Foot problems
Hello Dr.
You, I have a few questions regarding my mother's plantar pain.
My mother is 68 years old, and over three months ago, she experienced symptoms of plantar fasciitis in her left foot.
She went for acupuncture treatment, and the procedure was very painful; however, the doctor advised her to endure it.
Since then, the pain at the acupuncture site has not improved, and she feels pain when walking too much.
The pain seems to worsen with lack of sleep or cold weather, but it is less intense with sufficient rest, although it still hurts when pressed.
After a month and a half, she visited an orthopedic doctor and informed him about the acupuncture treatment, expressing concern that it might have caused damage, leading to persistent pain at the acupuncture site.
She requested an X-ray, but the doctor said it was unnecessary and diagnosed her with plantar fasciitis, prescribing pain medication to take as needed.
However, the pain at the acupuncture site persists, and she experiences sharp pain when pressing that area, while other areas and the plantar fasciitis region are no longer painful.
A couple of days ago, my mother went to a rehabilitation specialist who used ultrasound to examine the painful area on her foot to confirm whether it was indeed plantar fasciitis causing the prolonged pain.
The ultrasound indicated that the acupuncture site is still inflamed and swollen, while the plantar fasciitis area does not appear particularly affected.
The rehabilitation doctor suggested that the pain in her left foot is likely a bruise and recommended rehabilitation, foot soaking, and applying ointment to aid recovery.
The rehabilitation involves ultrasound and electrical therapy.
To provide additional context: the painful area on the left foot is located on the right side of the heel (near the arch close to the heel).
Here is a link to the image: https://imgur.com/a/wGUudHT.
I would like to ask Dr.
You:
1.
If acupuncture truly caused damage to the plantar area, is it possible for it to result in recurrent inflammation for such an extended period of three months?
2.
I am very concerned about the possibility of a broken needle being left inside during acupuncture, which could lead to localized pain and swelling.
Can ultrasound detect the presence of needles? Is an X-ray necessary?
3.
My mother's symptoms differ somewhat from typical plantar fasciitis symptoms; she does not experience pain or sharpness when getting out of bed in the morning, but rather feels pain after walking more.
Does this still qualify as plantar fasciitis, or could it indicate an injury to a specific area of the foot causing recurrent inflammation and pain?
Thank you, and I would also like to wish you a happy Lunar New Year, wishing you prosperity and good health in the Year of the Dragon.
Alex, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/02/16
Dr. You Dianqi reply Orthopedics
After evaluating the patient's condition, the physician will inform the patient if there is a need for additional examinations or assessments.
Please trust the physician's professional judgment.
If you have any concerns, it is advisable to consult in person.
Thank you.
Reply Date: 2024/02/16
More Info
Understanding foot pain, particularly in the context of plantar fasciitis and the effects of acupuncture, requires a comprehensive approach that considers both the physiological aspects of the condition and the potential implications of treatment methods like acupuncture.
1. Chronic Pain and Acupuncture: Your mother's experience of persistent pain after acupuncture raises valid concerns. While acupuncture can be beneficial for various musculoskeletal issues, it can also lead to complications if not performed correctly. If the acupuncture needles were inserted too deeply or inappropriately, they could potentially cause localized trauma or inflammation. However, it is uncommon for acupuncture to cause prolonged inflammation lasting three months. If the pain persists, it may indicate that the underlying condition, such as plantar fasciitis or another injury, has not been adequately addressed.
2. Needle Retention Concerns: The fear of a needle breaking and remaining embedded in the tissue is a legitimate concern, although it is rare. If a needle were to break, it would typically be visible on imaging studies. Ultrasound can help visualize soft tissue structures and may detect foreign bodies, including broken needles. X-rays are less effective for soft tissue evaluation but can rule out bony abnormalities. If there is a suspicion of retained needles or other foreign bodies, further imaging may be warranted.
3. Symptoms and Diagnosis: The symptoms your mother describes—pain that worsens with activity rather than upon waking—are somewhat atypical for classic plantar fasciitis, which often presents with sharp heel pain in the morning or after prolonged periods of inactivity. However, it is essential to note that plantar fasciitis can manifest differently in individuals. The fact that her pain is localized to the area where acupuncture was performed suggests that there may be an injury or inflammation specific to that site, possibly a soft tissue injury or even a mild strain of the plantar fascia itself.
