Ankle Ligament Tears: Treatment Options and Recovery Insights - Orthopedics

Share to:

Ankle ligamentous avulsion fracture


On June 18, I sustained an injury from a fall, and the initial hospital diagnosed me with a 7 cm laceration on my left ankle (extending from the dorsum of the foot to the ankle area of the calf, with the wound at the calf being deeper down to the muscle layer).
An X-ray at the first hospital showed no fractures.
After a long three weeks of wound recovery and suture removal, I am now in the fourth week.
The orthopedic surgeon at the second hospital suspected ligament damage and arranged for an ultrasound examination.
The original orthopedic surgeon, upon reviewing the ultrasound, suspected a fracture and ordered another X-ray, which again showed no fractures.
Consequently, I was referred to an orthopedic outpatient clinic.
After reviewing the ultrasound and X-ray reports, the orthopedic doctor stated that this is classified as a ligamentous avulsion fracture.
The doctor explained that this type of fracture is not visible on X-rays and is caused by the ligament tearing off a piece of bone during the injury.
He suggested two treatment options: the first is to reapply a cast for three months to allow for gradual healing, and the second is to repair the injury using an artificial ligament while also addressing the fracture.
The doctor mentioned that too much time has passed since the injury, and only an artificial ligament can be used at this point.
Since the injury occurred over a month ago, I must wait for the wound to fully heal before undergoing an ultrasound examination (scheduled for July 19).
Currently, the wound has healed without issues, but there is still swelling on both the medial and lateral sides of the left ankle, accompanied by pain while walking (I am unable to walk normally and have a limp), and I cannot dorsiflex my foot (limited range of motion).
During the ultrasound examination, the doctor was unable to manipulate the ankle.
Question 1: What are the recommended treatment options for this condition? Will using an artificial ligament have any long-term consequences, and how does it compare to the original ligament in terms of function?
Question 2: Between the two treatment methods, which one has a better healing outcome, and which has the least impact on future function?
Question 3: How long does postoperative care and recovery take after artificial ligament surgery, and when can I expect to return to work (sedentary)?
Question 4: What is the medical term for this type of surgery? I cannot find relevant case studies online, and which specialty does it belong to (orthopedics has various subspecialties)? How can I find a surgeon who specializes in this type of procedure? Are there specific terminologies associated with it?
Question 5: What is the approximate cost of artificial ligament surgery (requiring two artificial ligaments)? Are artificial ligaments considered out-of-pocket medical materials? Are there any alternatives or types of materials available?

Yi Hong, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/07/19

Dr. Chen Bochen reply Orthopedics


Hello: 1 & 2.
Artificial ligaments are considered a secondary option; autologous ligaments are more suitable.
3.
Not recommended.
4.
Consult an orthopedic foot and ankle specialist.
I recommend Dr.
Chiu Chia-Hung or Dr.
Chen Yen-Yu.
5.
Not recommended.

Reply Date: 2022/07/19

More Info


Understanding ankle ligament tears, particularly in the context of your injury, is crucial for determining the best treatment options and recovery strategies. Ankle ligament injuries can vary significantly in severity, and the treatment approach often depends on the specific ligaments involved, the extent of the damage, and the patient's overall health and activity level.


Treatment Options
1. Conservative Management: This typically involves rest, ice, compression, and elevation (RICE) to reduce swelling and pain. Physical therapy may also be recommended to strengthen the surrounding muscles and improve range of motion. However, given the nature of your injury, conservative management may not be sufficient.

2. Surgical Intervention: Given that your injury involves a suspected ligament tear and possible bone involvement, surgical options may be necessary. The two primary surgical approaches you mentioned are:
- Casting: This method involves immobilizing the ankle with a cast for an extended period (up to three months) to allow the ligaments to heal naturally. While this is less invasive, it may not restore full function if the ligaments are significantly damaged.

- Artificial Ligament Repair: This involves using synthetic materials to replace or repair the damaged ligaments. This method can provide more stability and may allow for a quicker return to function compared to conservative management.


Recovery Insights
1. Post-Surgery Recovery: Recovery from artificial ligament surgery typically involves a rehabilitation program that includes physical therapy. The timeline for recovery can vary, but many patients can expect to return to light activities within 3 to 6 months, while full recovery may take up to a year. The ability to return to work, especially in a sedentary position, may be sooner, depending on your comfort level and the nature of your job.

2. Long-term Outcomes: The long-term outcomes of artificial ligament surgery can be favorable, but they may not fully replicate the function of natural ligaments. Potential complications include graft failure, infection, and the possibility of arthritis developing in the joint over time. However, many patients report satisfactory results and improved stability after surgery.


