Knee
I am Ms.
Hsu, who asked a question on November 28.
1.
Currently, my knee still feels like there is something stuck in it, and I am unable to bend it.
Last Saturday, I visited a rehabilitation specialist, and the therapist mentioned that there might be a blood clot, which my body will absorb on its own.
A traditional Chinese medicine practitioner I consulted earlier also mentioned the possibility of a blood clot.
He said that if the swelling improves, it would be fine, but if the swelling does not go down, I would need to undergo blood extraction or acupuncture, which I find quite frightening.
Is this approach appropriate? Would blood extraction be a quicker solution? I am worried that if I delay too long, I might develop rheumatism as I get older.
2.
I also have a question about whether I should see a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner or a Western medicine doctor.
Could you please provide some advice? It seems that constantly changing doctors is not a viable solution.
Thank you.
Miss Hsu, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2003/12/01
Dr. Pan Yingda reply Rehabilitation
Hello: 1.
How long have you had your knee injury (this recent episode)? Generally, a hematoma should not last more than two weeks, and if you want to expedite the healing process, it is better to aspirate the hematoma (the hematoma causes the knee to swell like a blister, filled with fluid).
The previous response was more focused on your chronic, long-term issue (the injury from five years ago that has not healed), where the knee cannot bend.
If it feels stiff, you should suspect a meniscus issue; if it feels tight, it may be a hematoma that needs to be drained.
2.
Consult an orthopedic physician.
Reply Date: 2003/12/01
More Info
Knee pain can be a complex issue, especially when it persists over time and is accompanied by symptoms such as swelling, limited range of motion, and discomfort. Based on your description, it seems that you are experiencing significant knee issues that may require a more structured approach to treatment. Here are some insights regarding your concerns and recommendations on when to seek treatment and which type of doctor to consult.
Understanding Your Symptoms
1. Knee Stiffness and Swelling: The sensation of having something "stuck" in your knee, along with the inability to bend it, could indicate several underlying issues. Blood clots, as suggested by your physical therapist, can indeed cause swelling and stiffness. However, it is essential to differentiate between a true blood clot (deep vein thrombosis) and other causes of swelling, such as synovitis or a meniscal tear.
2. Management of Blood Clots: If a blood clot is suspected, it is crucial to seek medical attention promptly. Blood clots can lead to serious complications if they dislodge and travel to the lungs (pulmonary embolism). While some minor clots may resolve on their own, medical evaluation is necessary to determine the appropriate course of action. This may include imaging studies like an ultrasound to confirm the presence of a clot.
3. Treatment Options: The suggestion of acupuncture or traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) for managing swelling is common, but it should be approached with caution. While acupuncture can help with pain relief and inflammation, it is essential to ensure that there are no underlying serious conditions that require immediate medical intervention. If your symptoms do not improve or worsen, further evaluation, such as aspiration (removing fluid from the joint) or corticosteroid injections, may be warranted.
Choosing the Right Specialist
1. Western Medicine vs. Traditional Chinese Medicine: The choice between seeing a Western medical doctor or a TCM practitioner largely depends on your comfort level and the nature of your symptoms. Western medicine typically focuses on diagnosing the underlying cause through imaging and laboratory tests, followed by evidence-based treatments. In contrast, TCM may offer alternative therapies that can complement conventional treatments, especially for chronic pain management.
2. Consulting an Orthopedic Specialist: Given your ongoing knee issues, it may be beneficial to consult an orthopedic surgeon or a sports medicine specialist. These professionals are trained to diagnose and treat musculoskeletal conditions, including knee injuries. They can provide a comprehensive evaluation, including physical examination and imaging studies, to determine the best course of action.
3. Avoiding Frequent Doctor Changes: While it is understandable to seek multiple opinions, frequently changing doctors can lead to fragmented care. It is advisable to establish a relationship with a primary care physician or a specialist who can coordinate your care. This way, you can receive consistent treatment and follow-up, which is crucial for managing chronic conditions.
Recommendations for Your Situation
- Seek Immediate Evaluation: If you suspect a blood clot or if your knee pain and swelling worsen, seek immediate medical attention. An orthopedic specialist can perform the necessary evaluations and determine if further interventions are needed.
- Consider a Comprehensive Approach: If you are open to it, consider combining both Western and Eastern medicine approaches. For example, you could follow up with an orthopedic specialist for diagnosis and treatment while also exploring acupuncture or physical therapy for pain relief and rehabilitation.
- Monitor Your Symptoms: Keep track of your symptoms, including any changes in pain levels, swelling, or mobility. This information will be valuable for your healthcare provider in determining the best treatment plan.
In conclusion, knee pain can stem from various causes, and it is essential to approach treatment systematically. Consulting with an orthopedic specialist for a thorough evaluation is a prudent step. Additionally, considering complementary therapies can enhance your overall treatment experience. Remember, timely intervention is key to preventing further complications and ensuring a better quality of life.
Similar Q&A
Which Specialist Should I See for Chronic Knee Pain?
Since experiencing severe knee pain while climbing stairs several years ago, I have had recurrent episodes. Initially, my knee feels uncomfortable (it feels very tight while walking), followed by significant stiffness and swelling in my calf. In the past two months, I have also d...
Dr. Liao Yaopan reply Family Medicine
Hello, if the orthopedic consultation has confirmed that there are no issues, it is recommended to seek further evaluation from a rheumatologist. Please note that online consultations are not equivalent to in-person visits and cannot provide diagnoses or treatment recommendations...[Read More] Which Specialist Should I See for Chronic Knee Pain?
Which Specialist to Consult for Pain Behind the Knee?
If you are experiencing pain behind the knee, you should consult an orthopedic specialist.
Dr. Wang Zhaomin reply Rehabilitation
Please visit an orthopedic or rehabilitation clinic for consultation.[Read More] Which Specialist to Consult for Pain Behind the Knee?
Understanding Morning Knee Pain: When to See a Neurologist or Rehab Specialist
I am 45 years old, and recently I have been experiencing sudden knee pain every morning when I wake up. Sometimes the pain radiates down to my calves, but it usually subsides after a while. I have never experienced this before, and my family suggests it might be rheumatism. I wan...
Dr. Ye Boshou reply Neurology
You should first consult an orthopedic specialist to determine if there are any issues with your bones or tendons, as this is usually related to musculoskeletal pain. This could be due to prolonged standing or walking during the day, recent vigorous exercise, or even degenerative...[Read More] Understanding Morning Knee Pain: When to See a Neurologist or Rehab Specialist
Understanding Knee Pain: When to Consider Surgery vs. Medication
Hello Doctor: My knee has been painful for the past 4.5 years. Over a year ago, I underwent an MRI at Hospital A, which revealed cartilage fragmentation. I subsequently had arthroscopic surgery, but after the surgery, my knee developed swelling, and I was unable to bear weight, r...
Dr. Chu Baijun reply Orthopedics
Hello: MRI is a highly sensitive examination for knee issues. There is fragmentation of the knee cartilage, resulting in the formation of loose bodies (commonly referred to as "knee mice"). Arthroscopic surgery of the knee is the preferred treatment option. As for why t...[Read More] Understanding Knee Pain: When to Consider Surgery vs. Medication
Related FAQ
(Rehabilitation)
Knock Knees(Rehabilitation)
Knee(Neurology)
Foot Pain(Rehabilitation)
Knee(Surgery)
Coccyx Pain(Rehabilitation)
Knee Swelling(Orthopedics)
Knee Ligament(Orthopedics)
Patellar Dislocation(Orthopedics)
Post-Fracture Rehabilitation(Orthopedics)