Mixing Cow and Goat Milk for Infant Nutrition: Is It Safe? - Pediatrics

Share to:

Nursing with cow and goat milk?


Hello Dr.
Cheng: My son is now 4 and a half months old and is currently drinking Enfa A+.
A friend mentioned that goat milk formula can be beneficial for the respiratory system.
I am considering mixing cow's milk formula with goat milk formula for his feeding.
Is this appropriate? He currently weighs only 6.5 kg and has not gained any weight for the past two weeks.
Does this indicate developmental delay? He was born weighing 2.5 kg.
Additionally, can he drink rice water now? If I prepare it for him, should the water-to-rice ratio be 1:10? Thank you, Dr.
Cheng.

Lu Er Ma Mi, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2003/01/26

Dr. Zheng Peian reply Pediatrics


Hello, Ru'er's Mommy: Your baby weighed 2.5 kg at birth and 6.5 kg at four and a half months, which is considered normal.
It is recommended to record height, weight, and growth development every two months and document it on the growth chart in the health booklet for reference during pediatric check-ups or vaccinations.
There is no medical basis for the claim that goat milk formula can protect the airways; however, if it is a legally approved goat milk formula (specifically for infants), it is acceptable to mix it with cow's milk formula.
For infants with a family history of allergies or early signs of allergies, exclusive breastfeeding or hydrolyzed protein formula is beneficial in preventing allergies or asthma.
When introducing complementary foods, start with small amounts and gradually increase the quantity, ensuring that the consistency is not overly thick; it does not necessarily have to be a 1:10 water ratio.
Many thanks!

Reply Date: 2003/01/26

More Info


Mixing cow and goat milk for infant nutrition can be a topic of concern for many parents, especially when considering the nutritional needs of a growing infant. In your case, your son is currently 4.5 months old and is on a formula called "優生A+." It’s important to approach the introduction of any new food or milk with caution, particularly for infants who are still developing their digestive systems.

First, let’s address the idea of mixing cow and goat milk. Both cow and goat milk can provide essential nutrients such as protein, calcium, and vitamins. However, they are not recommended as primary sources of nutrition for infants under one year of age. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) advises that infants should be exclusively breastfed or formula-fed for the first six months of life. After six months, solid foods can be introduced, but milk (whether cow or goat) should not replace breast milk or formula until the child is at least one year old. This is primarily because cow and goat milk do not contain the right balance of nutrients that infants need, and they can also be harder for infants to digest.

Regarding your concern about your son's weight, it is essential to monitor his growth closely. A weight of 6.5 kg at 4.5 months, especially considering he was born at 2.5 kg, may indicate that he is not gaining weight as expected. Weight gain is a crucial indicator of an infant's health and development. If he has not gained weight in the last month, it would be wise to consult with a pediatrician to evaluate his growth patterns and overall health. They may suggest adjustments to his feeding regimen or further assessments to ensure he is receiving adequate nutrition.

As for introducing rice water (米湯) to your son, it is generally recommended to wait until around six months of age before introducing any solid foods or liquids other than breast milk or formula. If you choose to prepare rice water, the typical ratio is indeed about 1:10 (one part rice to ten parts water), but this should only be done once he is developmentally ready for solids. Rice water can be soothing for the digestive system, but it should not replace his primary source of nutrition, which should still be breast milk or formula.

In summary, mixing cow and goat milk is not advisable for infants under one year. Focus on ensuring that your son is getting enough formula and consult with a pediatrician regarding his weight and growth. Once he reaches six months, you can gradually introduce solid foods, including rice water, while continuing to provide adequate formula or breast milk. Always prioritize professional medical advice tailored to your child's specific needs.

Similar Q&A

Can You Mix Goat Milk and Cow Milk for Your Baby's Nutrition?

Dear Nutritionist, On July 2nd, I saw a news report stating that "goat milk should never be mixed with cow milk." However, my baby is not accustomed to pure goat milk, and I would like to add some goat milk to supplement nutrition. Is this true? My baby is currently on...


Dr. Tang Weili reply Nutrition
Xiao Ru: Hello! From the perspective of nutrition and food science, the nutritional components of cow's milk and goat's milk are similar. Adults can consume both beef and lamb, and young children can drink both cow's milk and goat's milk. However, since young ...

[Read More] Can You Mix Goat Milk and Cow Milk for Your Baby's Nutrition?


Choosing Between Goat Milk and Cow Milk for Your Toddler: A Nutritional Guide

Hello Dr. Tang: My son is currently unsure about which formula to choose, whether to drink cow's milk (Talon Tani) or goat's milk (Talon Tani)! Since birth, I have been giving him "You Sheng" formula (switching from stage 1 to stage 2 and then to stage 3). How...


Dr. Tang Weili reply Nutrition
Hello Pagy: First, I want to clarify that your son, who is 1 year and 2 months old, is in the growth stage of childhood rather than infancy. The nutrients necessary for his growth must come from a combination of different foods, including filling staple foods (such as rice, noodl...

[Read More] Choosing Between Goat Milk and Cow Milk for Your Toddler: A Nutritional Guide


Is Homemade Baby Food Nutritionally Adequate for Infants?

Hello, nutritionist: I have a question to ask you. Recently, I saw a program on television that introduced a method for making complementary foods for infants. It suggested using 1 cup (measuring cup) of brown rice, adding 2 raw cashews, and soaking them in 1000cc of hot water fo...


Dr. Shi Guimei reply Nutrition
Hello! Your baby is currently developing very well in terms of height and weight. When introducing complementary foods to infants, please keep the following points in mind: start with small amounts, introduce only one new food at a time, and wait for a period to see if the baby a...

[Read More] Is Homemade Baby Food Nutritionally Adequate for Infants?


Is Goat Milk Safe for Toddlers? Pediatrician's Insights on Health Risks

Hello, doctor; my child is currently one year and ten months old. Is it okay for him to drink a bottle of "Chianan goat milk" in the morning? I have heard that drinking goat milk at such a young age may cause "narrowing of the airways," and that older children...


Dr. Lin Huizhen reply Pediatrics
Dear Sindy, In traditional Chinese medicine, the effects attributed to goat milk are recognized; however, there is no specific evidence in Western medicine to support these claims. We believe that the nutritional components of cow's milk are comparable to, if not superior t...

[Read More] Is Goat Milk Safe for Toddlers? Pediatrician's Insights on Health Risks


Related FAQ

Infant Formula

(Pediatrics)

Breastfeeding

(Pediatrics)

Infant Nutrition

(Nutrition)

Complementary Foods

(Pediatrics)

Accidental Ingestion

(Pediatrics)

Pediatric Vomiting

(Pediatrics)

Jaundice

(Pediatrics)

Baby Stool

(Pediatrics)

Kidney

(Pediatrics)

Bedwetting

(Pediatrics)