Managing Hernia Recurrence: Can Support Garments Be a Long-Term Solution?

Hernia recurrence

I have undergone hernia surgery twice, but it has recurred.
I would like to ask the doctor: if I do not opt for surgery, can I simply wear hernia support garments? Are there any drawbacks to wearing hernia support garments long-term? Are there any potential side effects? Thank you, doctor.

Li Maike, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2021/02/25

Dr. Li Xinyi reply Urology

The most important aspect of a hernia is to prevent the hernial sac from becoming trapped outside the abdominal cavity, as this can lead to incarceration.
If the incarcerated portion becomes strangulated, it can result in tissue necrosis, which poses a significant risk.
Hernia belts do not have specific complications, but they may be uncomfortable to wear and may not always provide adequate support.
Additionally, they can cause localized temperature increases, potentially leading to issues such as tinea.

Reply Date: 2021/02/25

More Info

Managing hernia recurrence can be a challenging issue, especially after undergoing surgery multiple times. It's understandable to seek alternative solutions, such as wearing support garments like hernia belts or compression shorts. While these garments can provide temporary relief and support, they are not a permanent solution for hernia management.

Understanding Hernia Support Garments
Hernia support garments are designed to provide external compression to the affected area, which can help alleviate discomfort and prevent the hernia from protruding further. They can be particularly useful for individuals who experience pain or discomfort during physical activities or those who are not candidates for surgery due to various reasons, such as age, health conditions, or personal choice.

Benefits of Wearing Hernia Garments
1. Pain Relief: Many patients report a reduction in pain and discomfort when wearing a support garment. The compression can help stabilize the area and reduce the pressure on the hernia.

2. Increased Activity: Wearing a hernia support garment may allow individuals to engage in daily activities with more confidence, as it can provide a sense of security.

3. Non-Invasive Option: For those who are hesitant about undergoing another surgical procedure, support garments offer a non-invasive alternative.

Limitations and Potential Drawbacks
While hernia support garments can be beneficial, there are several limitations and potential drawbacks to consider:
1. Temporary Solution: Support garments do not address the underlying issue of the hernia. They may provide temporary relief, but they do not repair the hernia itself. Over time, the hernia may continue to enlarge or cause more discomfort.

2. Dependency: Relying solely on a support garment can lead to a dependency on it for comfort. This may discourage individuals from seeking appropriate medical treatment or considering surgical options when necessary.

3. Skin Irritation: Prolonged use of support garments can lead to skin irritation or rashes, especially if the garment is not made from breathable materials or if it is worn too tightly.

4. Limited Mobility: Some individuals may find that wearing a support garment restricts their movement or is uncomfortable during certain activities, particularly high-impact exercises.

5. Potential for Complications: In some cases, wearing a garment that is too tight can lead to complications such as impaired circulation or increased pressure on the abdomen, which could exacerbate the hernia.

Conclusion
In summary, while wearing hernia support garments can provide temporary relief and support, they should not be viewed as a long-term solution for managing hernia recurrence. It is essential to consult with a healthcare professional, such as a surgeon or a gastroenterologist, to discuss your specific situation and explore all available options, including the possibility of further surgical intervention.
If you choose to use a support garment, ensure that it fits properly and is made from comfortable, breathable materials. Regular follow-ups with your healthcare provider are crucial to monitor the condition of the hernia and to determine the best course of action moving forward. Ultimately, addressing the root cause of the hernia through appropriate medical care is the most effective way to manage this condition in the long term.

Similar Q&A

Managing Recurrence After Laparoscopic Inguinal Hernia Repair: What to Expect

About three years ago, I had surgery for a right inguinal hernia using laparoscopic extraperitoneal surgery with a synthetic mesh. About a year after the surgery, I noticed a bulge on the right side of my groin again, which has become more pronounced and sometimes painful, indica...

Dr. Xu Kaixi reply Surgery
If a recurrent hernia repair is performed using laparoscopic extraperitoneal surgery, consideration may be given to using traditional methods for subsequent surgery. Theoretically, the original mesh would remain in place, and the procedure would follow traditional techniques. The...

Should You Use Degradable Mesh for Hernia Surgery? Expert Insights on Benefits and Risks

My mother (59 years old) has been diagnosed with a hernia (a lump in the lower right abdomen near the groin). She has had two cesarean sections and often lifts heavy objects, but she does not have any issues with hypertension, diabetes, or high cholesterol. Her fasting blood suga...

Dr. Chen Jiaming reply Surgery
Hernia surgery is a very common procedure in Taiwan, with approximately 30,000 surgeries performed each year. The technique has evolved from traditional tissue repair methods to the current mainstream approach of tension-free repair using synthetic mesh. A wide variety of synthet...

Post-Hernia Surgery: Safe Exercises and Activities to Consider

Hello, Director Lin. I underwent left inguinal hernia surgery once in 2020 and once in 2021. The first surgery was traditional, and the second was with a mesh implant. The doctor mentioned that my abdominal wall is inherently thinner. Over the past few months, I feel that since i...

Dr. Lin Jianzhong reply Rehabilitation
Hello Mr. David: Movements such as torso twists, arm swings on tiptoes, and squats can still cause some degree of abdominal pressure, especially squats. If you have a relatively thin abdominal wall and have recently noticed that your left lower abdomen is more prominent while sta...

Understanding Post-Surgery Recovery Challenges After Abdominal Surgery

My father underwent surgery due to a hernia, which caused a portion of his intestine to protrude (he was under the care of the urology department at that time). The attending physician explained that the mesh used to support the intestine had ruptured due to improper straining. A...

Dr. Liu Mingyue reply Surgery
Hello: Based on your description, the patient likely had a hernia (commonly known as a "rupture") and underwent surgery at the hospital. During the surgery, the intestines would be pushed back, and the defect in the hernial sac would be repaired, along with reinforcemen...