Diuretics: Why Aren't They Working for Edema? - Pharmacology

Share to:

Medication Consultation


D.R.
Liu: I would like to ask why edema has not improved despite taking three diuretics daily as prescribed.
Additionally, is DORMICUM a prescription medication, and can it be obtained by individuals or at pharmacies? It seems that I need to double the dosage for it to be effective.
Sorry to bother you during your busy schedule.
Thank you.

L.S.S., 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/03/17

Dr. Liu Huiya reply Pharmacology


Dear L.S.S,
As far as I know, there are many reasons for the body to experience edema, and the use of diuretics is just one symptomatic treatment to help alleviate the symptoms.
More importantly, it is essential to identify and address the underlying cause of the edema for effective resolution.
For instance, is the edema pathological and caused by medication? You mentioned that taking three diuretic pills has not been effective; may I ask how long you have been on this medication? Some medications may take a few days to reach their optimal effect during the initial phase of treatment.
If you have been taking it for a while and still see no improvement, I recommend that you return to your physician to discuss your concerns and seek further evaluation or adjustments to your treatment plan.
Dormicum is a prescription medication and is classified as a controlled substance, which is usually not easily obtained at pharmacies.
This oral formulation is typically used to treat insomnia, and any dosage adjustments should be determined by your physician based on your condition.
If the prescribed dosage is insufficient and leads to inadequate effects, you should openly communicate this to your physician so they can adjust the dosage to better suit your needs or consider switching to other sleep medications (there are at least ten alternatives available) to establish the best treatment plan for you.
Therefore, I advise against privately adjusting the dosage of sleep medications to avoid more severe issues such as drug dependence or withdrawal.
Thank you for your letter, and I wish you peace and safety!

Reply Date: 2005/03/17

More Info


Diuretics are commonly prescribed medications used to help reduce fluid retention (edema) in the body by promoting the excretion of sodium and water through urine. However, there are several reasons why diuretics may not be effective for certain individuals experiencing edema, even when taken as prescribed.

1. Underlying Medical Conditions: The effectiveness of diuretics can be significantly influenced by the underlying cause of the edema. Conditions such as heart failure, liver cirrhosis, kidney disease, or certain hormonal imbalances can lead to fluid retention that is resistant to diuretics. For instance, in heart failure, the body may retain fluid due to decreased cardiac output, and simply increasing diuretic dosage may not address the root cause of fluid retention.

2. Type of Diuretic: There are different classes of diuretics, including thiazide diuretics, loop diuretics, and potassium-sparing diuretics. Each class works differently and may be more or less effective depending on the specific condition causing the edema. For example, loop diuretics like furosemide are often more potent and may be preferred in cases of significant fluid overload, while thiazide diuretics may be less effective in such scenarios.

3. Dosage and Administration: The dosage of the diuretic may not be sufficient to achieve the desired effect. In some cases, patients may require higher doses or more frequent administration to see a reduction in edema. However, increasing the dose should always be done under medical supervision to avoid potential side effects, such as electrolyte imbalances.

4. Medication Interactions: Other medications that a patient is taking can interfere with the effectiveness of diuretics. For example, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) can reduce the effectiveness of diuretics by promoting sodium retention. Additionally, certain supplements or over-the-counter medications may also have similar effects.

5. Dietary Factors: Sodium intake plays a crucial role in fluid retention. If a patient continues to consume a high-sodium diet, it can counteract the effects of diuretics. Patients are often advised to follow a low-sodium diet to enhance the effectiveness of diuretics.

6. Patient Compliance: Adherence to the prescribed medication regimen is essential for the effectiveness of diuretics. If a patient is not taking the medication as directed, it may lead to inadequate management of edema.

Regarding your question about DORMICUM (midazolam), it is indeed a prescription medication primarily used for sedation and anxiety relief. It is classified as a benzodiazepine and is typically administered in a clinical setting, such as during procedures or for short-term management of anxiety. Due to its potential for dependence and side effects, it is not available for purchase over the counter at pharmacies. Patients need a prescription from a qualified healthcare provider to obtain this medication.

In summary, if diuretics are not working for your edema, it is crucial to consult with your healthcare provider to evaluate the underlying cause, review your medication regimen, and consider potential dietary modifications. Adjustments to your treatment plan may be necessary to effectively manage your condition.

Similar Q&A

Managing Edema: Effective Strategies Beyond Diuretics for Relief

Currently, I have edema affecting only the left side of my body, including the chest, arm, and lower extremities. After a hospital examination, the following causes were identified: (1) kidney disease - proteinuria or nephrotic syndrome in the urine. (2) Endocrine disease - hypot...


Dr. Gao Jiankai reply Internal Medicine
Hello, thank you for your question. Please first confirm with your physician whether proteinuria and hypothyroidism are currently being treated with medication. If so, discuss with your physician the reasons why the edema is not improving. Generally, treatment requires some time ...

[Read More] Managing Edema: Effective Strategies Beyond Diuretics for Relief


Can Diuretics Be Reduced for Heart Failure Patients?

Hello Dr. Wu, my grandfather is a heart failure patient and the doctor has prescribed diuretics (such as furosemide). I would like to ask: 1. Are there times when diuretics can be discontinued? 2. Recently, my grandfather's calves have been unusually dry in the morning aft...


Dr. Wu Xueming reply Cardiology
If there is no edema in the lower extremities and the skin appears dry, the diuretic dosage can be reduced or discontinued.

[Read More] Can Diuretics Be Reduced for Heart Failure Patients?


Managing Blood Pressure and Edema in a 76-Year-Old Patient

Hello Dr. Wu: My mother is 76 years old and has been taking Adalat 30 mg for many years. Recently, she has experienced edema in her lower extremities. We switched her to one Zanidip (Lercanidipine) 10 mg at bedtime and one Fluitran (Furosemide) 2 mg during the day. Although the l...


Dr. Xiao Yongxun reply Internal Medicine
Dear Miss Hsiao-Fen: 1. Your mother is taking Adalat® (30mg; generic name Nifedipine), which is a calcium channel blocker. Long-term use can lead to sodium and fluid retention, resulting in edema. It is recommended to switch to Zanidip® (10mg; generic name Lercanidipine) and Flu...

[Read More] Managing Blood Pressure and Edema in a 76-Year-Old Patient


Understanding Why Diuretics Are Essential for Patients with Dilated Cardiomyopathy

Patients with dilated cardiomyopathy are prescribed diuretics to help reduce fluid overload and alleviate the burden on the heart. By decreasing the volume of fluid in the body, diuretics can help lower blood pressure and reduce symptoms such as shortness of breath and swelling, ...


Dr. Chen Qingbin reply Physical Fitness
Hello, yes; diuretics can reduce the workload on the heart. Director of the Health Education Department, Chen Ching-Pin.

[Read More] Understanding Why Diuretics Are Essential for Patients with Dilated Cardiomyopathy


Related FAQ

Medication Treatment

(Pharmacology)

Diuresis

(Urology)

Medication Safety

(Pharmacology)

Hypertension Medication

(Cardiology)

Drug Side Effects

(Pharmacology)

Weight Loss Products

(Pharmacology)

Medication

(Urology)

Gynecological Medications

(Pharmacology)

Erection

(Pharmacology)

Drug Interactions

(Urology)