Surgical Terminology and Specialization
1. Surgical Name: The procedure you are referring to is often called "ankle ligament reconstruction" or "ankle stabilization surgery." This falls under the specialty of orthopedic surgery, specifically within the subspecialty of foot and ankle surgery.

2. Finding a Specialist: To find a surgeon who specializes in this type of procedure, you can look for orthopedic surgeons who have a focus on foot and ankle surgery. It’s advisable to seek referrals from your primary care physician or consult with your current orthopedic doctor for recommendations.


Financial Considerations
1. Cost of Surgery: The cost of artificial ligament surgery can vary widely depending on the healthcare facility, the surgeon's experience, and geographical location. Generally, the expenses can range from several thousand to tens of thousands of dollars, especially if it involves advanced materials or techniques.

2. Insurance and Out-of-Pocket Expenses: Artificial ligaments are often considered a form of prosthetic device, which may not be covered by all insurance plans. It’s essential to check with your insurance provider regarding coverage for the procedure and any associated costs.

3. Material Options: There are various types of artificial ligaments available, including those made from synthetic materials like polyester or polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE). Discussing the options with your surgeon can help you understand the best choice for your specific case.


Conclusion
In summary, your recovery from an ankle ligament tear involves careful consideration of treatment options, potential surgical interventions, and a structured rehabilitation plan. Engaging with a specialized orthopedic surgeon will provide you with the best insights into your condition and the most appropriate treatment pathway. Remember to communicate openly with your healthcare team about your concerns and expectations to ensure a comprehensive approach to your recovery.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Ankle Ligament Tears: Treatment Options and Recovery Insights

Hello Doctor, my right ankle has been sprained for over three years. During this time, I have tried various non-surgical treatments and rehabilitation methods, but none have been effective. Recently, I had an MRI, and two doctors said there were no issues. However, after undergoi...


Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
You need to consult an orthopedic specialist who specializes in the foot and ankle to have a thorough evaluation to determine if surgery is necessary. You should also inquire about the recovery process after surgery. It is not possible to make a definitive conclusion about your c...

[Read More] Understanding Ankle Ligament Tears: Treatment Options and Recovery Insights


Managing Chronic Ankle Ligament Pain: Next Steps for Recovery

Hello, I sustained a tear in my ankle ligaments due to an accident last July. I started rehabilitation in September and also received glucose injections, but I have been experiencing pain ever since. I have only been doing the exercises taught by my physical therapist. This year,...


Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Ligament sprains typically require conservative treatment and rarely necessitate surgery. Continuing rehabilitation or wearing an ankle brace for protection is advisable. As long as there is no instability, recovery will gradually occur.

[Read More] Managing Chronic Ankle Ligament Pain: Next Steps for Recovery


Understanding Ligament Injuries: Surgery Options for Ankle Ligament Tears

Hello, after the car accident, I suffered a rupture of the medial collateral ligament of the ankle along with a closed fibular fracture. The doctor said that the fracture can be treated non-operatively, but the ligament must be surgically repaired. Is it possible to avoid surgery...


Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello, In response to your question, both the inner and outer sides of the ankle have strong ligaments. Generally, in cases of a typical sprain, the ligaments on the outer front side are injured. Usually, rest, reduced activity, or immobilization with a cast is sufficient for r...

[Read More] Understanding Ligament Injuries: Surgery Options for Ankle Ligament Tears


Understanding Ankle Ligament Injuries: Healing and Treatment Options

Hello, Doctor. I sprained the outer side of my right ankle while playing basketball on June 18. After seeing a doctor, I wore a brace for a month and underwent physical therapy to prevent adhesions, as well as training for the lateral calf muscles. After three months, I started p...


Dr. Chen Bochen reply Orthopedics
Hello, it is recommended to undergo an ultrasound examination of the ligaments. However, regardless of whether there is a tear or not, regenerative treatment can be performed to strengthen the ligaments, which can accelerate healing and help prevent re-injury.

[Read More] Understanding Ankle Ligament Injuries: Healing and Treatment Options


Related FAQ

Ankle Ligament Injury

(Orthopedics)

Post-Ankle Ligament Surgery

(Orthopedics)

Ankle Ligament Rupture

(Orthopedics)

Ankle Fracture Recovery

(Orthopedics)

Ligament Tear

(Orthopedics)

Ankle Injury

(Surgery)

Ankle

(Rehabilitation)

Acl

(Orthopedics)

Ankle Sprain

(Family Medicine)

Ligament Injury

(Rehabilitation)