Should You Skip Dinner for Weight Loss? Expert Insights on Meal Timing - Family Medicine

Share to:

Weight loss


Hello, Dr.
Hong.
I would like to ask whether it is better to skip dinner and replace it with fruit, or to replace lunch with fruit and have a normal dinner.
Some people say that not eating dinner can leave the stomach empty for too long, which is not good since breakfast is not eaten until the next day.
Thank you.

Ayu, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/10/14

Dr. Hong Chuanqi reply Family Medicine


Hello Ayu,
1.
To lose weight, it's not about replacing breakfast, lunch, or dinner with fruit; if you must choose, it's better to replace dinner, but do not skip dinner entirely.
If you eat more at breakfast, that would be ineffective.

2.
The best and only method for weight loss is exercise.
Older generations tended to work hard and eat less, resulting in a lean physique, while modern individuals eat more and better but exercise less, leading to obesity and a host of diseases such as diabetes and cancer.
Controlling food intake is merely a supportive measure.

Hong Chuanqi, 93.10.14

Reply Date: 2004/10/14

More Info


When it comes to weight loss, the timing and composition of meals play a crucial role in achieving your goals while maintaining overall health. Skipping dinner or replacing it with fruit may seem like a quick fix, but it can lead to several complications and may not be the most effective strategy for sustainable weight loss.

First and foremost, skipping dinner can disrupt your body's natural metabolic processes. When you go for extended periods without food, such as from dinner until breakfast the next day, your body may enter a state of starvation. This can slow down your metabolism as your body tries to conserve energy, making it harder to lose weight in the long run. Additionally, prolonged fasting can lead to increased hunger the following day, which may result in overeating at subsequent meals. This cycle can create a pattern of unhealthy eating behaviors that are counterproductive to weight loss.

Moreover, replacing dinner with fruit alone may not provide the necessary nutrients your body needs. While fruits are rich in vitamins, minerals, and fiber, they often lack sufficient protein and healthy fats, which are essential for muscle maintenance and overall health. A balanced meal should include a variety of food groups, including lean proteins, whole grains, healthy fats, and plenty of vegetables. This balance helps to keep you satiated, supports muscle repair, and provides the energy needed for daily activities.

Instead of skipping dinner, consider adopting a more balanced approach. Here are some expert insights on meal timing and composition that can help you lose weight effectively:
1. Regular Meal Timing: Aim to eat at regular intervals throughout the day. This can help regulate your metabolism and prevent extreme hunger that leads to overeating. If your schedule allows, try to have three balanced meals and one or two healthy snacks.

2. Balanced Dinner: For dinner, focus on a meal that includes lean protein (such as chicken, fish, or legumes), whole grains (like brown rice or quinoa), and a variety of vegetables. This combination will provide essential nutrients and keep you feeling full longer.

3. Portion Control: Pay attention to portion sizes. Eating smaller portions can help you manage calorie intake without feeling deprived. Use smaller plates to help control portions visually.

4. Healthy Snacks: If you find yourself hungry between meals, opt for healthy snacks like nuts, yogurt, or fresh fruits and vegetables. These can help bridge the gap between meals without adding excessive calories.

5. Hydration: Staying hydrated is crucial for weight loss. Sometimes, feelings of hunger can actually be signs of dehydration. Aim to drink plenty of water throughout the day.

6. Listen to Your Body: Pay attention to your hunger and fullness cues. Eating when you are hungry and stopping when you are satisfied can help you maintain a healthy weight.

7. Consult a Professional: If you are unsure about your dietary choices or need personalized advice, consider consulting a registered dietitian or nutritionist. They can help you create a meal plan that fits your lifestyle and weight loss goals.

In conclusion, skipping dinner is not the most effective strategy for weight loss. Instead, focus on balanced meals, regular eating patterns, and listening to your body's needs. This approach will not only support your weight loss efforts but also promote overall health and well-being. Remember, sustainable weight loss is a gradual process that requires patience and consistency.

Similar Q&A

Struggling with Irregular Meal Times: Tips for Healthy Eating

Hello, nutritionist: I currently work at a daycare, and the busiest hours are from 5 to 7 PM. Therefore, I eat dinner later, around 8 to 9 PM, which feels like having a late-night snack every day. To avoid getting hungry, I also eat a little something in the afternoon around 3 to...


Dr. Qi Minghua reply Nutrition
Based on your height, your ideal weight range is 55 to 67 kg, which means you fall into the category of being over 10% above your Ideal Body Weight (IBW) and can be classified as obese. You mentioned that you are busy with work until 7 PM for dinner, which is not considered late....

[Read More] Struggling with Irregular Meal Times: Tips for Healthy Eating


Does Eating Only When Hungry Benefit Your Health?

I have been consistently exercising and have a regular workout routine, almost daily. However, I have recently gained a few kilograms without realizing it. I think it might be because I am eating too much during my main meals (I do not snack, eat late-night meals, or drink bevera...


Dr. Ye Qianyu reply Family Medicine
Hello! Everyone's metabolic rate is different, so it cannot be generalized. If you feel that you are gaining weight with your current diet and exercise habits, it is advisable to undergo a health check-up to understand your Body Mass Index (BMI), body composition, basic live...

[Read More] Does Eating Only When Hungry Benefit Your Health?


Understanding Unintentional Weight Loss: When to Seek Medical Advice

Hello, doctor. This inquiry is on behalf of my mother. She is currently 56 years old and has experienced a weight loss from 61 kg to around 56 kg over the past 5 to 6 months, without any dieting or exercise. My mother is a teacher and often skips lunch due to her dislike of the s...


Dr. Ye Qianyu reply Family Medicine
Hello! It is recommended to visit the Metabolism Clinic for consultation.

[Read More] Understanding Unintentional Weight Loss: When to Seek Medical Advice


Understanding Breakfast: Timing and Healthy Snacking Between Meals

Hello, Doctor: I have a few related questions to ask. 1. How long after waking up without eating can it be considered that one has skipped breakfast? 2. The Department of Health advocates for regular meal times; does this also imply that one should not eat anything between meals?...


Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Internal Medicine
1. How long after waking up without eating can it be considered skipping breakfast? According to the normal human biological clock, humans work and are active during the day and rest and sleep at night. Therefore, three meals a day are generally needed, typically breakfast, lunch...

[Read More] Understanding Breakfast: Timing and Healthy Snacking Between Meals


Related FAQ

Weight Loss

(Family Medicine)

Family Medicine

(Nutrition)

Eating Habits

(Nutrition)

Digestion

(Family Medicine)

Binge Eating

(Psychiatry)

Bowel Movements

(Family Medicine)

Loss Of Appetite

(Gastroenterology and Hepatology)

Body Temperature

(Family Medicine)

Obesity

(Internal Medicine)

Accidental Ingestion

(Family Medicine)