Mental illness and civil service examinations, issues related to public service employment, and allocation of agencies?
Mental illness and public service employment, issues with job allocation, I remember when I was young and passed the civil service exam, no one dared to hire me, and I was not suitable for frontline work.
This was a long-standing controversy.
Later, the training committee held a coordination meeting.
Back then, I said that if no one dared to hire me, I would not take the public service job and would demand 5 million NTD in compensation.
Eventually, after some back-and-forth, I ended up working at a unit in the Ministry of Health and Welfare.
I think being assigned to a hospital's records room would also be acceptable.
If it’s as scary as everyone comments, being in a hospital, having a relapse, and receiving immediate medical attention seems fitting, haha, it’s frustrating.
I could go to a public hospital in the Kaohsiung-Pingtung area.
I have been in public service for nearly 21 years, with just over 6 years left on my mortgage.
It’s exhausting, and I wonder if I can redesign my career.
Also, do sheltered workshops offer salaries? What are the wages like? Is it at least minimum wage? I started working in public service right away and have never worked in other labor insurance jobs, so I’m unsure how jobs outside are.
Mental illness stigma still exists, just like 21 years ago; people still reject us.
I haven’t looked at related information for over a decade; is it still the same? We are in a helpless situation; who can help us? People keep saying how we should be, but I have been donating rice and supplies worth 6,000 NTD per year to local low-income households at temples, volunteering, and donating to the disadvantaged (certain disabilities) and sponsoring a poor child for 1,000 NTD per month.
Why is it so hard to even survive in employment? No one really dares to hire us.
I just want to say that there are more stable individuals (those with stabilized conditions who contribute to society), yet negative reports portray us this way.
Aren’t we supposed to step out? It’s frustrating.
I have been avoiding mental health-related topics to spare myself the sadness.
Fortunately, I passed the exam and have no choice but to continue; it’s a helpless feeling.
Can anyone offer advice?
Xiang (Cheng shang yi ti 208513), 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/05/21
Dr. Zhang Gengjia reply Psychiatry
Dear Ms.
Hsiang,
Thank you for once again providing a detailed description of your situation.
I understand the pressures and difficulties you are facing in both your work and personal life.
My recommendations are essentially the same as those for case 208513.
I hope these suggestions will be helpful to you, and I wish you a swift resolution to alleviate your work-related stress.
Wishing you all the best,
Dr.
Wang Cheng-Pang
Chianan Rehabilitation Hospital
(Note: I am responding on behalf of Dr.
Li Jun-Hong, who has been transferred to Taoyuan Rehabilitation Hospital.)
Reply Date: 2024/05/21
More Info
The challenges faced by public servants with mental health issues in Taiwan are multifaceted and deeply rooted in societal perceptions, workplace dynamics, and personal experiences. Mental health stigma remains a significant barrier, often leading to discrimination and exclusion from various opportunities, including employment in public service. This stigma can be exacerbated by a lack of understanding and awareness about mental health conditions among employers and colleagues, which can create an environment of fear and misunderstanding.
In your case, having worked in public service for nearly 21 years, it’s clear that you have navigated a complex landscape. The initial reluctance of employers to hire individuals with mental health issues reflects a broader societal fear of the unknown. Many employers may worry about the potential impact on workplace productivity or the ability of individuals to handle stress, especially in high-stakes environments like public service. This can lead to a cycle where individuals with mental health issues feel compelled to hide their conditions, leading to increased stress and feelings of isolation.
Your experience of being assigned to a position that may not align with your skills or interests, such as working in a hospital records room, highlights another challenge: the need for appropriate job placements that consider the unique strengths and limitations of individuals with mental health conditions. Job design and placement are crucial in ensuring that employees can thrive in their roles, especially for those who may require accommodations or a supportive work environment.
Moreover, your involvement in volunteer work and community support initiatives demonstrates a commitment to contributing positively to society, despite the challenges you face. This kind of engagement can be therapeutic and fulfilling, providing a sense of purpose and connection. However, it also raises questions about the recognition and support for individuals who are actively contributing to their communities while managing their mental health.
