Regarding the assessment of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) in the context of physical examinations?
Hello Dr.
Wu, I am a 20-year-old university student majoring in Transportation Studies, currently in my second year.
I was diagnosed with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) in the third year of junior high school and have been taking medications "Ritalin" and "Adderall" daily since the first year of high school.
My doctor also prescribed "You-Jet" to alleviate the anxiety side effects that may arise from ADHD medications, and I have continued to take these medications without interruption.
My career plan is to graduate from university, complete military service, and then apply for a position in the railway industry, considering both Taiwan Railways and High-Speed Rail.
However, if I need to apply for positions such as train conductor or driver, I must pass the "Railway Operations Personnel Physical Examination Regulations," which includes a clause stating: "Individuals with any of the following conditions are disqualified: those with psychological or psychiatric disorders, speech, perception, motor, or cognitive impairments, or seizure disorders such as epilepsy." I have consulted with my psychiatrist, who reassured me that my condition (ADHD) does not fall under the category of psychological or psychiatric disorders, nor is it classified as a neurosis, so I should not worry.
However, I still have concerns regarding this classification and would like to ask you, Dr.
Wu: Is ADHD considered a psychiatric disorder or psychological abnormality in this context? Have there been cases in such occupational health assessments where individuals were deemed to have significant mental illnesses? I would appreciate any relevant cases you may have encountered for my reference.
Thank you, doctor!
Xiao Gan, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/07/01
Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
ADHD is quite common and is not classified as a severe mental illness! - Dr.
Wu En-Liang
Reply Date: 2024/07/01
More Info
ADHD, or Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, is a neurodevelopmental disorder that affects both children and adults. It is characterized by symptoms such as inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity. While ADHD can pose challenges in various aspects of life, including academic and occupational performance, it is generally not classified as a severe mental illness or a significant psychological disorder.
In the context of medical examinations for railway careers, such as those for train conductors or drivers, the regulations often stipulate that candidates must not have any significant psychological or neurological disorders. However, ADHD is typically not included in this category. As you mentioned, your psychiatrist has indicated that your ADHD does not fall under the classification of a major psychological disorder or functional impairment. This aligns with the understanding in the medical community that ADHD, when managed appropriately, does not inherently disqualify individuals from certain professions, including those in the transportation sector.
It is important to note that the perception of ADHD can vary among different medical professionals and regulatory bodies. Some may view it as a condition that requires careful management, while others may not see it as a barrier to employment. In your case, since you have been under treatment and are managing your symptoms with medication, this further supports the notion that you can perform your duties effectively.
Regarding your concerns about whether there have been cases where individuals with ADHD were disqualified from railway positions due to their condition, it is relatively uncommon. Most cases of disqualification in such fields are associated with more severe mental health issues, such as schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or significant cognitive impairments. ADHD, particularly when treated, does not typically lead to such disqualifications.
In terms of your career aspirations, it is advisable to maintain open communication with your healthcare provider. If you are concerned about how your ADHD might be perceived during the medical examination for railway personnel, you could consider obtaining a letter from your psychiatrist that outlines your diagnosis, treatment, and the management of your symptoms. This documentation can help clarify your situation to the examining authorities.
Additionally, it is beneficial to stay informed about the specific requirements and regulations of the railway companies you are interested in. Each organization may have slightly different criteria for medical examinations, and understanding these can help you prepare accordingly.
In summary, ADHD is generally not classified as a major mental disorder that would disqualify you from railway positions. With proper management and treatment, many individuals with ADHD successfully pursue careers in various fields, including transportation. It is essential to continue working with your healthcare provider to ensure that your condition is well-managed and to address any concerns you may have about your future career.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Attention Issues: Overcoming Exam Anxiety and Focus Challenges
I currently have generalized anxiety disorder, and both my counselor and previous psychiatrist suspect that I may have attention deficit issues. I would like to inquire about the problem of never being able to finish exams. Despite being well-prepared and able to answer every que...
Dr. Liao Dinglie reply Psychiatry
Hello, internet user: From your description, you are concerned that you may have Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). You feel that your attention is not focused, and you often find yourself unable to complete exams. Even though you understand subjects like mathematic...[Read More] Understanding Attention Issues: Overcoming Exam Anxiety and Focus Challenges
Understanding ADHD: Evaluation and Testing Process Explained
Hello, doctor. Recently, I noticed an introduction to ADHD in the news. I find that I closely match the symptoms related to inattention. I am not inquiring whether I have this condition; I just want to know what assessments or tests are typically conducted if I seek medical atten...
Dr. Zhang Fangrong reply Psychiatry
Dear Sir/Madam, If you are assessing adult Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), the evaluation can include self-report scales as well as assessments conducted by a psychologist. The report will be compiled by the psychologist, and it will take approximately 1-2 weeks...[Read More] Understanding ADHD: Evaluation and Testing Process Explained
Understanding ADHD: Seeking Effective Treatments and Solutions
Hello, I was diagnosed with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) in my first year of high school, and I am now a sophomore in college. However, I don't feel that my condition has improved since entering university (I was admitted through a recommendation process)....
Dr. Chen Wenyu reply Psychiatry
Hello, Arting: The first-line medication for treating Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is "Ritalin" (methylphenidate). However, some individuals may experience symptoms such as palpitations and anxiety, as you described. You should discuss this further wi...[Read More] Understanding ADHD: Seeking Effective Treatments and Solutions
Understanding ADHD: Medication Effects and Attention Challenges
Hello Dr. Wu, I am currently visiting the hospital for ADHD. I have been taking Strattera 25mg for 28 consecutive days, and I feel that there has been no improvement in my attention. I only feel that my heart is racing, which makes me uncomfortable, and my sexual function seems t...
Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
If you or your child experiences discomfort or insufficient effects from medication, please be sure to communicate this with your child and adolescent psychiatrist. There are many reasons for poor attention, such as depression, anxiety, and insomnia, which can all contribute to a...[Read More] Understanding ADHD: Medication Effects and Attention Challenges
Related FAQ
(Psychiatry)
Attention(Psychiatry)
Work Fatigue(Psychiatry)
Difficulty Concentrating(Psychiatry)
Hyperactive Child(Psychiatry)
Work Adaptation(Psychiatry)
Cbt(Psychiatry)
Diagnosis(Psychiatry)
Headache(Psychiatry)
Sleepwalking(Psychiatry)