Supporting a Friend Through Depression: Her Struggles

How to help a friend overcome depression?

I have a good friend (a 37-year-old Christian woman) who is very cautious and a perfectionist.
Previously, she was introduced to many potential partners, but none were successful.
Two years ago, she developed an admiration for a man several years younger than her in an English class.
It was evident from his conversations that she cared about him, but she insisted that she only felt a "burden" to evangelize him and did not see him as a marriage prospect.
In reality, their interactions were limited to class discussions and some exchanges, and she had been sharing her faith with him, but there was no romantic relationship as far as I know.

However, in the past month or two, my friend has often been in tears (over this man) and has even expressed suicidal thoughts.
When I asked her what was wrong, she said she didn't know.
She keeps emphasizing that it is a burden from God to evangelize this man and insists that we do not understand her.
She claims to feel a "chemical reaction" towards him, which she cannot explain.
Now that the English course has ended, she is too afraid to contact him (she has never called him), but she is trying to obtain his phone number and address, and has been inquiring about his colleagues to learn more about him, all while never mentioning him.
Given that she has been so upset and crying, and since we are unclear about his feelings, we called his company to inquire about him and to express my friend's situation.
The man found it very abrupt and questioned why we were reaching out to him.
He responded coldly and mentioned that he already has a girlfriend.

1.
How can we help her? We suggested that she might be experiencing depression and could seek medical help or counseling, but she insists she is not sick and does not need it (she had obsessive-compulsive disorder a few years ago and improved with medication).

2.
She instructed us not to contact this man, but in our pursuit of the truth, we have already spoken to him.
Should we keep this matter hidden? Please help us understand how to assist her, as we truly do not know what to do.

judy, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/07/16

Dr. Lin Yanhong reply Psychiatry

Hello Judy, I am a medical consultation service representative from the "Taiwan e-Hospital" website.
Since Dr.
Lin Yan-Hong has left our hospital, he is unable to answer your related questions.
We apologize for any inconvenience this may cause.

Reply Date: 2005/07/16

More Info

Supporting a friend who is struggling with depression can be a challenging yet crucial task. Your friend's situation seems complex, as she is dealing with emotional turmoil related to her feelings for a man, alongside her mental health struggles. Here are some insights and suggestions on how to approach this situation effectively.

Understanding Her Struggles
1. Recognizing Depression: It’s important to understand that depression can manifest in various ways, including persistent sadness, emotional outbursts, and feelings of hopelessness. Your friend’s tears and expressions of suicidal thoughts are serious indicators that she may be experiencing depression. Even if she insists she doesn’t need help, it’s essential to approach the situation with empathy and understanding.

2. The Role of Perfectionism: Your friend’s perfectionist tendencies may contribute to her feelings of inadequacy and despair. Perfectionism often leads to unrealistic expectations, which can result in disappointment and self-criticism. This can exacerbate her emotional struggles, especially when she feels she has failed in her relationships or personal goals.

3. Spiritual Beliefs: As a Christian, your friend may feel a strong sense of duty to fulfill what she perceives as God’s expectations. This can create additional pressure and feelings of guilt if she believes she is not living up to those expectations. It’s vital to respect her beliefs while gently encouraging her to seek help.

How to Help
1. Encourage Professional Help: While your friend may deny needing help, it’s crucial to gently encourage her to speak with a mental health professional. You can suggest that therapy could provide her with a safe space to explore her feelings and develop coping strategies. Emphasize that seeking help is a sign of strength, not weakness.

2. Be a Supportive Listener: Sometimes, just being there to listen can make a significant difference. Allow her to express her feelings without judgment. Validate her emotions by acknowledging how difficult her situation is. Phrases like “It’s understandable to feel this way given what you’re going through” can help her feel heard.

3. Avoid Pressuring Her: While it’s important to encourage her to seek help, avoid pressuring her into it. Instead, let her know that you are there for her whenever she feels ready to talk or seek help. This approach respects her autonomy while still providing support.

4. Respect Her Boundaries: Regarding your inquiry about contacting the man she is interested in, it’s essential to respect her wishes. If she has explicitly asked you not to reach out to him, it’s crucial to honor that request. Breaching her trust could lead to further distress and feelings of betrayal.

5. Educate Yourself: Familiarize yourself with the signs of depression and effective ways to support someone dealing with it. Resources such as books, articles, or even support groups can provide valuable insights into how to navigate this situation.

6. Encourage Healthy Outlets: Suggest activities that might help her cope with her feelings, such as journaling, engaging in creative pursuits, or participating in physical activities. These outlets can provide her with a way to express her emotions constructively.

7. Monitor for Crisis Situations: If your friend expresses suicidal thoughts or intentions, it’s critical to take these seriously. Encourage her to reach out to a crisis hotline or a mental health professional immediately. If you believe she is in immediate danger, do not hesitate to contact emergency services.

Conclusion
Supporting a friend through depression requires patience, empathy, and understanding. While you may feel overwhelmed by her emotional state, remember that your role is to provide support without taking on the responsibility of fixing her problems. Encourage her to seek professional help, be a compassionate listener, and respect her boundaries. By doing so, you can help her navigate this challenging time while also taking care of your own emotional well-being.

Similar Q&A

Supporting a Friend with Depression: Navigating Emotional Challenges

Hello Doctor, I have a very close friend who told me that she was diagnosed with depression. I am very worried about her. She once mentioned that I shouldn't say things like "cheer up" to someone with depression, so I am very careful with my words because I fear th...

Dr. Qiu Junda reply Psychiatry
Hello: I'm glad to see your concern for your friend's condition. Here are some suggestions: 1. Since your friend has previously sought medical attention, you could accompany them to their appointment for consultation. This way, you can also ask how you can support and a...

How to Support a Friend Struggling with Depression Without Overstepping

My friend has mild depression, but her condition seems to have worsened recently. Initially, she only expressed thoughts of wanting to die verbally, but a few days ago, we discovered scars on her arms from cutting. Additionally, her grandmother passed away last week, and she was ...

Dr. Chen Meizhu reply Psychiatry
Hello: Based on your description, your friend is indeed experiencing a worsening of depression and may currently be at risk of self-harm. It is crucial to provide immediate and effective assistance by facilitating medical help. If accessing medical care is difficult, it would be ...

Coping with a Loved One's Depression: Tips for Support and Understanding

Hello, doctor: I have a friend who is suffering from depression, and I really don't know how to interact with them. Currently, it's impossible for me to leave them, but being around them is really exhausting! I feel like giving up everything and just walking away. Thank...

Dr. Chen Jiongxu reply Psychiatry
Hello! Thank you for your hard work! You care about your friend but are unsure how to interact with him. I suggest accompanying him to his medical appointments and asking the doctor about how to interact with someone with depression during the visit. You can also share your inter...

How to Support a Friend with Depression from Afar

Hello Doctor: I have a friend who is suffering from depression. He was receiving treatment while studying in Taiwan for about six months, but he didn't recover and graduated before returning to Malaysia. However, the hospital in Malaysia is far from him, and he doesn't ...

Dr. Qiu Junda reply Psychiatry
Hello. It's great to see that you continue to care about your friend's situation. I suggest you encourage him to continue seeking medical treatment in Malaysia without interruption. Additionally, you could send some information about combating depression to help him. It...