Can Children Drink Growth Soup After Early Menstruation? - Traditional Chinese Medicine

Share to:

The issue of children consuming growth-enhancing soup?


Hello Dr.
Chang: Last year, when my daughter was nearly 10 years old, she had her first menstrual period.
We took her to see a pediatric geneticist, who advised that her early menstruation was concerning and recommended delaying injections.
She received these injections for a year, and her second menstrual period occurred this June.
She is currently 11 years old and 151.7 cm tall.
Is it safe for her to drink growth tonic? If she drinks the growth tonic, can she still take calcium tablets or calcium powder?

Zhuang Tai Tai, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/08/19

Dr. Zhang Weidong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine


Hello, Mrs.
Chuang: You can still drink the bone-strengthening soup.
Please consult a trusted traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) practitioner nearby to prescribe suitable herbal medicine for you.
As for the issue of health supplements, I recommend discussing it with your TCM practitioner.
Each physician has different views on health supplements, so it's best to have your doctor provide you with answers! Zhang Wei-Dong, Department of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Changhua Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare.

Reply Date: 2023/08/19

More Info


When it comes to the dietary needs of children, especially those who have experienced early menstruation, it is essential to approach the topic with care and a solid understanding of nutrition and growth. Your daughter, having started her menstruation at a young age, may have specific nutritional needs to support her growth and development.

Firstly, regarding the consumption of "growth soup" or any similar dietary supplements, it is crucial to understand what these products contain. Growth soups often include ingredients that are believed to promote bone health and overall growth, such as various herbs, animal bones, and sometimes added nutrients like calcium. Given that your daughter is 11 years old and has already experienced early menstruation, her body is undergoing significant changes, and she may benefit from a well-balanced diet that supports her growth.

In terms of calcium intake, it is vital for children, especially during their growth spurts, to have adequate calcium for bone development. The recommended dietary allowance (RDA) for calcium for children aged 9-18 years is about 1,300 mg per day. This can be achieved through a combination of dietary sources such as dairy products (milk, yogurt, cheese), leafy green vegetables, and fortified foods. If your daughter is consuming growth soup that is rich in calcium, it can complement her diet, but it is essential to monitor her overall calcium intake to avoid excessive consumption.

Regarding the use of calcium supplements, such as calcium tablets or powders, it is generally safe for children to take these if they are not getting enough calcium from their diet. However, it is crucial to consult with a healthcare provider before starting any supplements. They can assess your daughter's dietary intake and determine if supplementation is necessary. Over-supplementation can lead to health issues, including kidney stones and impaired absorption of other minerals.

Additionally, since your daughter has experienced early menstruation, it is essential to consider her overall health and nutritional status. Early menstruation can sometimes be associated with various factors, including genetics, body weight, and nutrition. Ensuring that she has a balanced diet rich in vitamins and minerals, particularly those that support hormonal balance and bone health, is crucial. Foods rich in magnesium, zinc, and vitamin D are also beneficial for overall health and development.

In conclusion, your daughter can consume growth soup, and it may be beneficial for her growth and development, especially if it is rich in essential nutrients. However, it is essential to balance this with her overall dietary intake, including calcium from food sources and any supplements. Consulting with a pediatrician or a nutritionist can provide personalized guidance tailored to her specific needs, ensuring that she receives the best possible support during this critical growth period. Regular check-ups can also help monitor her growth and development, addressing any concerns that may arise.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Growth Spurts: Do Boys Need Herbal Remedies Like Zhuanggu Soup?

Hello Dr. Lin, I would like to ask if it is too early for a boy in the fifth grade to start developing? (He has a slight Adam's apple, a hoarse and deep voice, and some fine pubic hair.) Will this affect his height growth? Is it necessary for him to drink growth tonic? Wha...


Dr. Lin Huanquan reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Hello: The purpose of the growth tonic is twofold: firstly, to promote growth and development, commonly referred to as increasing height; secondly, to regulate the body constitution during the growth process. Xiao Wu has started developing a bit early, as this typically occurs ar...

[Read More] Understanding Growth Spurts: Do Boys Need Herbal Remedies Like Zhuanggu Soup?


Effectiveness of Herbal Soup for Menstrual Relief: Expert Insights

Hello, doctor. I found a herbal soup for menstrual relief while browsing at Watsons. I'm not sure if it's effective since my period is not due until next week, but I'm hesitant to drink it because I'm afraid it might be bitter. Do you think it is effective? Al...


Dr. Lin Wenbin reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Biochemical soup has the effect of promoting blood circulation and can help eliminate blood stasis. However, from a Western medicine perspective, menstruation is a natural phenomenon and does not require specific medical treatment. Uterine polyps, once removed, may still recur. I...

[Read More] Effectiveness of Herbal Soup for Menstrual Relief: Expert Insights


Help! I'm a 14-Year-Old Struggling with Growth and Menstruation

I am a second-year junior high school student, and I haven't gotten my period yet. My height is only 151 cm, and my weight is 37 kg. I live in a rural area and am raised by my grandparents, so my diet is not very good; I only eat simple meals. I would like to know if there a...


Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
According to the growth curve percentiles for your age, both your height and weight are at the 3rd percentile (meaning you rank among the lowest three out of one hundred girls your age). This meets the criteria for referral for further evaluation (to check bone age and hormone le...

[Read More] Help! I'm a 14-Year-Old Struggling with Growth and Menstruation


Can You Drink Herbal Soup or Milk Tea During Your Period?

Is it okay to drink Four Gods Soup or fresh milk tea during menstruation? Will it cause a decrease in menstrual flow or end the period early?


Dr. Zhang Kunmin reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello, the general Four Gods Soup usually does not have significant effects unless there are other ingredients present. You may discuss this further with a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner. Thank you! Wishing you peace and health, Dr. Chang.

[Read More] Can You Drink Herbal Soup or Milk Tea During Your Period?


Related FAQ

Menstruation

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Postpartum Recovery

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Traditional Chinese Medicine Nutrition

(Nutrition)

During Pregnancy

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Growth And Development

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Herbal Decoction

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Acid Reflux

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Headache

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Bladder

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)

Hair

(Traditional Chinese Medicine)