The knee has not healed despite prolonged treatment?
At the end of last year, during a visit to Hsinchu, I had 50cc of fluid drained from my knee due to swelling.
The doctor mentioned that the fluid had some blood in it, which could indicate an old injury; however, I couldn't recall any specific injury.
Later, the doctor suggested an injection (which I believe was a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory medication) and said the chances of improvement were high, but unfortunately, there was no improvement.
Two days after the injection, I noticed a bruise-like area (about the size of a red bean) on my knee.
The doctor advised me to use "heat therapy" to help disperse the blood clot.
The pain persisted without improvement, so I underwent an MRI, and the doctor reassured me that it was not a "malignant bone tumor." The MRI results indicated swelling and mild "plica syndrome." Since the doctor had done his best, he advised me to wear a knee brace regularly or consider arthroscopic surgery at a larger hospital.
Now, whenever my knee hurts, the injection site (a little above the knee) swells into a round lump, and I have difficulty squatting (it feels tight), making it hard to go up and down stairs.
In September of this year, I visited the orthopedics department at Linkou Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, expecting to undergo the daunting "arthroscopy." However, the doctor explained that this condition is more common in females, and both of my knees have the same issue, with the left knee being the first to show symptoms.
He recommended training my quadriceps, doing 100 repetitions daily for 5 seconds each, and taking medication if the pain worsens.
If there is no improvement after three months, he suggested surgery to release the lateral ligaments.
So far, my knee still hurts, and there hasn't been any improvement.
What should I do? I have always seen orthopedic specialists, and one doctor at a different hospital mentioned that my issue "might be an intra-articular obstruction, possibly involving the meniscus and cruciate ligaments." Since the MRI did not reveal any issues, he suggested that an arthroscopy might be necessary.
Do I really need to undergo arthroscopy? I feel a sense of fear regarding surgery.
This situation has troubled me for nearly a year, and despite visiting two or three different hospitals, there has been no improvement, and I still lack a definitive diagnosis and cause.
Therefore, I am unsure how to proceed with targeted treatment.
I happened to read an article in the newspaper titled "What is a synovial plica?" It refers to excess synovial tissue left over from early fetal development.
Normally, during later development, these tissues gradually merge into a single large synovial cavity.
If this merging process is incomplete, it can result in a band-like fold of synovial tissue near the knee.
I would like to ask the doctor if there is a way to improve and potentially cure my condition.
Yan Zai Mei, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/11/17
Dr. Shi Qiming reply Orthopedics
Dear netizen: Based on your condition, after various imaging examinations, a definitive diagnosis has still not been obtained.
It is indeed necessary to perform arthroscopy for both diagnosis and treatment.
If intra-articular bone cysts are discovered during the procedure, they can be treated simultaneously.
Director of Orthopedics, Hsinchu Hospital, Department of Health, Executive Yuan, Dr.
Wang Tzu-Kang.
Reply Date: 2004/11/17
More Info
Chronic knee pain can be a complex and frustrating condition, especially when it persists despite various treatments and evaluations. Based on your description, it seems that you have undergone several diagnostic procedures, including aspiration of knee fluid and MRI scans, which have not provided a clear resolution to your symptoms. The presence of blood-tinged fluid during aspiration may indicate underlying issues, such as previous trauma or internal bleeding, even if you do not recall a specific injury.
Your MRI results showing edema and mild "plica syndrome" suggest that there may be irritation or inflammation in the knee joint, possibly related to the synovial plica, which is a remnant of embryonic tissue that can become inflamed or irritated. This condition is more common in women and can lead to pain and restricted movement, particularly during activities like squatting or climbing stairs.
The recommendation to strengthen your quadriceps muscles is a common and effective approach to managing knee pain. Stronger quadriceps can help stabilize the knee joint and reduce the strain on other structures, potentially alleviating pain. It is essential to follow a structured rehabilitation program, focusing on gradual strengthening and flexibility exercises. If pain persists, consider consulting a physical therapist who can tailor a program to your specific needs and monitor your progress.
Regarding the suggestion of arthroscopic surgery, it is understandable to feel apprehensive about surgical intervention. However, if conservative measures, including physical therapy and injections, have not provided relief, arthroscopy may be a reasonable next step. This minimally invasive procedure allows for direct visualization of the knee joint and can address issues such as meniscal tears or plica syndrome that may not be evident on MRI.