Regarding sheltered workshops, these can provide a viable employment option for individuals with mental health issues, offering a supportive environment where they can work at their own pace. However, the pay in such settings often aligns with minimum wage standards, which may not be sufficient for individuals trying to support themselves or their families. The balance between job satisfaction, mental health management, and financial stability is a delicate one.
It’s also important to consider the evolving landscape of mental health treatment and support in Taiwan. While there has been progress in reducing stigma and increasing awareness, many individuals still feel marginalized. The need for ongoing education about mental health in workplaces, schools, and communities is crucial. This can help foster a more inclusive environment where individuals with mental health issues are seen as valuable contributors rather than liabilities.
In conclusion, the challenges faced by public servants with mental health issues in Taiwan are complex and require a multifaceted approach. Advocacy for better workplace policies, increased awareness and education about mental health, and the promotion of supportive employment practices are essential steps toward creating a more inclusive society. Your experiences and insights are valuable in this dialogue, and sharing them can help raise awareness and foster understanding among those who may not fully grasp the challenges faced by individuals with mental health conditions. It’s crucial to continue seeking support, whether through professional counseling, peer support groups, or community resources, to navigate these challenges effectively.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Mental Health and Public Service Eligibility in Taiwan
Hello, Doctor. I would like to ask: 1. Does seeing a psychiatrist disqualify someone from being a public servant? The regulations for civil service examinations state that individuals with psychiatric disorders cannot hold public office. I would like to verify under what condit...
Dr. Zhang Fangrong reply Psychiatry
1. Does seeing a psychiatrist disqualify someone from holding a public office? Certainly not. In fact, the government conducts special examinations for individuals with disabilities annually. For more information, please refer to the Civil Service Examination website and other re...[Read More] Understanding Mental Health and Public Service Eligibility in Taiwan
Understanding the Rise of Mental Health Issues in Modern Society
Hello, doctor. I'm back to visit the Taiwan e-Hospital, a community for patients like me. Why is it that despite the continuous advancement of technology and society, there are more and more individuals suffering from psychosomatic disorders? Furthermore, some people, upon l...
Dr. Tang Jiahong reply Psychiatry
Hello. Based on the information you provided, it may be beneficial for you to find a trusted physician to discuss the impact of perceived enemies on your well-being and explore treatment options for your mental and physical health conditions. Perhaps after a more in-depth discuss...[Read More] Understanding the Rise of Mental Health Issues in Modern Society
Seeking Help: Navigating Mental Health Challenges in Taiwan
I am a gay person from a violent family background. I was very normal in elementary school, but in sixth grade, I experienced physical abuse from my father. In middle school, I was filled with resentment and had thoughts of death and killing. During high school, violent tendencie...
Dr. Lin Yanhong reply Psychiatry
If it's convenient for you, please come to the outpatient clinic for a detailed discussion. Thank you![Read More] Seeking Help: Navigating Mental Health Challenges in Taiwan
Seeking Mental Health Support in Taipei: A Teacher's Dilemma
Dear Dr. Song, I apologize for the intrusion. I am a teacher at Zhensheng Junior High School. I greatly admire your expertise after hearing your lecture at the school. I have a friend who has only been able to secure substitute teaching positions after four consecutive years of ...
Dr. Song Chengxian reply Psychiatry
Hello Pei-Ying: Regarding your friend's desire to seek medical help in Taipei for managing panic and anxiety issues, Taipei actually has the most mental health resources available. Not only do major medical centers (National Taiwan University Hospital, Veterans General Hospi...[Read More] Seeking Mental Health Support in Taipei: A Teacher's Dilemma
Related FAQ
(Psychiatry)
Emotional Distress(Psychiatry)
Facing Death(Psychiatry)
Difficulty Concentrating(Psychiatry)
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder(Psychiatry)
Suicide(Psychiatry)
Worry(Psychiatry)
Cbt(Psychiatry)
Social Anxiety Disorder(Psychiatry)
Low Mood(Psychiatry)