Elderly individuals often have a tendency to collect items?
Hello, psychiatrist.
My father is nearly seventy years old, in good health, financially secure, and mentally clear.
However, he has always been frugal, and in recent years, he has developed a habit of picking up miscellaneous items and bringing them home.
I've even heard that he uses a stick to search for treasures in garbage piles.
This habit has caused us great distress, but despite our repeated advice, he refuses to listen.
Is there any way to improve this situation? Regards, Ah-Hui from Tainan.
Ah Hui, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2001/03/26
Dr. Lin Yanhong reply Psychiatry
Hello: From your description, your father's behavior does seem unusual, but it's difficult to determine the reasons behind it.
Is it simply a matter of being frugal by nature, or does he have specific thoughts? Have there been any changes in his other daily activities? Without this information, it is challenging to assess the underlying issues accurately.
I recommend that you take your father to see a psychiatrist under the pretext of a health check-up or for other reasons to gain a clearer understanding.
You can also call (06) 6351131-2101; I have clinic hours on the mornings of the 1st, 2nd, and 5th, as well as Thursday afternoons.
Only after a thorough evaluation can I provide you with appropriate advice.
Sincerely, Lin Yan-Hong, Xinying Hospital.
Reply Date: 2001/03/26
More Info
Hoarding behavior, particularly in seniors, can be a complex issue that often stems from a variety of psychological, emotional, and social factors. Understanding this behavior is crucial for families who wish to support their loved ones while also maintaining a safe and functional living environment.
Firstly, it’s important to recognize that hoarding is not merely a matter of being messy or disorganized; it is classified as a mental health disorder. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5) identifies hoarding disorder as characterized by persistent difficulty discarding or parting with possessions, regardless of their actual value. This behavior often leads to clutter that disrupts the individual’s living space and can create significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning.
In the case of your father, who is in his seventies and exhibits hoarding tendencies, several factors may contribute to his behavior. Seniors often face significant life changes, such as retirement, loss of loved ones, or declining health, which can lead to feelings of loneliness, anxiety, or a sense of loss of control. For some, collecting items can provide a sense of purpose or comfort, especially if they have lived through times of scarcity or hardship. Your father’s frugality and tendency to pick up items from the street may be rooted in a desire to save money or a belief that these items could be useful in the future.
To address this issue, here are several strategies that families can consider:
1. Open Communication: Start by having an open and non-judgmental conversation with your father about his behavior. Express your concerns from a place of care rather than criticism. Ask him about the significance of the items he collects and how they make him feel. Understanding his perspective can help you approach the situation more effectively.
2. Educate Yourself and Your Family: Learn more about hoarding disorder and its underlying causes. This knowledge can help you approach the situation with empathy and patience. It can also help you identify when professional intervention may be necessary.
3. Set Boundaries: While it’s important to respect your father’s autonomy, setting reasonable boundaries can help maintain a safe and functional living environment. Discuss specific areas of the home that need to remain clear for safety reasons, such as pathways and exits.
4. Encourage Professional Help: If your father’s hoarding behavior is severe and poses a risk to his health or safety, it may be beneficial to encourage him to seek help from a mental health professional. A therapist who specializes in hoarding disorder can provide strategies and support tailored to his needs. If he is resistant to the idea of therapy, you might suggest a general health check-up, framing it as a way to ensure he is healthy.
5. Involve Support Groups: There are support groups for both individuals with hoarding tendencies and their families. These groups can provide valuable resources, coping strategies, and a sense of community. Engaging with others who understand the challenges can be beneficial for both you and your father.
6. Gradual Decluttering: If your father is open to it, consider a gradual approach to decluttering. Start with less emotionally charged items and work together to sort through them. This can help him feel more in control of the process and less overwhelmed.
7. Focus on Emotional Support: Sometimes, hoarding behavior is a manifestation of deeper emotional issues. Providing emotional support and companionship can help alleviate feelings of loneliness or anxiety that may contribute to his hoarding.
8. Safety First: If the clutter poses immediate safety risks, such as fire hazards or health concerns, it may be necessary to take more direct action. In extreme cases, contacting local health services or social services for assistance may be warranted.
In conclusion, addressing hoarding behavior in seniors requires a compassionate and understanding approach. By fostering open communication, educating yourself and your family, and encouraging professional help, you can support your father in managing his behavior while ensuring a safe living environment. Remember, change may take time, and patience is key in this process.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Hoarding Behavior in Seniors: Seeking Help for a Loved One
Hello Dr. Shen: I have a long-standing issue that I seek your professional opinion on. My mother-in-law is sixty years old and has a habit of collecting junk and hoarding it at home without organizing it, which has filled several rooms and even the balcony, creating a dirty envir...
Dr. Shen Zhengnan reply Geriatrics
Hello, there are several possible situations regarding the behavior of elderly individuals collecting scrap: 1. If this habit or related work existed during their youth, it may be a continuation of their original behavior into old age, which, due to a decline in cognitive abiliti...[Read More] Understanding Hoarding Behavior in Seniors: Seeking Help for a Loved One
Understanding Family Dynamics and Mental Health: Coping with Anxiety and Depression
Hello, doctor. I find myself in a difficult situation, which is why I'm asking here. With the pandemic, the children have been home, making it impossible for me to visit the hospital for a discussion. Here’s the situation: my husband is also a healthcare professional, but he...
Dr. Cai Qijin reply Psychiatry
Hello: 1. Based on the information you provided, the gentleman may exhibit symptoms related to hoarding disorder. Following external intervention, he may also experience subsequent emotional symptoms, necessitating an evaluation for possible major depressive episodes. It is advis...[Read More] Understanding Family Dynamics and Mental Health: Coping with Anxiety and Depression
Understanding Repetitive Behaviors in Aging Parents: A Mental Health Perspective
In the past two to three years, I have noticed that my father exhibits certain fixed and repetitive behaviors that are time-sensitive. On specific days, he repeatedly calls a few designated individuals, and if they do not answer, he continues to call persistently for a long time....
Dr. Wu Enliang reply Psychiatry
It seems that your personality has changed somewhat in recent years. It is advisable to seek medical attention from a psychiatrist or neurologist. Dr. Wu En-Liang.[Read More] Understanding Repetitive Behaviors in Aging Parents: A Mental Health Perspective
Addressing Disturbing Behavior in Elderly Relatives: A Family's Dilemma
Hello, doctor. My grandfather is in his 80s and has started exhibiting troubling behaviors over the past year or two. He has been stealing underwear, targeting both neighbors and his daughter-in-law, and has even sexually harassed his daughter-in-law and exposed himself to the ne...
Dr. Xiao Minghong reply Psychiatry
Dear Ms. Chiu, Due to the insufficient information you provided, I can only make judgments based on the information currently available. If there are any shortcomings, I hope you can be understanding. The symptoms you mentioned, such as stealing underwear and exposing oneself, m...[Read More] Addressing Disturbing Behavior in Elderly Relatives: A Family's Dilemma
Related FAQ
(Psychiatry)
Family Interaction(Psychiatry)
Alzheimer'S Disease(Psychiatry)
Bulimia Nervosa(Psychiatry)
Sleepwalking(Psychiatry)
Cbt(Psychiatry)
Hypochondria(Psychiatry)
Adhd-Related(Psychiatry)
Dementia(Geriatrics)
Social Anxiety Disorder(Psychiatry)