Knee Pain: Could It Be Gout? Insights from Traditional Chinese Medicine

Knee pain

Hello, for the past year or two, I have been experiencing knee pain for about four days each month, but it is not accompanied by soreness.
The pain can occur in either the left or right knee, and when I try to sit down or stand up, the pain is almost unbearable, making it difficult to remain upright.
Could this condition be related to gout? Currently, I am studying in Scotland, and the weather has turned cold, with temperatures often below 7-8 degrees Celsius.
About two weeks ago (around October 5th), I developed a rash on my upper body that lasted for about ten days.
After that, my left knee hurt for about 4-5 days, and now my right knee has started to hurt.
I would like to know what might be wrong with my body.
Thank you, Connie.

connie, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/10/21

Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine

The symptoms worsen significantly at temperatures of 7-8°C, which is due to poor blood circulation.
Previous injuries have led to the formation of fibrous tissue during the healing process, obstructing blood flow.
When the temperature drops, blood coagulation and Qi stagnation can cause knee pain.
Using knee braces to increase the temperature around the knee or applying heat therapy can improve blood circulation and alleviate the pain.

Reply Date: 2004/10/21

More Info

Hello Connie,
Thank you for reaching out with your concerns regarding your knee pain. Based on your description, it seems that you are experiencing intermittent knee pain that is quite severe when transitioning from sitting to standing. You also mentioned that this pain alternates between your left and right knee and has been occurring for the past couple of years. Given the context of your symptoms and the recent cold weather in Scotland, let's explore the possibility of gout and other potential causes from a Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) perspective.

Gout is a form of inflammatory arthritis characterized by sudden and severe pain, redness, and swelling in the joints, often affecting the big toe but can also involve the knees. It is caused by the accumulation of uric acid crystals in the joints, leading to inflammation. While your description of pain does not include swelling or redness, it is still possible that gout could be a contributing factor, especially if you have a history of high uric acid levels or dietary habits that may predispose you to gout attacks.

From a TCM perspective, knee pain can be attributed to several factors, including "wind," "cold," and "dampness," which can obstruct the flow of Qi (energy) and blood in the body. The cold weather you are experiencing may exacerbate these conditions, leading to increased pain and discomfort in your knees. TCM often views the body as a system where imbalances can lead to pain and dysfunction. The fact that your knee pain is severe enough to hinder your ability to stand suggests that there may be an underlying blockage or deficiency that needs to be addressed.

Additionally, the rash you experienced prior to the onset of knee pain could indicate an underlying issue with your immune system or skin health, which may also be related to your joint pain. In TCM, skin issues can sometimes reflect internal imbalances, such as heat or dampness in the body.

To address your knee pain, consider the following recommendations:
1. Warmth and Protection: Given the cold weather, it is essential to keep your knees warm. You might want to use knee warmers or heat packs to improve circulation and alleviate pain. This aligns with TCM principles of using warmth to dispel cold and promote the flow of Qi and blood.

2. Dietary Adjustments: Pay attention to your diet, as certain foods can influence uric acid levels. Reducing intake of purine-rich foods (such as red meat, shellfish, and alcohol) may help if gout is a concern. Incorporating more fruits, vegetables, and whole grains can support overall health.

3. Herbal Remedies: TCM offers various herbal formulations that can help alleviate knee pain and improve circulation. Herbs like Du Huo (Angelica pubescens) and Sang Zhi (Mulberry twig) are often used to treat joint pain and inflammation.

4. Acupuncture: This TCM practice can be beneficial for pain relief and improving the flow of Qi in the body. Acupuncture may help reduce inflammation and alleviate pain in your knees.

5. Consult a Healthcare Professional: It is crucial to consult with a healthcare provider, preferably one familiar with both Western and Eastern medicine, to get a comprehensive evaluation. Blood tests can help determine uric acid levels, and imaging studies can rule out other conditions.

In conclusion, while gout could be a potential cause of your knee pain, it is essential to consider other factors, including environmental influences and internal imbalances as viewed through the lens of TCM. Taking proactive steps to manage your symptoms and seeking professional guidance will be key to finding relief. Please take care, and I hope you find a solution to your knee pain soon.

Best regards.

Similar Q&A

Traditional Chinese Medicine Solutions for Knee Joint Discomfort

A year ago, I visited an orthopedic specialist due to discomfort in my knee and underwent an X-ray examination. The diagnosis was cartilage wear in the knee. The physician believed that I was still young and not suitable for taking glucosamine supplements, so he only recommended ...

Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
In Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), the treatment of cartilage wear involves differentiation and treatment based on the patient's specific condition, which includes observing, listening, questioning, and pulse diagnosis. The prescription is tailored according to the patie...

Understanding Knee Pain: Insights from Traditional Chinese Medicine

Hello Dr. Yan, I had a car accident at the end of 2017, during which I sustained a bruise on my right knee and received immediate treatment. Concerned about potential issues with the knee joint, I went to an orthopedic clinic for an X-ray. After the orthopedic physician reviewed...

Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dear Online Friend Ah Xiang, Thank you for your letter. Every experience leaves a mark; a knee that has been injured may heal, but it will not return to its original state. Just like a cut from a knife leaves a scar, the tissues beneath the skin also bear the effects. Even now, ...

Understanding Knee Pain: When to Seek Traditional vs. Orthopedic Treatment

In May of this year, I started doing some Tabata exercises (squats and lunges) and after about a month, I noticed pain in my knees. I went to see a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner for treatment. The treatment included acupuncture, which felt very sore, followed by the d...

Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, based on your description, it is possible that you are experiencing symptoms of patellar malalignment, which is common among young women. Additionally, excessive exercise in a short period may have exacerbated the symptoms. Please visit an orthopedic clinic for an examinat...

Understanding Inner Heel Pain: Causes and Treatments in Traditional Chinese Medicine

1. Elevated serum uric acid levels have been present for three months, and despite treatment, there has been no reduction; the patient is still on medication. 2. An X-ray was performed, and the physician noted no evidence of bone spurs. 3. The main symptom is that the feet feel...

Dr. Chen Weili reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
Mr. Wang: 1. Elevated uric acid levels should be managed not only with medication but also through dietary control. It is advisable to avoid high-purine foods as much as possible. If you have any questions, please consult a nearby hospital. 2. For heel pain, please apply a hot co...