Navigating Dual Psychiatric Care: Is It Okay to See Two Doctors?

Therapeutic window

Dear Doctor: I have been troubled by this issue for a long time.
I have depression and have been undergoing treatment for almost a year.
However, I am receiving treatment from two different doctors at two different hospitals.
I feel guilty towards both doctors, as it seems like I don't trust their expertise.
I apologize for this, but I cannot avoid seeing either of them.
Both doctors discuss my condition and medications together, which gives me a sense of security and support.
I only dare to seek help from them and trust them, but I feel very sorry for my actions.
I also hesitate to bring this up with my doctors.
From a doctor's perspective, is what I am doing right or wrong?

You Mei Mei, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/05/14

Dr. Wang Chongren reply Psychiatry

Dear Dr.
Wang Chong-Ren of the Tainan Hospital, Department of Psychiatry, Executive Yuan Health Department:
It is common for patients to consult several physicians during the initial stages of treatment.
However, seeing two doctors for the same issue for nearly a year may reflect a bottleneck in the therapeutic relationship, possibly related to the sense of security and support you mentioned in consulting two physicians.
Since both doctors will discuss your condition together, you may want to bring up your concerns with the one who is more frequently involved in psychotherapy.
If that is not feasible, consider seeking help from a psychologist to address your concerns through the therapeutic process.

Wishing you good health and all the best from the Tainan Hospital!

Reply Date: 2005/05/14

More Info

Navigating the complexities of mental health treatment can be challenging, especially when it comes to the question of whether it is appropriate to see two different psychiatrists simultaneously. Your feelings of guilt and concern about not trusting your doctors are understandable, but it's essential to recognize that your mental health journey is unique, and there are valid reasons for seeking multiple perspectives.

First and foremost, it is not uncommon for patients to seek care from more than one psychiatrist, especially in the early stages of treatment or when they are exploring different therapeutic approaches. Many individuals find comfort in having multiple sources of support, particularly when dealing with conditions like depression, where feelings of isolation and uncertainty can be prevalent. The fact that both of your doctors are discussing your case and collaborating on your treatment is a positive sign that they are working together to ensure you receive the best care possible.

However, it is crucial to consider the potential drawbacks of dual treatment. Having two different treatment plans can sometimes lead to confusion regarding medication management, therapy approaches, and overall treatment goals. It may also create a situation where the communication between your doctors is not as seamless as it could be, which might affect the continuity of your care. Therefore, while it is okay to seek multiple opinions, it is essential to strive for a more unified approach to your treatment.

If you feel comfortable, consider discussing your situation with one of your psychiatrists. Open communication is vital in any therapeutic relationship, and your doctors would likely appreciate your honesty. They can help you weigh the pros and cons of continuing with both treatments and may even suggest a plan to transition to a single provider if that is in your best interest. This conversation could also help alleviate any feelings of guilt you have about seeing both doctors, as they may reassure you that seeking help is a sign of strength, not distrust.

Regarding your concerns about medication and its effects on cognitive function, it is essential to understand that while some antidepressants can have side effects, they do not typically cause permanent cognitive decline. Medications like Efexor (Venlafaxine), Zoloft (Sertraline), and others can sometimes lead to feelings of sluggishness or cognitive fog, especially when starting or adjusting dosages. It is crucial to communicate these side effects to your psychiatrist, as they can help adjust your treatment plan to minimize these issues.

Lastly, if you are feeling uncertain about the effectiveness of your treatment, it is vital to address this with your doctor. Mental health treatment often requires patience and ongoing assessment, and it is normal to have periods of doubt. Regular follow-ups and open discussions about your progress can help you and your psychiatrist make informed decisions about your care.

In conclusion, while it is acceptable to seek care from two psychiatrists, it is essential to consider the potential complications and strive for open communication with your healthcare providers. Your mental health is a priority, and ensuring that you have a cohesive treatment plan will ultimately support your journey toward recovery. Don't hesitate to reach out to your doctors and express your feelings; they are there to help you navigate this process.

Similar Q&A

Choosing Between Neurology and Psychiatry for Anxiety Treatment: Key Insights

Dear Dr. Yeh, I have a few questions to ask. 1. Both neurology and psychiatry encompass the treatment of "anxiety disorders." In your expert opinion, which specialty should one consult to avoid misunderstanding and mistakenly visiting the wrong department, thus wasti...

Dr. Ye Boshou reply Neurology
1. Mild anxiety disorders can be easily managed by either neurology or psychiatry, but severe anxiety that disrupts daily life should be addressed by a psychiatrist, and psychological counseling may be necessary. 2. Whether personality traits and psychological states evolve into ...

Navigating Unwritten Rules in Psychiatric Care: Your Options Explained

In psychiatry, there seems to be an unwritten rule that the first psychiatrist you see becomes your primary provider for ongoing treatment. In other words, if you are dissatisfied and wish to switch doctors, it depends on whether the psychiatrist is willing to have an open conver...

Dr. Ding Shuyan reply Psychiatry
Hello, because you have been seeing the same physician for a long time, this physician should theoretically have a better understanding of your condition. Other doctors in the same hospital may be less familiar with you and might be more hesitant to change the prescriptions made ...

Navigating Your First Psychiatric Appointment: What to Expect and How to Prepare

Hello, doctor. Thank you for your detailed response to my concerns. Since I have never visited a psychiatrist before, I have some worries. If I have multiple mental health issues, how should I explain them? Should I provide a detailed account of each one? Additionally, what is th...

Dr. Ding Shuyan reply Psychiatry
Hello, it's definitely best to share all your concerns with the doctor. If you feel too nervous and forget to mention something, or if time is limited, you can always provide additional information during your next visit. It's normal to feel anxious about seeing a psych...

Navigating Long-Term Mental Health Care: Seeking New Solutions After 20 Years

I have been seeing a psychiatrist for nearly 20 years due to emotional instability, which causes me to talk to myself and isolate myself, often laughing alone. Although I have been treated at a specialized hospital, the doctors later told me that there were no alternative medicat...

Dr. Liao Dinglie reply Psychiatry
Hello, dear netizen: Over the past 20 years, there have been significant advancements in the pharmacological treatment of mental illnesses, particularly in the improvement of medication side effects. I believe you have had considerable communication with your physician regarding ...