the Hormonal Effects of Ashitaba and Lutein Supplements - Traditional Chinese Medicine

Share to:

Health food and medication issues?


Hello, Doctor: (1) I would like to add a small amount (1/2 stick) of green juice to my daily diet, primarily made from Ashitaba.
I read online that Ashitaba can promote lactation, and due to my family medical history, I need to avoid estrogenic substances.
Therefore, I would like to ask if Ashitaba is considered an estrogenic plant? (2) I have floaters in my vision, and my doctor recommended that I take lutein.
However, most lutein supplements on the market contain marigold, which I read online can induce menstruation, so is it also an estrogenic plant? I really can't find any information on this, so I kindly ask for your assistance, thank you, Doctor!

Xiao Ning, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/04/30

Dr. Zhang Chunfang reply Traditional Chinese Medicine


Hello: It is best to choose common ingredients for dietary therapy.
Green vegetables can replace Ashitaba, and goji berries can substitute for calendula.
Do not be deceived by claims of miraculous effects, but also avoid consuming them daily.
It is advisable to switch ingredients according to the season or enjoy them every few days.
Wishing you good health.
Best regards, Department of Traditional Chinese Medicine.

Reply Date: 2022/04/30

More Info


When considering the hormonal effects of Ashitaba (Angelica keiskei) and Lutein supplements, it is essential to understand the properties of these substances and their potential interactions with hormonal systems in the body.

1. Ashitaba and Hormonal Effects: Ashitaba is a green leafy vegetable that is often consumed for its health benefits, including its potential antioxidant properties and ability to promote overall wellness. There is some anecdotal evidence suggesting that Ashitaba may have lactogenic effects, meaning it could potentially stimulate milk production in breastfeeding mothers. However, the scientific evidence supporting this claim is limited. Importantly, Ashitaba does not contain phytoestrogens, which are plant-derived compounds that mimic estrogen in the body. Therefore, it is not classified as an estrogenic plant. If you have a family history of hormone-sensitive conditions, it is generally considered safe to consume Ashitaba in moderation, but it is always advisable to consult with a healthcare provider before making any significant dietary changes.

2. Lutein and its Ingredients: Lutein is a carotenoid found in various fruits and vegetables, particularly leafy greens. It is well-known for its role in eye health, particularly in protecting against age-related macular degeneration and cataracts. Lutein itself does not have hormonal properties and is not known to influence estrogen levels in the body. However, many Lutein supplements on the market contain additional ingredients, such as Marigold (Calendula officinalis), which is sometimes included for its potential health benefits. Calendula has been traditionally used for various medicinal purposes, and while it is not classified as a phytoestrogen, there are claims that it may have some effects on the menstrual cycle. However, the evidence is not robust, and more research is needed to establish any significant hormonal effects.

Given your concerns about avoiding estrogenic substances, it is crucial to read the labels of any supplements carefully. If a Lutein supplement contains Calendula or other herbal ingredients, it would be wise to research those specific components or consult with a healthcare professional to ensure they align with your health needs and family history.

In summary, Ashitaba is not an estrogenic plant and is generally safe for consumption in moderation. Lutein, on its own, does not have hormonal effects, but caution should be exercised regarding any additional ingredients in Lutein supplements. Always consult with a healthcare provider for personalized advice, especially when dealing with family histories of hormone-sensitive conditions.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Retinal Health: Is My Lutein and Supplement Intake Safe?

Hello Doctor: I have high myopia, and the doctor mentioned that my retina is very thin, with degeneration observed in the OCT of my left eye. I would like to ask if taking 2 capsules of lutein and 1 capsule of Shusheming daily would be excessive. 1. The lutein supplement contai...


Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello, Xiao-Ji: Taking 2 capsules of lutein and 1 capsule of Shushe Ming at this dosage should be fine. Please rest assured. The ophthalmology department at Puzi Hospital in Taiwan is open from Monday to Friday, 8:00 AM to 12:00 PM and Wednesday afternoons from 1:00 PM to 4:30 PM...

[Read More] Understanding Retinal Health: Is My Lutein and Supplement Intake Safe?


Managing Dry Eye, Floaters, and Thyroid Issues: Medication and Supplements Guide

I am currently taking Soothe (Shu Le Jin) at a dosage of half a tablet twice a day, in the morning and evening, due to my high myopia, floaters, and dry eye syndrome. Are there any side effects of this medication for me? My cholesterol levels are around 205, with LDL (bad cholest...


Dr. Huang Xunying reply Family Medicine
The side effects of Shulejin include ciliary muscle spasm, headache, difficulty concentrating on vision, decreased night vision, local irritation, increased salivation, and increased sweating; however, not everyone will experience these symptoms. This medication can be taken alon...

[Read More] Managing Dry Eye, Floaters, and Thyroid Issues: Medication and Supplements Guide


Understanding Lutein and Its Impact on Hormone-Related Cancers

Hello Nutritionist: The patient is 50 years old. I understand the importance of increasing the intake of natural foods, and we will do our best to provide the patient with natural foods. Regarding the previously mentioned nutrients, I would like to know if there are any component...


Dr. Xie Peiru reply Nutrition
Hello, Regarding the lutein supplement you mentioned, I am unsure about the specific type of extraction used, such as whether the black soybean extract is derived from the whole black soybean or just the skin. Due to the uncertainty of the extraction source, I cannot provide a ...

[Read More] Understanding Lutein and Its Impact on Hormone-Related Cancers


Is It Possible to Be Allergic to a New Supplement Brand?

I usually take brand A's lutein supplement capsules and have been doing so for several years without any issues. Recently, I decided to try brand B, but every time I take brand B's lutein, I immediately experience palpitations. At times, I even feel short of breath whil...


Dr. Huang Shenggang reply Pharmacology
Basically, you need to first determine whether these two brands are pharmaceuticals or food products. Any pharmaceutical should have a drug registration number. Since the ingredients of these two brands are quite different, it can be said that some components of Brand B may not b...

[Read More] Is It Possible to Be Allergic to a New Supplement Brand?


Related FAQ

Health Supplements

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Menopausal Disorders

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Sexual Dysfunction

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Acne

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Seborrheic Dermatitis

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Menstrual Period

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Hair

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Acid Reflux

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Hepatitis B

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Drug Interactions

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)