Shoulder joint sounds
Dear Dr.
Shi,
I would like to ask you a question regarding my right shoulder.
I suffered a comminuted fracture of my right clavicle in a car accident last June, which required surgery to stabilize it with a plate.
My recovery has been good; X-rays show no visible cracks, and I have full range of motion in my right shoulder.
My attending physician has also said that I can return to normal activities.
However, I am still experiencing some issues with my right shoulder joint that have been troubling me, and I hope you can help clarify them.
Since childhood, whenever I reach behind my back and swing my arm back and forth, my shoulder would make a cracking sound.
However, I have noticed that since the accident, this cracking sound has become more pronounced.
For example, when I let my arm hang naturally and rotate my palm side to side, or when I raise my arm overhead and move it side to side, the shoulder joint makes a cracking sound at almost any angle of movement, accompanied by a slight tingling and aching sensation.
Although this does not affect my daily activities, during exercise, if I swing my right arm quickly or with force, I feel that my right shoulder joint seems off, causing some soreness and tingling, which makes me hesitant to exert myself.
As a result, my right arm has not yet regained its pre-injury strength.
I asked my attending physician about this, and he mentioned that it could be the sound of ligaments sliding over bone, and that it might improve after the plate is removed.
However, I am still quite worried and wonder if there might have been damage to the joint during the accident.
Is this situation normal, or should I seek further medical attention? Would heat therapy or pain relief patches help improve the condition?
Thank you for your assistance!
Fenghen, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2006/02/13
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Your attending physician's response is correct; if there are sounds during joint movement without pain, it is not a concern.
However, if an injury occurs and it does not involve the joint surface of the shoulder, there should be no issues.
After a clavicle fracture surgery, if it has healed, the plate can be removed.
As for whether the sounds will disappear, it is difficult to say.
Additionally, using heat therapy or adhesive patches can help alleviate soreness symptoms.
Reply Date: 2006/02/13
More Info
After a significant injury like a car accident, it is not uncommon for patients to experience lingering symptoms such as joint noises, pain, and discomfort in the affected area. In your case, the right shoulder, which underwent surgery for a comminuted fracture, is now producing sounds and sensations that are concerning you. Let's break down the potential causes and solutions for your situation.
Understanding Joint Noises
The sounds you are hearing from your shoulder joint, often described as "popping" or "cracking," can be attributed to several factors:
1. Ligament Movement: As your doctor mentioned, the noise could be due to ligaments or tendons sliding over bony structures in the shoulder. This is often harmless, especially if it is not accompanied by pain.
2. Joint Mechanics: After an injury, the mechanics of the shoulder joint may change. Scar tissue can form, and the alignment of the joint may be altered, leading to abnormal sounds during movement.
3. Rotator Cuff Issues: Given your history of shoulder injury, there is a possibility of rotator cuff involvement. This group of muscles and tendons stabilizes the shoulder and allows for a wide range of motion. If these structures are inflamed or injured, they can contribute to both pain and noise during movement.
4. Osteoarthritis: Although less likely given your age and the recent nature of your injury, joint noises can also be a sign of early degenerative changes in the joint, such as osteoarthritis.
Pain and Discomfort
The sensations of pain and tingling you are experiencing, especially during certain movements or activities, may indicate:
- Inflammation: Post-injury inflammation can lead to pain and discomfort, particularly when engaging in activities that stress the shoulder.
- Impingement: If the space in the shoulder joint is narrowed (as noted in some X-ray reports), it can lead to impingement syndrome, where tendons are compressed during arm movements, causing pain and noise.
- Weakness: The inability to fully regain strength in your shoulder may be due to disuse or improper rehabilitation post-surgery.
Recommendations
1. Physical Therapy: Engaging in a structured physical therapy program can be immensely beneficial. A physical therapist can provide targeted exercises to strengthen the shoulder, improve range of motion, and address any imbalances.
2. Imaging Studies: If the noises and pain persist or worsen, consider discussing further imaging studies, such as an MRI, with your physician. This can help assess the integrity of the rotator cuff and other soft tissues around the shoulder.