4. Treatment and Rehabilitation: Given the ultrasound findings indicating inflammation at the acupuncture site, the recommended treatment of rehabilitation, including ultrasound therapy and electrical stimulation, is appropriate. These modalities can help reduce inflammation and promote healing. Additionally, your mother should consider modifying her activities to avoid exacerbating the pain, such as limiting prolonged standing or walking on hard surfaces.
5. Further Evaluation: If her symptoms do not improve with conservative management, a referral to a specialist, such as a podiatrist or orthopedic surgeon, may be beneficial. They can perform a more thorough evaluation, including a physical examination and possibly advanced imaging, to rule out other conditions such as plantar fibromatosis, nerve entrapment, or other soft tissue injuries.
In summary, while acupuncture can be a helpful treatment modality, it is crucial to monitor for any adverse effects, especially if pain persists. The symptoms your mother is experiencing may not align perfectly with plantar fasciitis, suggesting the need for further evaluation and possibly a different treatment approach. Ensuring that she receives appropriate care and rehabilitation will be key to her recovery.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Persistent Foot Pain: Insights for Effective Rehabilitation
The patient has been suffering for about five years and has not been diagnosed with plantar fasciitis (no doctor has made such a determination). They have consulted numerous practitioners in both traditional Chinese medicine and Western medicine (across many specialties), as well...
Dr. Chen Wayda reply Rehabilitation
Based on your description, it is difficult to make an accurate diagnosis. Please come to the clinic for an evaluation.[Read More] Understanding Persistent Foot Pain: Insights for Effective Rehabilitation
Understanding Plantar Fasciitis: Symptoms, Treatments, and Recovery Tips
For the past ten months, both of my feet have been experiencing pain at the front and back. The first visit to the doctor was ineffective. For the first three months, I managed by soaking my feet in hot water. I tried traditional Chinese medicine, but the results were limited. La...
Dr. Xie Tianjie reply Orthopedics
Foot pain is common in modern society, with patients often reporting soreness in the soles of their feet while standing or walking, which alleviates when sitting or resting. Foot pain can include conditions such as plantar fasciitis, fat pad syndrome, or calcaneal bone lesions. A...[Read More] Understanding Plantar Fasciitis: Symptoms, Treatments, and Recovery Tips
Understanding Foot Pain: Causes, Diagnosis, and Treatment Options
Hello, Doctor Shi: A couple of days ago, I started experiencing pain in my last toe, specifically at the junction of the phalanx and metatarsal bones. The pain came on suddenly and is quite intense. I visited a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner for massage, but it didn...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Is the pain located on the bottom of your foot, and is it accompanied by redness, swelling, and warmth? These are all important factors for diagnosis. Generally, plantar pain is often related to footwear or activities such as walking or running. Overuse can lead to inflammation o...[Read More] Understanding Foot Pain: Causes, Diagnosis, and Treatment Options
Understanding Metatarsal Pain vs. Plantar Fasciitis: Treatment Options and Advice
Are metatarsal pain and plantar fasciitis the same condition? Should I see an orthopedic doctor? I have previously consulted a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner and received acupuncture twice, but the bottom of my foot (the area under my toes) is still swollen and painful...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Metatarsal fractures and plantar fasciitis are distinct conditions. The metatarsals are located on the underside of the foot, consisting of five bones, and are typically caused by external trauma. A fracture is defined as a disruption in the continuity of the bone, which results ...[Read More] Understanding Metatarsal Pain vs. Plantar Fasciitis: Treatment Options and Advice
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Plantar Fasciitis(Orthopedics)
Dorsal Foot Pain(Orthopedics)
Foot Pain(Rehabilitation)
Plantar Fasciitis(Rehabilitation)
Feet(Family Medicine)
Foot Numbness(Orthopedics)
Foot(Internal Medicine)
Hallux Varus(Orthopedics)
Foot(Neurology)