I am unsure whether I have asthma and uncertain if I should continue using the bronchodilator?
Hello Doctor, I have had allergic rhinitis since childhood, and I have been coughing for three years.
During this time, I have seen several pulmonologists due to reasons such as attending school, returning to my hometown, and moving north for work.
The pulmonary function tests conducted by previous doctors were all normal, but most of the results indicated that I have asthma, while a few suggested it was merely allergies or bronchial hyperreactivity.
However, I do cough quite frequently, and sometimes I need to take a deep breath to relieve the tightness in my lungs.
The commonality among these doctors is that they all prescribed bronchodilators for me to use.
Despite using them for three years, I still cough, and it seems there is no significant effect.
It could be that my condition would have worsened without them, and the medication is just controlling it.
This time, after moving north for work and seeing a new doctor, my pulmonary function tests were also normal, leading to the conclusion that I do not have asthma and that I no longer need to use bronchodilators.
The doctor only prescribed me a nasal spray (fluticasone) which I have been using consistently.
The differing opinions from various doctors have left me quite confused.
I have a few main questions: 1.
Based on the description above, do I have asthma or could there be other reasons for my cough? 2.
Do I need to continue using bronchodilators? I am a bit worried that stopping them suddenly might worsen my cough.
Thank you, Dr.
Yang, for your patience in reading and responding!
Mr. Hsieh, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/03/23
Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: When asthma is not exacerbated, lung function can be normal.
Typically, regular daily use of inhaled long-acting bronchodilators combined with corticosteroids should improve symptoms.
In cases of allergic bronchitis, the use of bronchodilators should also lead to improvement.
Coughing may need to be monitored for significant temperature fluctuations or continued exposure to allergens (such as dust mites or animal dander), which could be contributing factors.
If improvement is not as expected, it is crucial to strictly control environmental factors or take appropriate measures (such as wearing a jacket in the morning and evening, avoiding cold drinks, etc.).
This is for your reference!
Reply Date: 2022/03/23
More Info
Understanding asthma and its management can be quite complex, especially when symptoms like persistent cough are involved. Based on your description, it seems you have been dealing with a chronic cough for three years, with varying opinions from different pulmonologists regarding your diagnosis and treatment. Let’s break down your concerns and provide some clarity.
1. Do you have asthma?
The fact that you have a history of allergic rhinitis suggests that you may have a predisposition to respiratory issues, including asthma. However, the normal pulmonary function tests (PFTs) you’ve undergone indicate that your airways are functioning well at the time of testing. Asthma is characterized by reversible airway obstruction, which may not always be evident during a standard PFT, especially if you are not experiencing an exacerbation at the time of testing. It’s also possible that your cough could be due to other factors, such as post-nasal drip from your allergic rhinitis, chronic bronchitis, or even gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), which can also cause chronic cough.
2. Do you need to continue using bronchodilators?
Bronchodilators, particularly short-acting beta-agonists (SABAs), are typically used to relieve acute asthma symptoms by relaxing the muscles around the airways. If you have been using them for three years without significant improvement in your cough, it raises the question of whether they are the appropriate treatment for your condition. If your cough is primarily due to non-asthmatic causes, continuing bronchodilators may not be necessary. However, if you experience any wheezing, chest tightness, or difficulty breathing, it may indicate that you still have some degree of asthma or reactive airway disease, and bronchodilators could be beneficial.
3. What about the nasal spray?
The nasal spray you mentioned, likely a corticosteroid like Fluticasone (Flonase) or Budesonide (Rhinocort), is effective for managing allergic rhinitis. By controlling nasal inflammation, it may help reduce post-nasal drip, which can contribute to your cough. It’s essential to continue using this medication as prescribed, as it can help manage your allergy symptoms and potentially alleviate some of the cough.
4. What should you do next?
Given the conflicting opinions from different doctors, it may be beneficial to seek a second opinion from a specialist in allergy and immunology or a pulmonologist who has experience with complex cases. They may recommend additional testing, such as a methacholine challenge test, which can help determine if you have asthma that is not evident on standard PFTs.
5. Lifestyle and environmental factors:
Consider evaluating your environment for potential triggers of your cough. Common irritants include smoke, strong odors, cold air, and allergens like dust mites, pet dander, and pollen. Implementing measures to reduce exposure to these triggers can be beneficial.
In conclusion, while you may not have classic asthma based on your PFTs, your chronic cough warrants further investigation to determine its underlying cause. Continuing with the nasal spray is advisable, and the need for bronchodilators should be reassessed based on your symptoms and any new findings from further evaluations. Always communicate openly with your healthcare provider about your concerns and the effectiveness of your current treatment plan.
Similar Q&A
Persistent Cough: Understanding Causes and Treatment Options
Hello Doctor: I have been coughing since I caught a cold around October last year, and it lasted for more than a month. I later visited a pulmonologist who performed an X-ray and pulmonary function tests. Initially, I was prescribed cough suppressants and expectorants, but my cou...
Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello Han: From the previous use of inhalers, there has been improvement, and the physician's diagnosis of asthma seems to be correct. However, asthma patients can still experience acute exacerbations due to factors such as colds, exposure to allergens (like dust mites or po...[Read More] Persistent Cough: Understanding Causes and Treatment Options
The Necessity of Switching to Long-Term Asthma Management Medications
Previously, I was diagnosed with allergic asthma due to a wheezing cough. I have been using Ruanwa (Montelukast) and Quyi Le (Budesonide) along with a short-acting bronchodilator as needed. This has been going on for about six months, and my symptoms have been quite stable, with ...
Dr. Zhang Ziyan reply Pulmonology
Hello Yuan, as described, if there are no symptoms during the day and night, we should compare lung function before and after to see if there is a significant difference. If there is not much difference, I personally tend to maintain the original medication regimen. Runwa is a re...[Read More] The Necessity of Switching to Long-Term Asthma Management Medications
Understanding Chronic Wet Cough: Diagnosis and Treatment Options
Hello Doctor, I have suffered from colds since childhood and have frequently visited clinics for respiratory diseases. For the past five years, after catching a cold, I have experienced a persistent wet cough (clear mucus with slight foaming) that lasts from one to four months. D...
Dr. Lu Mingzhi reply Pulmonology
Hello: The typical symptoms of asthma include prolonged intermittent cough with phlegm, shortness of breath, wheezing, and chest tightness (especially worsening at night or in the early morning). However, not every asthma patient exhibits these typical symptoms. Although pulmonar...[Read More] Understanding Chronic Wet Cough: Diagnosis and Treatment Options
Understanding Throat Irritation and Dry Cough: Is It Asthma?
I have a habit of running 10 kilometers or hiking regularly, and I participate in full marathon events. I do not smoke or drink alcohol. I have been experiencing nasal allergies, often sneezing, and I frequently have a scratchy throat and dry cough, although the dry cough tends t...
Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: You may have allergic rhinitis, so be careful not to consume overly cold foods. If you are not experiencing difficulty breathing, you might consider not using bronchodilators for the time being![Read More] Understanding Throat Irritation and Dry Cough: Is It Asthma?
Related FAQ
(Pulmonology)
Wheezing, Coughing(Pulmonology)
Asthma(Pulmonology)
Bronchitis(Pulmonology)
Asthma(Internal Medicine)
Cough(Internal Medicine)
Medication Consultation(Pulmonology)
Pediatric Asthma(Pediatrics)
Bronchial Sensitivity(Otolaryngology)
Bronchial Fibrosis(Internal Medicine)