3. Pain Management: Over-the-counter anti-inflammatory medications can help manage pain and reduce inflammation. Heat therapy can also be soothing, especially before engaging in exercises.
4. Activity Modification: While it is important to remain active, be mindful of the movements that exacerbate your symptoms. Gradually increase the intensity of your activities and avoid heavy lifting or overhead movements until you feel more stable.
5. Follow-Up with Your Doctor: If you continue to experience significant discomfort or if the noises become more pronounced, it is advisable to follow up with your orthopedic surgeon or a sports medicine specialist. They can provide a comprehensive evaluation and determine if further intervention is necessary.
Conclusion
In summary, while joint noises after an injury can be concerning, they are often benign, especially if not accompanied by significant pain. However, given your history and ongoing symptoms, it is essential to take a proactive approach to your rehabilitation. Engaging in physical therapy, managing pain effectively, and maintaining open communication with your healthcare provider will be key to your recovery. Remember, every individual's healing process is unique, and patience is crucial as you work towards regaining full function of your shoulder.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Shoulder Noises: Causes and Non-Surgical Treatment Options
If there is a popping sound in the shoulder when raising or lowering the arm, and this has been occurring for several months, it could be due to various reasons such as tendonitis, bursitis, or a labral tear. These conditions can cause the tendons or ligaments to catch on the bon...
Dr. Li Yongheng reply Orthopedics
Hello, if there is noise when moving your shoulder up and down and you have no previous history of injury, it is usually harmless. The cause may be related to poor tendon and ligament elasticity, insufficient muscle strength, or inadequate support and protection. It is recommende...[Read More] Understanding Shoulder Noises: Causes and Non-Surgical Treatment Options
Understanding Shoulder Sounds and Muscle Changes After Sports Injury
Last month, while playing basketball, I lost my balance and fell backward, landing on both hands. It hurt at the moment, but the pain subsided after a while. Later, I noticed that when I raise my right arm, there is a strange noise coming from my upper arm and shoulder (I can...
Dr. Zhou Jianwen reply Rehabilitation
Hello, sir: Based on the symptoms you described, it could be tendonitis, muscle inflammation, or muscle spasms. A definitive diagnosis requires an actual clinical evaluation. I recommend visiting a nearby rehabilitation clinic for further examination and treatment. Wishing you a ...[Read More] Understanding Shoulder Sounds and Muscle Changes After Sports Injury
Understanding Joint Noises: Causes and Solutions for Common Issues
I sometimes hear sounds in my hand joints (shoulder and elbow) when bending and straightening. My left knee, which was previously injured (bruised from a fall), makes a grinding noise when I walk or run. I'm not sure if this indicates any problems and if it can be improved. ...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
It is normal for joints to make sounds; this may be the sound of tendons sliding over the joint. If it does not cause pain or affect joint function, there is generally no cause for concern.[Read More] Understanding Joint Noises: Causes and Solutions for Common Issues
Understanding Shoulder and Elbow Noises During Push-Ups
Doctor: I apologize for the previous question regarding the elbow; I should have included the shoulder. When doing push-ups, both my right shoulder and right elbow make a popping sound, but there is no pain. I'm a bit concerned, so I would like to ask what this might indicat...
Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello, Zhang: It is normal for joints to make sounds during activity; this is caused by the friction between cartilage and tendons or ligaments. If there is no pain, there is no need for concern or treatment. Some individuals have a habit of creating friction sounds in their fing...[Read More] Understanding Shoulder and Elbow Noises During Push-Ups
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Shoulder Joint Pain(Neurology)
Shoulder And Neck(Orthopedics)
Rotator Cuff Tear(Orthopedics)
Shoulder Pain(Rehabilitation)
Scapular Fracture(Orthopedics)
Acromioclavicular Joint Dislocation(Orthopedics)
Tendonitis(Orthopedics)
Sports Injury(Orthopedics)
Left Shoulder Bone Pain(Neurology)