. In your case, starting with medication (Metformin) was a common and effective choice, especially given your initial blood sugar levels and HbA1c (7.1%). Metformin is typically the first-line medication for type 2 diabetes because it helps lower blood sugar levels and has additional benefits such as weight loss and cardiovascular protection.

On the other hand, some individuals may be able to manage their diabetes effectively through lifestyle changes alone, particularly if their blood sugar levels are not excessively high at diagnosis. This approach often involves significant dietary modifications, regular physical activity, and weight management. The decision to use medication or rely solely on lifestyle changes can depend on several factors, including the severity of diabetes at diagnosis, individual health conditions, and personal preferences.

The difference you noted between "gentle" and "aggressive" approaches to treatment reflects the varying philosophies in diabetes management. Some healthcare providers may prioritize medication early on to achieve better control, while others may emphasize lifestyle changes first, especially if the patient is motivated and capable of making those changes. Ultimately, the best approach is one that is tailored to the individual, considering their specific circumstances, preferences, and health goals.

2. Adjusting Medication: Your current physician's recommendation to reduce your Metformin dosage as your weight decreases is a common practice. Weight loss can improve insulin sensitivity and help lower blood sugar levels, potentially allowing for a reduction in medication. However, it's important to continue monitoring your blood sugar levels closely during this transition.

Regarding the possibility of stopping medication altogether, it's essential to approach this decision cautiously. While some individuals can achieve normal blood sugar levels through lifestyle changes alone, this is not the case for everyone. Factors such as genetics, the duration of diabetes, and the presence of other health conditions can influence whether someone can maintain control without medication. If you are considering the option of stopping medication, it would be wise to discuss this thoroughly with your healthcare provider. They can assess your current health status, blood sugar levels, and overall diabetes management plan to determine the best course of action.

3. Seeking a Second Opinion: If you feel uncertain about your treatment plan or are tempted by the idea of managing diabetes without medication, seeking a second opinion can be beneficial. A different healthcare provider may offer new insights or alternative strategies that align better with your goals. However, it's crucial to ensure that any changes to your treatment plan are made under the guidance of a qualified healthcare professional.

In conclusion, diabetes management is highly individualized, and what works for one person may not be suitable for another. It's essential to maintain open communication with your healthcare team, regularly monitor your blood sugar levels, and make informed decisions based on your unique health situation. Lifestyle changes, including a balanced diet and regular exercise, play a critical role in managing diabetes, but medication may still be necessary for optimal control. Always prioritize your health and well-being in any treatment decisions you make. Thank you for your questions, and I wish you the best on your journey to managing diabetes!

Similar Q&A

Understanding When to Start Diabetes Medication: A Patient's Dilemma

Hello Dr. Lin, I recently had two fasting blood glucose tests with results of 103 and 107, and my HbA1c levels were 6.5 and 6.8. The physician at the diabetes specialty clinic advised me to start medication and prescribed Metformin extended-release tablets, one per day. However, ...

Dr. Lin Wuxuan reply Internal Medicine
Hello: The treatment of diabetes will generally follow the guidelines provided for diabetes management, but some details will still need to be adjusted based on the physician's clinical experience. Although there are differences in opinion between the two physicians, both fu...

Managing Diabetes Medications for Lean Patients: Key Considerations

Hello Doctor, my father is 63 years old and has symptoms of diabetes (pre-meal blood sugar around 120). He is currently taking diabetes medication. My father has a lean body type and is not obese, follows a vegetarian diet, and avoids greasy foods, smoking, and alcohol. Initially...

Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Internal Medicine
Dear Mr. Paul Chen: 1. The first-line medication for most patients with type 2 diabetes is Metformin, which you referred to as Asures®. Regarding medication choices for leaner diabetic patients, there can indeed be some controversy in the medical community. It is advisable to in...

Managing Diabetes: Diet Tips, Insulin Effects, and New Treatments

1. I would like to know what dietary choices are best for managing diabetes. 2. Does long-term insulin injection have adverse effects on the body? 3. Are there better treatment options available for diabetes now?

Dr. Yang Guojun reply Internal Medicine
1. Avoid consuming high-sugar foods such as sugary beverages, and increase physical activity. 2. Insulin is a substance that the body naturally produces, making it essential for the treatment of diabetes, and it does not have adverse effects. 3. There are now many new oral medica...

Should Diabetic Patients Rely on Insulin or Oral Medications?

My mother has had diabetes for over ten years. In December of last year, her doctor recommended insulin injections to control her blood sugar. After the New Year, she did not take insulin for about two weeks, and her blood sugar levels were 148 postprandial and 118 preprandial. T...

Dr. Guo Qinghui reply Internal Medicine
Diabetic patients need to maintain their blood glucose levels within a certain range to delay the onset of complications. The use of insulin or oral antidiabetic medications to control blood sugar each has its advantages, disadvantages, and limitations, and is also related to the...