Benign Cartilage Tumors in the Knee: Causes and Diagnosis

Knee cartilage tumor

My younger sister is 18 years old.
Earlier this year, she discovered a protrusion on the inner side of her right knee due to a sports injury.
Recently, she underwent an X-ray at a major hospital, and the doctor confirmed it to be a benign cartilage tumor.
However, when I asked the doctor about the cause of my sister's chondroma, he only mentioned genetics.
I would like to know how to accurately determine whether a chondroma is benign.
Additionally, since it is hereditary, should all family members undergo X-ray examinations to detect it? If so, which areas should be examined? Thank you!

Xiao Yu, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/09/13

Dr. Lin Gengxiao reply Orthopedics

1.
When assessing bone tumors, considerations include the nature of the cells, the tumor's location, and the rate of tumor growth.
While malignant tumors pose a threat to life, even benign tumors can cause significant issues depending on their location; for instance, tumors on joint surfaces may restrict movement, and those near nerves can lead to nerve compression.
Rapidly growing tumors are more likely to compress surrounding tissues.
2.
To determine whether a tumor is benign, X-rays are the most basic examination.
They can provide preliminary information about the presence, size, growth rate, and location of the tumor, and changes observed on X-rays can help in classification.
However, X-rays have limitations, and a diagnosis cannot be solely based on their results.
Physicians will arrange for further imaging studies such as computed tomography (CT), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), or even biopsy as clinically indicated.
3.
For tumors of the knee cartilage, attention should be paid to their location.
Patients should consult with their physician to determine if the tumor invades the joint surface, whether it may affect future mobility, and when the next follow-up should occur.
4.
Generally, bone tumors have few hereditary cases, and unless there is a clear family history, preventive screenings are not typically arranged.
If a physician suggests a hereditary component, patients can inquire whether family screenings or genetic testing should be considered.

Reply Date: 2004/09/13

More Info

Understanding benign cartilage tumors, particularly in the knee, is crucial for both diagnosis and management. Your sister's case of a benign cartilage tumor, confirmed through X-ray, raises several important questions regarding its causes, diagnosis, and implications for family members.

Causes of Benign Cartilage Tumors:
Benign cartilage tumors, such as osteochondromas or chondromas, can arise from various factors. While genetics can play a role, as indicated by your doctor, it is not the sole cause. These tumors often develop during periods of rapid growth, typically seen in children and adolescents. They can be associated with certain genetic conditions, such as multiple hereditary exostoses (MHE), which is characterized by the development of multiple osteochondromas. However, not all benign cartilage tumors are hereditary; many occur sporadically without a family history.

Diagnosis of Benign Cartilage Tumors:
To accurately determine whether a cartilage tumor is benign, several diagnostic steps are typically taken:
1. Imaging Studies: X-rays are the first step, as they can reveal the presence of a tumor and its characteristics. However, further imaging, such as MRI or CT scans, may be necessary to assess the tumor's size, location, and relationship to surrounding structures. MRI is particularly useful for evaluating soft tissue involvement and the cartilage itself.

2. Biopsy: In some cases, a biopsy may be performed to obtain a tissue sample for histological examination. This is the definitive way to determine the nature of the tumor. Benign tumors will show characteristic features under the microscope, such as well-defined borders and a lack of aggressive growth patterns.

3. Clinical Evaluation: A thorough clinical evaluation by an orthopedic specialist is essential. They will consider the patient's age, symptoms, and the tumor's behavior (e.g., whether it is growing or causing pain).

Family Screening:
Regarding the hereditary aspect, if your sister's tumor is indeed linked to a genetic condition, it may be prudent for other family members to undergo screening. However, not all benign cartilage tumors are hereditary. If there is a family history of similar tumors or associated conditions, it may warrant further investigation.

For family members, X-rays should focus on areas where tumors are commonly found, such as the long bones (femur, tibia, fibula) and the pelvis. If there are any symptoms or palpable masses, those areas should be prioritized for imaging.

Conclusion:
In summary, while your sister's benign cartilage tumor is likely not a cause for alarm, understanding its nature and potential hereditary implications is essential. Regular follow-ups with an orthopedic specialist and appropriate imaging can help monitor the tumor's behavior. If there are concerns about hereditary conditions, genetic counseling may also be beneficial for your family. Always consult with healthcare professionals for personalized advice and management plans tailored to your sister's specific situation.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Knee Osteochondroma: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options

One day while sitting and watching TV, I noticed a lump near my knee when I had my legs stretched out on the sofa. I found it quite strange, so I went to the public health center and was told it is a knee chondroma. I would like to inquire about the causes of this knee chondroma ...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Miss Yang, the issue you are inquiring about may be an osteochondroma, which is a benign and quite common tumor of the knee joint. If it is solitary, it is generally benign. The growth of the tumor is usually slow, and if it reaches a certain size, it may compress surrounding tis...

Understanding Knee Cartilage Growth: Causes, Treatment, and Concerns

I have a friend whose son is 14 years old. Recently, he discovered a growth on the inner side of his right knee that is about the size of an egg, but there were no previous issues in that area. An X-ray examination report states: "A pedunculated bony outgrowth is seen on the...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
What you described is a type of osteochondroma (also known as exostosis), which is usually benign and can typically be treated with surgical excision. Other treatment methods are generally ineffective, and diet does not play a role. The chance of recurrence is usually low. There ...

Pros and Cons of Surgical vs. Non-Surgical Treatment for Knee Cartilage Tumors

Please compare the pros and cons of surgical and non-surgical options.

Dr. Hong Ximing reply Orthopedics
The principles for surgery on knee chondromas are: if it affects knee joint function, if the tumor is growing larger, or if pain is impacting quality of life. However, for detailed information, please consult an orthopedic surgeon to establish a diagnosis. Thank you for your inqu...

Understanding Synovial Tumors: Symptoms, Treatment, and Prognosis

Hello, I would like to ask about my condition. I started experiencing severe pain in my knee in 1999 due to something getting stuck inside. X-rays showed normal results. By 2000, I began to have swelling, and the fluid extracted was bloody. After undergoing arthroscopy, small fra...

Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello: In response to your question... based on your description, you are most likely suffering from pigmented villonodular synovitis (PVNS), which is a benign tumor characterized by a tendency to recur. Pathologically, it may be derived from fibroblasts or macrophages, and the l...