Before proceeding with surgery, it is crucial to have a thorough discussion with your orthopedic surgeon about the potential benefits and risks. Ask about the specific findings that would warrant surgery and what the expected outcomes are. It may also be helpful to seek a second opinion from another orthopedic specialist, particularly one who has experience with knee conditions similar to yours.
In addition to surgical options, consider exploring other non-invasive treatments. These may include:
1. Corticosteroid Injections: If you haven't already, corticosteroid injections can help reduce inflammation and provide temporary relief from pain.
2. Hyaluronic Acid Injections: These injections may help lubricate the joint and improve mobility, particularly in cases of osteoarthritis.
3. Physical Therapy: A physical therapist can provide targeted exercises to improve strength, flexibility, and function, which may alleviate pain over time.
4. Alternative Therapies: Some patients find relief through acupuncture, massage therapy, or chiropractic care. While the evidence for these treatments varies, they may be worth exploring as adjuncts to your primary treatment plan.
5. Weight Management: If applicable, maintaining a healthy weight can significantly reduce stress on the knee joint, potentially alleviating pain.
6. Activity Modification: Avoiding activities that exacerbate your pain and incorporating low-impact exercises, such as swimming or cycling, can help maintain fitness without putting undue stress on your knee.
In conclusion, while your situation is undoubtedly challenging, there are multiple avenues to explore for relief. Engaging in a comprehensive treatment plan that includes physical therapy, potential surgical options, and lifestyle modifications may ultimately lead to improved function and quality of life. It's essential to remain proactive in your care and communicate openly with your healthcare providers about your concerns and treatment preferences.
Similar Q&A
Effective Strategies for Managing Persistent Knee Pain: A Comprehensive Guide
Dear Dr. Lee, I have been experiencing knee pain for the past two years, which has caused significant inconvenience in my daily life, especially since I used to enjoy walking and hiking as forms of exercise. I have sought medical attention multiple times, but the opinions have v...
Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello: In response to your question, based on your description, possible diagnoses include patellar chondromalacia or subluxation, avascular necrosis of the femoral condyle, and degenerative arthritis. The diagnostic tools should be utilized in the following order: 1. Standing kn...[Read More] Effective Strategies for Managing Persistent Knee Pain: A Comprehensive Guide
Understanding Persistent Knee Discomfort: Causes and Solutions for Active Individuals
Hello Dr. Cheng, I am someone who loves sports, including swimming, basketball, various ball games, and jogging. However, since I completed my military service and started working over a year ago, my physical activity has significantly decreased. Two months ago, I began experien...
Dr. Zheng Shunping reply Rehabilitation
Hello: In response to your question... it is difficult to determine the cause based solely on your description. In addition to your medical history, a thorough clinical physical examination is necessary, along with further imaging studies such as X-rays, ultrasounds, MRI scans, o...[Read More] Understanding Persistent Knee Discomfort: Causes and Solutions for Active Individuals
Chronic Knee Pain in Young Adults: Causes and Solutions
Since I was about six or seven years old, I have frequently experienced knee pain. My parents said it was due to growing pains, so they would rub in some liniment, which would help alleviate the discomfort. Now that I am almost twenty-two, I still experience these symptoms, parti...
Dr. Chen Xingyuan reply Orthopedics
Dear User: Based on your description, if your knee pain is not related to activity, it is important to consider whether it may be a rheumatologic or immunological issue, or a pathology of the knee joint. I recommend that you visit an orthopedic clinic or a rheumatology clinic (pr...[Read More] Chronic Knee Pain in Young Adults: Causes and Solutions
Persistent Knee Pain After Injury: Seeking Answers and Solutions
Hello Doctor: Thank you for your tireless efforts in answering the questions of netizens. I truly appreciate it. In mid-February, while running, I tripped over an unknown object and fell, landing on both knees. The pain was so intense that I lay on the ground for several minutes,...
Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, both meniscus and cruciate ligament injuries cannot be diagnosed with X-rays; an MRI is necessary. Regarding the interpretation of MRI results, there can be some margin of error. PRP injections cannot alleviate pain from a right knee fracture; if there is no displacement, ...[Read More] Persistent Knee Pain After Injury: Seeking Answers and Solutions
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Knee Swelling(Orthopedics)
Joint Pain(Orthopedics)
Femoral Pain(Orthopedics)
Knee(Neurology)
Dorsal Foot Pain(Orthopedics)
Knee(Rehabilitation)
Heel Pain(Orthopedics)
Calf Pain(Orthopedics)
Periostitis(Orthopedics)